sex with under aged children is alright with the Jewish Talmud ?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Status
Not open for further replies.

JEDIYoda

Lifer
Jul 13, 2005
33,986
3,321
126
Do you believe a three year old can engage in sexual act like you quoted the Talmud states??

The problem with you Routan is you are single minded!
Did you even reads that link??
That link answers all your questions.
Come back and ask such a idiotic question after you read the link......
http://talmud.faithweb.com/articles/three.html
The Talmud Does Not Permit Sex With A Three Year Old

All you had to do is read and understand the link....
The Op when he started this thread did not understand the complexity of reading and understanding the Talmud! It`s obvious that you do not understand iether.
 
Last edited:

routan

Senior member
Sep 12, 2010
837
0
0
The problem with you Routan is you are single minded!
Did you even reads that link??
That link answers all your questions.
Come back and ask such a idiotic question after you read the link......
http://talmud.faithweb.com/articles/three.html
The Talmud Does Not Permit Sex With A Three Year Old

All you gad to do mis read the link....
The Op when he started this thread did not understand the complexity of reading and understanding the Talmud! It`s obvious that you do not understand iether.

You're not answering a simple question. I did not ask if it is permissible or not. I am asking whether you believe a 3 year old can engage in a sexual act?

Your words:
The same usage occurs in the passage in Talmud Avodah Zarah 37a. The Talmud states that at the age of three a girl is capable of participating in a sexual act. However, that act is not permissible. See also Jerusalem Talmud Ketuvot 1:2 (4b).
you're a fucking pervert
 

Karl Agathon

Golden Member
Sep 30, 2010
1,081
0
0
I dont beleive the OP is anti-semitic. However Routon hates Jews and anything having to do with Jewish people.
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
You're not answering a simple question. I did not ask if it is permissible or not. I am asking whether you believe a 3 year old can engage in a sexual act?

Your words:

you're a fucking pervert

It's not permissible, it's not like it's Islam where it's not only permissible but also encouraged per the prophet himself to go around fucking six year olds...

When you live in a glass house, don't cast fucking stones you retarded piece of sheit.
 

woolfe9999

Diamond Member
Mar 28, 2005
7,153
0
0
Thank you for defending me.
Of course i do not hate Jews. For me Jews are exactly the same kind of human as anybody else on this planet and should have a chance to live in peace and happiness. But i do not feel comfortable about the way AIPAC, ADL or John Hagee behave. Being pro war is not the way.

Whether or not you are anti-semitic, you are knowingly or unknowingly repeating anti-semitic tropes here. Anti-semites routinely distort, misinterpret or take Talmudic passages out of context. Your OP has been debunked already by Jediyoda. This article addresses pretty thoroughly various accusations about the Talmud, including the one described in your OP. In sum, it is taken out of context and does not mean what you think it means.

http://www.adl.org/presrele/asus_12/the_talmud.pdf

That said, I am not a fan of any religion and place little stock in ancient texts, be it the Talmud, the Koran or the New Testament. Needless to say, attitudes and views of those times were not in alignmenth modern values and would be considered distinctly politically incorrect, if not barbaric, today.

PS: oh right, you are not fond of the ADL. That and your OP are pretty good clues as to what websites you've been frequenting.

- wolf
 

werepossum

Elite Member
Jul 10, 2006
29,873
463
126
Exactly! And that is why untouchables (non-Hindu) should NOT be allowed to study Hindu scriptures. They are too stupid, undeveloped, and barbaric to understand the stupendous philosophy contained therein.

Hindu orthodoxy FTW! :D

Btw, john of SHITfield, do you know what the year 1200 CE was famous for in England? ;)

They drove out the jews en masse from that island!

And, where did the jews go when the Romans destroyed their temple and threatened them? Take a wild guess. :)

Not to mention too clean and too prosperous!
 

werepossum

Elite Member
Jul 10, 2006
29,873
463
126
It's not permissible, it's not like it's Islam where it's not only permissible but also encouraged per the prophet himself to go around fucking six year olds...

When you live in a glass house, don't cast fucking stones you retarded piece of sheit.
HEY! She was nine! He showed enormous restraint for two years!

In the words of Mohammed:
"Honest to Me, I thought she was twelve, officer!"
 

Baasha

Golden Member
Jan 4, 2010
1,989
20
81
There are no untouchables outside of Hindu society. You are ahead of us on the red dot thing though; we have no equivalent scratch-off system to discover if our new wife's dowry is a motel or a convenience store. :D

You will first have to discover if your new wife is not a prostitute on Craigslist. Being the 100th man she's been with must make you vermin feel proud!
 

Lemon law

Lifer
Nov 6, 2005
20,984
3
0
Don't be a fool werepossim, as you say, "
In the words of Mohammed:
"Honest to Me, I thought she was twelve, officer!"

The point is that the time, its was the Christian, Muslim, and Jewish gold standard of female human rights.

That was a period thankfully long forgotten, at the current time, the Israeli problem is that the larger world now regards current Israeli behavior as the bigger problem.

Are we going to forever wallow in the past or will we embrace a future world founded on justce?
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
HEY! She was nine! He showed enormous restraint for two years!

In the words of Mohammed:
"Honest to Me, I thought she was twelve, officer!"

Should be fucking glad this English Captain wasn't the one capturing their pedophile prohphet while i was moving though that area (long time ago, non military, feels distant today) he wouldn't have had much time for prophecies before i would have ended his career as an author...
 

werepossum

Elite Member
Jul 10, 2006
29,873
463
126
You will first have to discover if your new wife is not a prostitute on Craigslist. Being the 100th man she's been with must make you vermin feel proud!
:D I've had lovers who've had WAY more than a hundred lovers, of both sexes, although none to my knowledge were prostitutes. Never bothered me a bit. However, look around you at the forbidden temples. Hindus invented sexual promiscuity.

Don't be a fool werepossim, as you say, "
In the words of Mohammed:
"Honest to Me, I thought she was twelve, officer!"

The point is that the time, its was the Christian, Muslim, and Jewish gold standard of female human rights.

That was a period thankfully long forgotten, at the current time, the Israeli problem is that the larger world now regards current Israeli behavior as the bigger problem.

Are we going to forever wallow in the past or will we embrace a future world founded on justce?
Muhammed was certainly a man of the times, but bedding a nine year old was not exactly the gold standard of human rights even then. Twelve or thirteen was the minimum considered acceptable, and late teens was not at all unusual. Go back and look at marriage records, and remember that with generally poorer nutrition and no compounds mimicking estrogens, sexual maturity came later. Menses at nine is a relatively recent modality. As far as that being "a period thankfully long forgotten", remember that the Muslims the Koran is the literal word of G-d (assuming you believe that Allah is G-d) and unchanged is still the moral law of Muslim lands.

Ooh, I thought of another great thing about India; its music drives away evil spirits. Well, technically it drives away everything, but it still counts.
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
Don't be a fool werepossim, as you say, "
In the words of Mohammed:
"Honest to Me, I thought she was twelve, officer!"

The point is that the time, its was the Christian, Muslim, and Jewish gold standard of female human rights.

That was a period thankfully long forgotten, at the current time, the Israeli problem is that the larger world now regards current Israeli behavior as the bigger problem.

Are we going to forever wallow in the past or will we embrace a future world founded on justce?

Oh no it was not, it was a barbaric custom ONLY shared in the Muslim world, not in Europe nor anywhere else.

Thing is, it's STILL prevalent among Muslim leaders to have pre teen girls as mistresses.

Omar has three, but that won't stop you from celebrating him, will it? I mean, as long as he's killing American and British soldiers you are just loving him, aren't you?

How's the peace treaty that was supposed to be forced through a good six months ago working out for you? How about the military dictatorship which is the new version after the arab spring?

Not one of your predictions ever turn out the way you hope for, i suppose if they did, neither you nor me would be here discussing it, we would be praising your new masters that you wish for so much...

In short, piss off and no, there is no new Nazi uprising you can attend, it's just the same old shit and i'll still beat your arse into a bloody pulp if i see you attending one.
 

Doboji

Diamond Member
May 18, 2001
7,912
0
76
This thread is despicable.... The OP was clearly trying to get someone to call him anti-semetic. He was successful too. Then he plays innocent... What me anti-Jew?what? I was just trying to have an honest discussion...about an anti-semetic myth about Jews having sex with 3 year olds. Never mind anti-semetic... You're just an asshole.
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
:D I've had lovers who've had WAY more than a hundred lovers, of both sexes, although none to my knowledge were prostitutes. Never bothered me a bit. However, look around you at the forbidden temples. Hindus invented sexual promiscuity.

Why give a shit who she was with before, she's with you now.... If she picked up something to do along the way, good for you..


Muhammed was certainly a man of the times, but bedding a nine year old was not exactly the gold standard of human rights even then. Twelve or thirteen was the minimum considered acceptable, and late teens was not at all unusual. Go back and look at marriage records, and remember that with generally poorer nutrition and no compounds mimicking estrogens, sexual maturity came later. Menses at nine is a relatively recent modality. As far as that being "a period thankfully long forgotten", remember that the Muslims the Koran is the literal word of G-d (assuming you believe that Allah is G-d) and unchanged is still the moral law of Muslim lands.

Ooh, I thought of another great thing about India; its music drives away evil spirits. Well, technically it drives away everything, but it still counts.

I'll have a talk with you on nutrition later on, suffice to say, phytoestrogens do not induce puberty and has very little effect in anyone but post menopausal women and then only because of the metabolites.

I read some studies back in the day about the whole milk producers trying to vilify soy fiasco, turned out that milk colostrum didn't do sheit for ergogenics (no surprise since any peptide is broken down before absorbed if it is the size of HGH) and that soy is more healthy for adult males than regular milk.
 
Jun 26, 2007
11,925
2
0
This thread is despicable.... The OP was clearly trying to get someone to call him anti-semetic. He was successful too. Then he plays innocent... What me anti-Jew?what? I was just trying to have an honest discussion...about an anti-semetic myth about Jews having sex with 3 year olds. Never mind anti-semetic... You're just an asshole.

We need to be less fucking touchy, it's IN the interpretation, not even you can deny that so sit back and thank JediYoda for giving the explanation needed for it to be understood while you piss on those who refuse to understand it.

I like William, if you have a problem with him you can state it but he's no fucking anti-semite or neo nazi, i do believe there are a sheitload of them around here but he's not one of them, he's genuinly appalled by what he read and tries to look for answers, as he should, don't blame him for doing that.

Shalom.
 

werepossum

Elite Member
Jul 10, 2006
29,873
463
126
Why give a shit who she was with before, she's with you now.... If she picked up something to do along the way, good for you..

I'll have a talk with you on nutrition later on, suffice to say, phytoestrogens do not induce puberty and has very little effect in anyone but post menopausal women and then only because of the metabolites.

I read some studies back in the day about the whole milk producers trying to vilify soy fiasco, turned out that milk colostrum didn't do sheit for ergogenics (no surprise since any peptide is broken down before absorbed if it is the size of HGH) and that soy is more healthy for adult males than regular milk.
Agreed. Welcome back, by the way.
 

Doboji

Diamond Member
May 18, 2001
7,912
0
76
We need to be less fucking touchy, it's IN the interpretation, not even you can deny that so sit back and thank JediYoda for giving the explanation needed for it to be understood while you piss on those who refuse to understand it.

I like William, if you have a problem with him you can state it but he's no fucking anti-semite or neo nazi, i do believe there are a sheitload of them around here but he's not one of them, he's genuinly appalled by what he read and tries to look for answers, as he should, don't blame him for doing that.

Shalom.

Nah fuck that... Call it for what it is. This crap in the op is garbage, and a simple google search exposes it for what it is. If William is a good guy... Cool. Then William next time don't be a moron and use the fucking google before you go insulting a whole religion.
 

werepossum

Elite Member
Jul 10, 2006
29,873
463
126
Nah fuck that... Call it for what it is. This crap in the op is garbage, and a simple google search exposes it for what it is. If William is a good guy... Cool. Then William next time don't be a moron and use the fucking google before you go insulting a whole religion.
But we HAVE to insult entire religions. We don't have time to insult all these people individually!
 

Infohawk

Lifer
Jan 12, 2002
17,844
1
0
Must suck for a Hindu Fascist/Supremest like yourself to live among all the Untouchables in the USA, especially when a lot of them think you are inferior to them.

I doubt he has the guts to share his hindi-fascist beliefs with his acquaintances and colleagues. Most people wouldn't want to do business with or work with someone with bizarre and malicious beliefs. I'm sure he just tries keep it to talk about "exotic cars" as they roll their eyes.
 

Karl Agathon

Golden Member
Sep 30, 2010
1,081
0
0
i doubt he has the guts to share his hindi-fascist beliefs with his acquaintances and colleagues. Most people wouldn't want to do business with or work with someone with bizarre and malicious beliefs. i'm sure he just tries keep it to talk about "exotic cars" as they roll their eyes.

lmfao!!!!!!
 

JEDIYoda

Lifer
Jul 13, 2005
33,986
3,321
126
you're a fucking pervert

My words hardly...the link says it is not permissible and it says if sex does take place it is child abuse...so where do you get that I approve of something as deplorable as abusing a 3 yr old??
 
Status
Not open for further replies.