Originally posted by: Craig234
Originally posted by: Fear No Evil
Sending his kids away to private schools while he makes it more difficult for regular people to do so is elitist.. Taxing the rich because they are successful is elitist. Apologizing to the world is elitist. Wanting to implement a carbon tax is elitist.
Putting mustard on your hamburger without ketchup just makes you a f--king moron.
There isn't much point in pointing at idiotic posts and saying they're idiotic, but sometimes it's hard to resist. Like the one above.
One of the common fallacies I see on the right is when they hide an illogical claim behind an attack on the motive of the 'other side'. So in this case, the actual merits of raising taxes on the rich isn't discussed, the actual reasons the proponents have for doing so aren't discussed - instead, the straw man is used that the motive is to punish them for being successful. The illogic of that statement is obvious - it's idiotic - but it serves the purpose of getting people who don't use logic to oppose the tax increase.
It even gets to the point of irony, where the people who are actually defending the real 'elites', the CEO's, the tycoons, the Wall Street moguls, by screwing the public, realizing they are vulnerable to a populist attack on their elitist policies, simply turn the tables and attack the people defending the public as the 'elites'. And on some, it works.
Let's apply a little logic and ask, what's more elitist - assuming elitist is 'bad' here - between raising the taxes on the most wealthy - of giving them *lower* taxes?
Only this sort of idiotic logic-free propaganda such as spewed by DearNoEvil can claim that taking more from the elites and less from others is the 'elitist' policy.
Similarly - what's more elitist: for the most powerful nation in the world who does some wrongs to others to arrogantly refuse to acknowledge any of them - or to apologize?
Again, only the idiotic logic-free argument says it's more elitist for the elites to apologize.
Protecting the environment with a carbon tax is elitist? OK, we're well past the point that calling an idiotic post idiotic is pointless.