Space Oddity, recorded by Commander Chris Hadfield on the International Space Station

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

cbrunny

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 2007
6,791
406
126
Billions of Canadian money, American, EU money , years of building this worthless tin can and what we get for it after all this time, a guy wasting his time playing a guitar that probably cost $2 000 000 to send up there. Hadfield should be ashamed of himself all the agencies involved in the space station should be ashamed.

This isn't even space exploration like some of you mentioned it's just a hunk of metal orbiting the earth and costing billions. If they spend that money on rovers and send them to planets that would be space exploration. The ISS is just a giant jobs program.

LOL! Hilarious.
 

Brovane

Diamond Member
Dec 18, 2001
6,370
2,577
136
Billions of Canadian money, American, EU money , years of building this worthless tin can and what we get for it after all this time, a guy wasting his time playing a guitar that probably cost $2 000 000 to send up there. Hadfield should be ashamed of himself all the agencies involved in the space station should be ashamed.

This isn't even space exploration like some of you mentioned it's just a hunk of metal orbiting the earth and costing billions. If they spend that money on rovers and send them to planets that would be space exploration. The ISS is just a giant jobs program.

Here is some of just the 2012 research on the ISS.

http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/research/news/2012_highlights.html

Oh Yes the astronauts do not work 24x7 when they are up there. They have day's off and also overall downtime.
 

datalink7

Lifer
Jan 23, 2001
16,765
6
81
Billions of Canadian money, American, EU money , years of building this worthless tin can and what we get for it after all this time, a guy wasting his time playing a guitar that probably cost $2 000 000 to send up there. Hadfield should be ashamed of himself all the agencies involved in the space station should be ashamed.

This isn't even space exploration like some of you mentioned it's just a hunk of metal orbiting the earth and costing billions. If they spend that money on rovers and send them to planets that would be space exploration. The ISS is just a giant jobs program.

Your ignorance is astounding in multiple ways.

First, by stating that "what we get" from the ISS is a guy playing a guitar. There is a lot of research happening on the station. It isn't just people playing music.

Second, assuming that government money went towards making this music video. He most likely made it in his off time. Government employees are allowed to have off time, right?

Third, if you were really concerned about "useless wastes of money", you'd stop posting, cancel your Internet, and donate the money saved towards a charity. But you don't really care that much, do you?
 

unokitty

Diamond Member
Jan 5, 2012
3,346
1
0
Astronaut-Band-Flash-FM09.jpg


Hatfield has played in the Astronaut Band for about 13 years now.

Personally, I think that he is one of the better things happening at NASA.

Uno
 
Last edited:

SlowSpyder

Lifer
Jan 12, 2005
17,305
1,002
126
Billions of Canadian money, American, EU money , years of building this worthless tin can and what we get for it after all this time, a guy wasting his time playing a guitar that probably cost $2 000 000 to send up there. Hadfield should be ashamed of himself all the agencies involved in the space station should be ashamed.

This isn't even space exploration like some of you mentioned it's just a hunk of metal orbiting the earth and costing billions. If they spend that money on rovers and send them to planets that would be space exploration. The ISS is just a giant jobs program.


http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/...-rock-star...-and-Bowie-isnt-complaining.html


The Canadian astronaut has become the first rock star in space, posting an astonishing video of himself playing guitar and singing in zero gravity aboard the International Space Station. The song, appropriately, is David Bowie’s Space Oddity, with music recorded on earth and vocals recorded in space. As the astronaut bobs weightlessly around singing “here I am, sitting in a tin can far above the world”, we see our big, beautiful planet looming behind him. The video would have cost a small fortune to shoot in a studio but presumably just took the singing spaceman a couple of spare hours with a handicam.


It doesn't sound like it was a big costly project. I have no issue with them having a little fun when you're up there for days, weeks, maybe even months at a time. Besides, I nef at work all the time.
 

KeithTalent

Elite Member | Administrator | No Lifer
Administrator
Nov 30, 2005
50,231
118
116
Yes yes, it's "badass"...a 720p (in this day and age?) video of a guy lipsyncing, some great shots of Earth, neither of which I can't already find on Youtube.

Don't get me wrong, I'm all for space exploration, science, riding around in pressurized cans of air above the atmosphere...but WTF? if you've got the balls to ride up into space...sing the damn song yourself.

Like I said, your tax dollars at work.

Go away.


This was awesome! Loved it! :awe:

KT
 

darkewaffle

Diamond Member
Oct 7, 2005
8,152
1
81
Neato! I wonder if anyone loves their job as much as that guy. Also that shot of the 'wing' and the earth rotating beneath it was amazing, around 2:50-3:00.
 

DrPizza

Administrator Elite Member Goat Whisperer
Mar 5, 2001
49,601
167
111
www.slatebrookfarm.com
One of my students mentioned something about space. I said, "hey, speaking of space, check this out." It was toward the end of class, and I was already well ahead of where I had intended to get in the material. It was well received by students who recognized the song.

Billions of Canadian money, American, EU money , years of building this worthless tin can and what we get for it after all this time, a guy wasting his time playing a guitar that probably cost $2 000 000 to send up there. Hadfield should be ashamed of himself all the agencies involved in the space station should be ashamed.

This isn't even space exploration like some of you mentioned it's just a hunk of metal orbiting the earth and costing billions. If they spend that money on rovers and send them to planets that would be space exploration. The ISS is just a giant jobs program.

I'm a huge critic of manned space flight. If you look at the most important research that they're doing (linked to above), one major experiment is the Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer & the search for figuring out what the heck is dark matter. There's no specific reason for that experiment to be aboard the ISS, except to give them something to do. Except for research on the human body, there's very little, if any, research that requires an ISS to perform. It was mentioned that SpaceX makes it easier to retrieve science experiments. Well then, send an unmanned version of SpaceX up, perform experiments robotically, then bring it back. Again, no need for the middle man. Though, I'll admit that there are some areas of research that might be promising - bone density & possible solutions which might be applicable to persons aging on Earth.

Regardless though - this coming from a critic of manned space flight - your opinion is idiotic. That video was awesome, and if it inspires even one kid to pay more attention in science, it was worth it.
 

SphinxnihpS

Diamond Member
Feb 17, 2005
8,368
25
91
NASA is built on the foundation of dreams and art....and a little bit of military need

Looks like a perfect way to spend money in my opinion.

Until I have a flying car, they are nothing but high-altitude playboys.:mad:
 

Paratus

Lifer
Jun 4, 2004
17,629
15,814
146
One of my students mentioned something about space. I said, "hey, speaking of space, check this out." It was toward the end of class, and I was already well ahead of where I had intended to get in the material. It was well received by students who recognized the song.



I'm a huge critic of manned space flight. If you look at the most important research that they're doing (linked to above), one major experiment is the Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer & the search for figuring out what the heck is dark matter. There's no specific reason for that experiment to be aboard the ISS, except to give them something to do. Except for research on the human body, there's very little, if any, research that requires an ISS to perform. It was mentioned that SpaceX makes it easier to retrieve science experiments. Well then, send an unmanned version of SpaceX up, perform experiments robotically, then bring it back. Again, no need for the middle man. Though, I'll admit that there are some areas of research that might be promising - bone density & possible solutions which might be applicable to persons aging on Earth.

Regardless though - this coming from a critic of manned space flight - your opinion is idiotic. That video was awesome, and if it inspires even one kid to pay more attention in science, it was worth it.

One of the specific reasons AMS was designed to be on-board the ISS was the power requirements. It runs 2-3KW. Add in another KW or two to be a free flyer and you'd need to add something like the billion dollar Juno probe with 10+KW arrays to carry the already over budget AMS-2.

The ISS already had the power, attitude control, and comm systems to support such a payload.
 

olds

Elite Member
Mar 3, 2000
50,120
776
126
I was pretty disgusted by some of you guys feeding the trolls. I mean if you just ignore them they'll give up. But if there were no more troll here the forums would dry up.
So keep up the good work Yamada, OlafSicky and SphinxnihpS
 
Last edited:

AmdEmAll

Diamond Member
Aug 27, 2000
6,699
9
81
I was pretty disgusted by some of you guys feeding the trolls. I mean if you just ignore them they'll give up. But if there were no more troll here the forums would dry up.
So keep up the good work Yamada and OlafSicky.

You forgot SphinxnihpS

Make them all walk the plank!
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,851
31,340
146
Yes yes, it's "badass"...a 720p (in this day and age?) video of a guy lipsyncing, some great shots of Earth, neither of which I can't already find on Youtube.

Don't get me wrong, I'm all for space exploration, science, riding around in pressurized cans of air above the atmosphere...but WTF? if you've got the balls to ride up into space...sing the damn song yourself.

Like I said, your tax dollars at work.

did some one piss in your cheerios, kick your dog, and rub sand in your vagina all at once?
 

zinfamous

No Lifer
Jul 12, 2006
111,851
31,340
146
Billions of Canadian money, American, EU money , years of building this worthless tin can and what we get for it after all this time, a guy wasting his time playing a guitar that probably cost $2 000 000 to send up there. Hadfield should be ashamed of himself all the agencies involved in the space station should be ashamed.

This isn't even space exploration like some of you mentioned it's just a hunk of metal orbiting the earth and costing billions. If they spend that money on rovers and send them to planets that would be space exploration. The ISS is just a giant jobs program.


you will never be smart, useful, or important enough to do something as amazing as spending time in space.