Students support socialism but think like capitalist

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

alcoholbob

Diamond Member
May 24, 2005
6,390
470
126
I'm against socialism! I should be able to kill anyone and take their stuff, laissez-fair and all. I think the guy doing the interview is the socialist, trying to steal IQ points because he's obviously impoverished in that regard.

I've seen greater persuasive arguments in dog vomit.

Is there really that big of a difference between property taxes and collective ownership of land? In the former the moment you can't afford to pay it's taken from you anyway.
 

cytg111

Lifer
Mar 17, 2008
26,792
16,065
136
Interesting video, the students all say they favor the idea of socialism and spreading the wealth around, as one put it there’s a lot of excess in America. But asked if they would be willing to share part of their gpa with students with less high of a gpa the breaks screech, the responses are all "no I worked hard for it, it’s mine". You can see them visually rethinking their world right there in front of the camera, good stuff.


UglyCasanova : His mind constantly telling him that what is heart is forcing him to do is wrong. That black spot on the inside that just wont go away. Pity.
 

cytg111

Lifer
Mar 17, 2008
26,792
16,065
136
You caught me! I was projecting

The point was that when someone achieves something through hard work, they aren't generally happy about sharing it. I can identify with this because it's the question I always ask when we come up with a new program or group that needs help. How many hours of my labor are going to be taken from me? I'm not talking about investments or passive income, I'm talking about the actual hours I have to work to support those less fortunate than I am.

Yea, cause if you were fucked up with an open gun shot wound to the head that is how you would think ... I get it.
If you could lift your fucking IQ one point and tell me, would it matter if you paid 99% tax if you still had the same purchasing power that you have right now? For your class segment, how well are you off now compared to 20 years ago, 50, 100? Why do you think that is? Cause the King stuffed all the silvers in his coffers and never invested in infrastructure and education? (like Drumph is doing..)

And how many hours do I need to work to help out those less fortunate than me... OR how many more hours must I work so Trump can the next big one on Iran?
Fuck it right? MORE, BIGGER BOMBS AND FUCK THE LESS FORTUNATE ... #MAGA

Idiots.

Or just shot in the head.
 

Vic

Elite Member
Jun 12, 2001
50,422
14,337
136
Is there really that big of a difference between property taxes and collective ownership of land? In the former the moment you can't afford to pay it's taken from you anyway.
Assuming this is a serious post, yes, there is a huge difference. Property taxes are what pays for many of the public services that are essential in providing value to the private ownership of land. Like for the county recorders office where the owners deed to that land is safely kept should others try to make a claim to it, for the law enforcement in case others might try to seize the land by force, and for the road that provides the land with egress to the outside. And also for the public schools that allow for your neighbor's children to gain the basic skills to be able to find gainful employment later in life, and thus be less likely to resort to stealing your property.
Without these things, the owner's land would be greatly diminished in value, likely by far more than the amount of the taxation, as we see in areas where the above public services are inadequate. There is no such thing a free lunch.
 

cytg111

Lifer
Mar 17, 2008
26,792
16,065
136
Interesting video, the students all say they favor the idea of socialism and spreading the wealth around, as one put it there’s a lot of excess in America. But asked if they would be willing to share part of their gpa with students with less high of a gpa the breaks screech, the responses are all "no I worked hard for it, it’s mine". You can see them visually rethinking their world right there in front of the camera, good stuff.



Uuuuuuuuuuuuuh duuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuh

Heres an interesting article

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/income-share-agreements-student-debt-111904922.html

"How a new financing model could fix America’s broken student loan system"
 

Blackjack200

Lifer
May 28, 2007
15,995
1,688
126
Uuuuuuuuuuuuuh duuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuh

Heres an interesting article

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/income-share-agreements-student-debt-111904922.html

"How a new financing model could fix America’s broken student loan system"

I honestly think this is the way to do it:

1. US Government repays all outstanding student debt.
2. US Government no longer guarantees student debt.
3. Student debt can be discharged in bankruptcy just like consumer debt with no recourse to the lender.
4. State schools and community colleges are recapitalized by the federal government and the states. State schools are low cost (~5k/year tuition) with admissions standards. Community colleges are free with no admissions standards. Completion of an associates degree at the community college guarantees acceptance at the state school.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarthKyrie

Majes

Golden Member
Apr 8, 2008
1,164
148
106
It's interesting that so many people want Conservatives to come up with solutions to things plaguing the current economic system...

Conservatives like the current system, and they fight to protect it. The only modifications Conservatives seem to make occur when there is a huge crisis or when they figure out how to personally or politically take advantage of the system. So no one should be shocked that Conservatives don't have any proposals or solutions to something that they don't see as a problem.

Can you work hard in this country and make a living? Own a house? Have a family? Buy the things you need? The answer is yes. The system currently supports those that are willing to work hard and smart. Those people can flourish in this economy. I don't have an awful lot of pity for those who aren't willing to work for a better life.

On the other hand I fully realize that business in this country is so incredibly good at selling to people and in many cases taking advantage of people. I bet everyone here has been swindled or taken advantage of in some monetary transaction.

A free market is a dangerous one and that's why I try to be open minded about plans like the one Jaskalas outlined earlier in this thread. He has some really awesome ideas to protect people from the sharks that surface in capitalist societies.

But so many of you see the problems in this system and simply blame conservatives instead of proposing solutions. Please keep in mind that conservatives like the current system so it's more a question of whether or not you can convince them it's worth changing...
 

Jhhnn

IN MEMORIAM
Nov 11, 1999
62,365
14,686
136
It's interesting that so many people want Conservatives to come up with solutions to things plaguing the current economic system...

Conservatives like the current system, and they fight to protect it. The only modifications Conservatives seem to make occur when there is a huge crisis or when they figure out how to personally or politically take advantage of the system. So no one should be shocked that Conservatives don't have any proposals or solutions to something that they don't see as a problem.

Can you work hard in this country and make a living? Own a house? Have a family? Buy the things you need? The answer is yes. The system currently supports those that are willing to work hard and smart. Those people can flourish in this economy. I don't have an awful lot of pity for those who aren't willing to work for a better life.

On the other hand I fully realize that business in this country is so incredibly good at selling to people and in many cases taking advantage of people. I bet everyone here has been swindled or taken advantage of in some monetary transaction.

A free market is a dangerous one and that's why I try to be open minded about plans like the one Jaskalas outlined earlier in this thread. He has some really awesome ideas to protect people from the sharks that surface in capitalist societies.

But so many of you see the problems in this system and simply blame conservatives instead of proposing solutions. Please keep in mind that conservatives like the current system so it's more a question of whether or not you can convince them it's worth changing...

That's bullshit. A vote for Trump was a vote protesting the system. That's beyond obvious.
 

Majes

Golden Member
Apr 8, 2008
1,164
148
106
That's bullshit. A vote for Trump was a vote protesting the system. That's beyond obvious.

Lol... Maybe in other areas? But economically what did the conservatives do? Back to tax cuts, back to trickle down.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,519
20,142
146
Funny how liberals in the US who advocate socialism always point to lily-white Nordic countries but don't mention any of the successful mostly brown countries when espousing that same socialism, and they definitely don't want to make the necessary cultural/economic changes that allows what they perceive to be socialism in Nordic countries in order for it to actually work in the USA.




Why are the Nordic countries ranked as the world’s best countries to live in?

Allow me to spell this out for you:
Because. They. Are. Not. Advocating. For. Socialism.

Just a few social policies. You know. The fucking ones the Nordic countries have.

But keep beating the ever loving fucking shit out of that socialist strawman. It's working for the base.

giphy.gif
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarthKyrie

thraashman

Lifer
Apr 10, 2000
11,112
1,587
126
If GPA were comparable to money in this fashion, then GPA under the current economic system the US has would allow those with the highest GPAs to plunder the grades of lower GPA students to add to their own to create a GPA so high it's use is literally implausible. Those highest GPA students would then tell the C students that the D and F students are the real reason the C students grades are suffering. Meanwhile those A students would be getting the easiest tests to earn A's and A+s and A+++++s, and the C, D, and F students would get harder and harder tests and sometimes no tests at all that still counted against their grade.


Socialism would say I have a C in the class maybe I didn't put the effort in, maybe I was suffering depression and missed class, or maybe I just didn't pick up the material as quickly as others. Then you have an A in the class, perhaps you put in great effort, perhaps you guessed lucky on every test so far, perhaps the teacher just likes you. Now we take the same test, we get the same questions right and wrong, we get the same grade on that test. No matter where we stood before. The current system says that in that same scenario, you get an A on that test because you already have an A in the class and it would bring down the class avereage, even though you actually skipped the test. In essence you're "too good to fail" this test. While I get a D on the test because I was already doing poorly, even though I didn't miss a single question, because you with your A convinced enough other students I cheated because I was doing poorly before. And then those other students all chanted "make this class great again" and committed violent acts against the student that transferred into the class 3 weeks after it began.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DarthKyrie

FelixDeCat

Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
31,259
2,784
126

Repost.

Bernie Sanders is a psychopathic nutjob with ZERO chance of winning even a job as dogcatcher. Nobody is for bernie.

Also Nordic countries arent $21.5 trillion in debt and getting deeper by the the second like we are. They also pay huge income tax, we dont pay that kind of tax for dumbassed socialist programs and we wont volunteer for that shit either.

Socialism is wrong.

Its wrong for nordic countries, its wrong for capitalist loving Americans and its wrong for everyone on Earth.

Nothing is free for anyone. Nothing.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: IJTSSG

brycejones

Lifer
Oct 18, 2005
30,286
31,329
136
Repost.

Bernie Sanders is a psychopathic nutjob with ZERO chance of winning even a job as dogcatcher. Nobody is for bernie.

Also Nordic countries arent $21.5 trillion in debt and getting deeper by the the second like we are. They also pay huge income tax, we dont pay that kind of tax for dumbassed socialist programs and we wont volunteer for that shit either.

Socialism is wrong.

Its wrong for nordic countries, its wrong for capitalist loving Americans and its wrong for everyone on Earth.

Nothing is free for anyone. Nothing.

Poor Felix his sensitive eyes have trouble being shown the facts. The rest is just mindless ranting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Meghan54

ivwshane

Lifer
May 15, 2000
33,738
17,390
136
Repost.

Bernie Sanders is a psychopathic nutjob with ZERO chance of winning even a job as dogcatcher. Nobody is for bernie.

Also Nordic countries arent $21.5 trillion in debt and getting deeper by the the second like we are. They also pay huge income tax, we dont pay that kind of tax for dumbassed socialist programs and we wont volunteer for that shit either.

Socialism is wrong.

Its wrong for nordic countries, its wrong for capitalist loving Americans and its wrong for everyone on Earth.

Nothing is free for anyone. Nothing.

Compelling/eye roll
 
  • Like
Reactions: Meghan54