Hands on first time with the Note 5 ( and S6 edge+) today.
Eh.
Fine, the N5 is a great device on it's own, but for previous Note owners (me certainly) who really like the full feature set, none of its improvements are enough to overcome it's feature downgrades. Loss of SD storage is just too much a kick in the ass to me.
I also despise..loathe...HATE the glass back. It feels slippery and nasty...it doesn't even look good. Glass is an idiotic material for a phone. People will cover it up to protect it (so whats the point?) Or put up with it making the phone slippery in hand and eventually shattered and cracked like so many iPhone 4 owners I recall. Just a dumb backward ass move the glass nonsense IMO.
Much as I'm not impressed by the Note 5, I recognize its an awesome device and will probably sell well with people new to Samsung and the Note line, if not previous hardcore Note fans. It could be a smart move to attract new users as opposed to appease current Note owners, I dunno.
But for me the thing that hits home biggest: side by side with the Note 4, the Mg still IMO is the MUCH better device in every way save stats. The N4 looks more preimum. Looks/feels sturdier, and feels like more of a serious device than a boutique toy that the N5 borders on.
I wish Samsung and others hadnt swallowed so much Apple cool-aid; the back of the N4 looks and feels far better, more practical, more serious than that slimey glass mess on the N5. That that glass is to accomodate the loss of two key Note features is IMO just insult to injury.
Kinda sad as I've had the N2,N3 and N4 and felt each was atleast a decent step past the last, or at least an adequate refinement (N4). Each time I've felt the momentum to own the next subside a little... but bottom line I still wanted to own the next. Not this time.
The N5 for me breaks the trend. I feel its too much of a downgrade for no real purpose other than some notion of 'hipness' which I've never cared about with electronic devices. Form definitely overtook function which is a detriment to the Note IMO.
Oddest to me is what would compel most people to buy an N5 vs. an edge+? The pen? I don't see most caring about that.
The edge+ is (IMO) more compelling, more radical, more interesting, more impressive than the N5. I don't see why the average consumer would choose an N5 over it.
I don't see gloom and doom for Samsung. They'll probably do well and people will go blindly back to piddly 32GB being 'enough' and scoffing at the idea that for some strange reason in 2015/16 anyone would want more storage than that without paying through the nose, or use a phone as a productivity device not just a shiney make-believe 'status symbol'.
The age of add your own storage or swap out a battery are coming to and end, Samsung knows it and is fully onboard, ready to lock those avenues down, roll back time and profit handsomely.
I'll likely stick with my 'old school' Note 4 for longer. $8 added wireless charging to it that's been rock solid.