Which one knows about the situation? The practical one or the care-free one? It really isn't natural for a person to be OK with this sort of situation. Also, you said that you've been with one for a year and a half now. Are you absolutely certain the other girl still feels the same way?
Oh, one more thing, not to come down on the mighty elite members of the board, but baffled, Red, and others, don't hijack this poor guy's thread to talk about the situation with ilikesprite. Doing so just brings the situation up for the rest of the board again, and that isn't necessary. If you really want to let this incident sink to the bottom, then take your discussion to PM. Regardless, it doesn't belong in Ramses's thread.
Ryan