William Gaatjes
Lifer
Whereas from previous threads, we know that society is the only thing keeping atheists from behaving like an asshole toward others, except that they didn't admit it.
It is called social structure. A hypothetical thought experiment :
When we would take a person of age 10 randomly out of for example your city. We place that person for the next 50 years isolated somewhere in a forest without radio, internet, books or any other human. Just enough knowledge about how to stay alive. When we come back after 50 years, what would be the behaviour ? That person would still recognize us but would not function in a modern social structure anymore. Religion was and is a handy tool for social structure. But unfortunately it can easily be abused. Just as easy as it is to feed an atheist with idea's of how people should live is it easy to feed someone religious with idea's how someone should live. Neither has to be right.
It is all about social structures, how do you behave towards one and other.
But as in all cases with religion, first there is someone who has a vision and then there are people who want power. Have you ever seen a religion where the people could decide what would happen and not the priest/iman/prophet/god ? Afcourse you can have some riot. But then there is always someone who has gods voice in his ear... Convenient is it not ?
It depends on by what kind of ground rules people are willing to live. With out social control, where everybody freely gives up some freedom to live together and take care of each other, the social structure will always breakdown. Excesses will appear, corruption, crime and so on. It is the strength and it is the weakness of cooperation. The chinese mention yin and yang, it is true.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yin_and_yang