I've never seen a guy and thought "Hot Damn, he's SEXXXAYY!" It just can't happen. I suppose, if asked and/or the question comes up, I could decide whether or not he is attractive to girls, but I'm not really a good judge of that, either.
But anyway, I'm, as mentioned before, a straight male.
And as for the question of "Make out with a fugly as hell lady or a hot guy?", my answer is: I'd shoot myself first.
😀