Serviceman goes on shooting spree in Afghanistan.

Hayabusa Rider

Admin Emeritus & Elite Member
Jan 26, 2000
50,872
4,216
126
We really really need to get out of that pit.

link to article

Reporting from Kabul, Afghanistan -- A lone American serviceman slipped away from his base in southern Afghanistan before dawn Sunday and went on a methodical house-to-house shooting spree in a nearby village, killing 16 people, nearly all of them women and children, according to Afghan officials who visited the scene.

The NATO force confirmed that the assailant was in military custody, and that he had inflicted an unspecified number of casualties during the shooting spree at about 3 a.m. Sunday. The U.S. Embassy called for calm and expressed deep condolences; the Taliban referred to the killings as an “act of genocide.”

The British Broadcasting Corp. reported that the shooter was a staff sergeant and a member of the U.S. special operations forces who had been involved in training the Afghan police.

The incident, potentially the worst atrocity of the 10-year war to be deliberately carried out by a single member of the Western military, represents a stunning setback to U.S.-Afghan relations, already shaken by last month’s burning of copies of the Koran at a U.S. military base north of Kabul.

Anti-U.S. sentiment flared into deadly riots after the Koran-burning at Bagram airfield came to light. American officials have said the action was a mistake and offered profuse apologies, but some Afghans, including lawmakers and senior clerics, brushed aside the apologies and called for harsh punishment of those involved.

The shooting early Sunday took place in Panjwayi district outside Kandahar city, in a village called Alkozai. U.S. military officials, speaking on condition of anonymity, said it was believed that the assailant had suffered a mental breakdown.

The NATO force issued a terse statement confirming casualties and promising a full investigation by U.S. and Afghan authorities. Later, the acting commander of the U.S.-led coalition, Lt. Gen. Adrian Bradshaw, expressed “deep regret and sorrow at this appalling incident.”

“I cannot explain the motivation behind such callous acts, but they were in no way part of authorized … military activity,” he said.

In the hours after the shooting rampage, casualty counts varied widely. By late afternoon, however, an official provincial delegation had arrived at the scene.

beloved patriot Agha Lalai Dastgeeri, a member of that team, said the official tally was 16 dead. Nine of them were women, four were children and three were men, he said.

“I saw the dead bodies and visited the victims’ families,” he said soberly.

Earlier, beloved patriot Mohammad Ehsan, the deputy head of Kandahar’s provincial council, had put the number of dead at 18. Javed Faisal, a spokesman for the Kandahar media center, said “up to 15” people had been killed, and several others wounded. The conflicting casualty counts could not immediately be reconciled.

The attacker’s motive was unknown, but relations between the U.S. military and ordinary Afghans have been highly fraught since February’s Koran-burning riots, which exacerbated longstanding tensions over civilian casualties and night raids led by U.S. special forces.

During more than a week of nationwide protests over the burning of the holy books that left at least 30 people dead, six U.S. service members were shot and killed by Afghan soldiers or, in the case of two of them, a worker at Afghanistan’s Interior Ministry. Two of the American troops who were killed were deployed in Kandahar province.

Kandahar, which is President Hamid Karzai’s home province, is also the birthplace and spiritual home of the Taliban. Panjwayi district was the scene of heavy fighting two years ago as U.S. forces made a major push to dislodge the insurgents, and parts of the district remain volatile.

The episode is certain to complicate U.S. dealings with Karzai, who has been resistant to American plans to try to inaugurate peace talks with the Taliban movement in the Gulf state of Qatar. The shooting comes days after an agreement to hand suspected insurgents in American custody over to control of Afghan officials -- a process that is expected to take some months. Karzai had demanded an immediate handover of the main U.S. detention center.

Civilian casualties -- almost always accidentally inflicted, when they come at the hands of the Western military -- have long been a sore point in the West’s dealings with Karzai. In a statement, the U.S. Embassy denounced “all violence against civilians,” and promised that the “individual or individuals responsible for this act will be identified and brought to justice.”

--Laura King

We've been in a place where we're an annoyance at best and most definitely hated by some.
We've been sticking people in this rat hole when we should have been out almost a decade ago.
We try to dispose of qurans properly and we apologize for an honest mistake but not a word offered for the loss of six of our soldiers and 30 or more dead altogether.
We've thrown our people into a pressure cooker and turned up the heat all the way.
The result? Someone explodes with tragic results.

In such a screwed up place I don't know if this will be seen as being worse than burning a book or not but certainly more people will die, something which should not have happened in the first place.

I don't care about the election or political posturing, we need to get out starting now.
 

Double Trouble

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
9,272
103
106
This is sad. You place people in such an environment for extended time and some are going to snap. This action certainly can't be excused or justified in any way, and the perp will be punished. I'm surprised it hasn't happened more.

That place is beyond saving anyway, it's time to bring everyone home.
 

a777pilot

Diamond Member
Apr 26, 2011
4,261
21
81
I agree with the sentiments of the two post before me....it is time, past time, in my opinion, to get out of there.
 

leper84

Senior member
Dec 29, 2011
989
29
86
What's funny is situations like this, or the Koran burning, almost seem like they are used to create MORE tension to justify our continued existence in these countries. Sort of 'we can't leave now because its still not safe'...

More war, more debt, more contracts. To play conspiracy theorist, it seems interesting this 'soldier' is special operations considering how much the CIA likes to recruit from that group. Also consider this is the sort of thing the CIA does.
 

micrometers

Diamond Member
Nov 14, 2010
3,473
0
0
Yes, executed with Afghan witnessess at the execution so they can say they saw it happen.

I'll bet some Republican presidential candidate or talk radio host will accuse Obama of selling out servicemen if there is any serious justice meted out to this guy. Heck, I'd just turn him over to the Afghans and let them deal with him.

But seriously, look at how the country reacted to the Mai Lai massacre. The murdering soldiers were actually hailed as heroes in some parts.
 

cybrsage

Lifer
Nov 17, 2011
13,021
0
0
Different nation back then, or at least I hope so. You will always have some crazies who applaud crazy things, but hopefully the lions share of people will abhor this act.
 

monovillage

Diamond Member
Jul 3, 2008
8,444
1
0
I'm not sure what the proper military regulations would be, but if possible i'd like to see this tried in public or with observers in Afghanistan and if he's found guilty to be executed with victims families as observers in Afghanistan.
 

cybrsage

Lifer
Nov 17, 2011
13,021
0
0
Sad part is that there will always be Republicans coming up with excuses for being there.

Notice Obama has not let the nation yet either...he still has excuses for being there.

Oh, and before you say anything, Obama is not a republican. Figured you might not know this, due to him behaving much like Bush.
 

PottedMeat

Lifer
Apr 17, 2002
12,365
475
126

cybrsage

Lifer
Nov 17, 2011
13,021
0
0
For me, it is easy. You commit murder, you should be executed. I also believe if you attempt to commit murder (or any other crime) you should be punished as if you were successful. You should not get a lighter sentence simply because you failed.
 

Hayabusa Rider

Admin Emeritus & Elite Member
Jan 26, 2000
50,872
4,216
126
For me, it is easy. You commit murder, you should be executed. I also believe if you attempt to commit murder (or any other crime) you should be punished as if you were successful. You should not get a lighter sentence simply because you failed.

I believe that the mental state of a person needs to be taken into account. We are not served well by a system that had no intelligence or understanding. Justice by algorithm is something I oppose. Yes the law has a form which me must be followed, but applying "zero tolerence" principles is foolishness.
 

cybrsage

Lifer
Nov 17, 2011
13,021
0
0
I believe that the mental state of a person needs to be taken into account. We are not served well by a system that had no intelligence or understanding. Justice by algorithm is something I oppose. Yes the law has a form which me must be followed, but applying "zero tolerence" principles is foolishness.

I say their mental state can only be taken into account if it restores life to the dead person. Unless it does, the punishment is the same.

If you purposefully go out to murder, you should die. Accidents are different, but I do not care WHY you decided to murder others.

You can look at it this way as well:

If you murder someone, there are only two states of mind you could have, you could be sane or insane. If you are sane, you are a threat to society and must be executed for the safety of society.

If you are insane, there are only two next steps to follow, if you can be cured or not. If you cannot be cured, you are a threat to society. You must be executed for the safety of society, for you will murder again. If you can be cured, any cure would require you to fully understand what you did to another human. You murdered them, forever snuffing out their life and causing pain and suffering to their family and friends forever. No upstanding member of society could live with such guilt and shame, they would commit suicide.

As a fair society, we should not force such pain and suffering upon anyone, so we should execute them for their own sake.



(This is a paraphrase of Robert Heinlein)
 

CallMeJoe

Diamond Member
Jul 30, 2004
6,938
5
81
For me, it is easy. You commit murder, you should be executed. I also believe if you attempt to commit murder (or any other crime) you should be punished as if you were successful. You should not get a lighter sentence simply because you failed.
You assume everyone convicted is necessarily guilty. Recent judicial history argues otherwise.
 

cybrsage

Lifer
Nov 17, 2011
13,021
0
0
You assume everyone convicted is necessarily guilty. Recent judicial history argues otherwise.

We either must assume the convicted are guilty or we must assume the convicted are innocent. There really is no other choice with the system we have.

We both know that putting convicted criminals in jail is done because we assume they are guilty after being convicted, right?
 

dmcowen674

No Lifer
Oct 13, 1999
54,894
46
91
www.alienbabeltech.com
Notice Obama has not let the nation yet either...he still has excuses for being there.

Oh, and before you say anything, Obama is not a republican. Figured you might not know this, due to him behaving much like Bush.

:rolleyes:

I don't reply to you much because you are clearly an RBM.

Anyway of course you are disingenuous as your first post as usual.

Obama has gotten a lot of our asses out of there.

Everyone knows except apparently your little mind that it takes time to wind down the military machine whether it was cranked up by a legitimate war or a false war such as the ones started by your hero Bush.
 

davmat787

Diamond Member
Nov 30, 2010
5,513
24
76
More war, more debt, more contracts. To play conspiracy theorist, it seems interesting this 'soldier' is special operations considering how much the CIA likes to recruit from that group. Also consider this is the sort of thing the CIA does.

The vast majority of CIA employees are desk jockeys, err I mean analysts. I would be shocked if this guy was employed for any sort of action role. His actions do not dictate that he can follow orders or work in a team environment, let alone by himself in some third world hell hole.

Oh, and lol at the Taliban calling 21 deaths a genocide. I bet that call that a soccer match, all distastefulness aside. :sneaky:
 
Last edited:

cybrsage

Lifer
Nov 17, 2011
13,021
0
0
:rolleyes:

I don't reply to you much because you are clearly an RBM.

You are ProJo, so who are you to talk?

Anyway of course you are disingenuous as your first post as usual.

Obama has gotten a lot of our asses out of there.

Everyone knows except apparently your little mind that it takes time to wind down the military machine whether it was cranked up by a legitimate war or a false war such as the ones started by your hero Bush.

Wait...Obama has pulled our troops out of Afghanistan? When did this happen, or are you lying about it?
 

CallMeJoe

Diamond Member
Jul 30, 2004
6,938
5
81
We either must assume the convicted are guilty or we must assume the convicted are innocent. There really is no other choice with the system we have.
We both know that putting convicted criminals in jail is done because we assume they are guilty after being convicted, right?
Apologies to OP for thread diversion. Capital punishment vs. conviction of innocents has no place in this thread.
 

Hayabusa Rider

Admin Emeritus & Elite Member
Jan 26, 2000
50,872
4,216
126
We either must assume the convicted are guilty or we must assume the convicted are innocent. There really is no other choice with the system we have.

We both know that putting convicted criminals in jail is done because we assume they are guilty after being convicted, right?

This is heading down a different rabbit hole, but what you quoted is the reason I'm generally against the death penalty. We put people in prison based on the legal assumption of guilt. Sometimes that's wrong and the person is released, but how do you give them years back? Well that's something we have to deal with and hopefully restitution is made as best as can be, however how much money does it take to bring a dead man back to life? Nothing. Too bad, so sad doesn't cut it for me.

Back to the main topic please.
 

ASK THE COMMUNITY