Originally posted by: zinfamous
Originally posted by: Inspector Jihad
Originally posted by: jinduy
roger federer is GOAT. no question with this win (if he wins).
i'm a huge federer fan but he never had to go against a really good player until nadal...and nadal has outplayed federer in head to head matchups.
this.
I think Federer is the shit, but this win was rather... "cheap," being that he didn't have to get through Nadal, who consistently owns him on clay.
I wouldn't call it cheap. It's not like Nadal intentionally lost to Soderling. And given that Nadal has cleaned up so easily on clay it was quite an accomplishment for him to get taken out so handily by a relative no name.
And saying Federer never had to go against a really good player until Nadal came along is just BS. It's like saying Tiger doesn't have to play against any really good players. Good as Nadal may be, I don't see him sticking it out and taking as many slams as Federer.
Oh and record-wise Nadal may dominate Federer on clad, but c'mon now, most of their matches have gone the distance. It's just been a point here or there that's made the difference -- there's definitely some skill involved in that, but its not ownage.