Real or Rendered - The truth has been set free!

[Czar]

Originally posted by: rh71

Originally posted by: Czar

Originally posted by: rh71
I'm very torn on this one... I will lean towards real because the rug at the bottom of the stairs has too much detail in the folding. Also the top stair ledge has an imperfection... if it were rendered, that wouldn't be so in a scene so clean.

I was about to say fake because the light shining right near the bottom of the stairs has faded shadows similar to something a smudge tool can do.

well, if it were rendered then there wouldnt be much point to use photoshop to create shadows

you're talking to a guy who knows nothing about 3d rendering.. I only know photoshop. So tell me it's real...

hehe, well for 3d the renderer does everything regarding shadows, photoshop is used for color touchups and sometimes to make certain areas brighter or others darker, just like you would with a photograph


and I used 3dsmax

 

[NL5]

I say it's real...

 

[lozina]

I said real.

Looking back at it, I still think it's real!

I have to say, you do fine work there Czar

 

[TerryMathews]

To me, what gives away renders most of the time is a lack of focus.

I know, sometimes you get pictures without any out-of-focus areas as well. But that's fairly rare. Most of the time, something in the scene is out of focus.

 

[Nitemare]

Rendered but a very good one

 

[Injury]

Your floor texture looks a bit stretched or a bit crooked. Awesome though. Did you model the plants or paint effects? Got any more camera angles?

 

[MacBaine]

So far nobody has noticed the fact that he said he just found this image on the net.

I am saying real, just because I know 99% of the "rendered" posts in here are just arrogant idiots with no ability whatsoever who are using non-reasons to force a justification that it is rendered.

 

[Steve]

It's real. Don't let me catch you in my house again.

 

[causearuckus]

rendered

 

[Adica]

I dunno. I am stumped.

 

[rezinn]

I voted real due to small details in the lighting, the glass, and on the floor. Plus, it appears as if you can see more than sunlight through the windows. The pixilation doesn't really concern me.

 

[Cristatus]

i would have to vote real because of the amount of details in the rug at the bottom of the stairs

 

[TitanDiddly]

I said real on a first impulse.

 

[Czar]

the poll is so close

will post the truth when I get back from the gym in about 2 hours or so

 

[Tanner]

wow...eitheway

 

[JeffreyLebowski]

Definatly rendered. The detail in the shadows is to good.

 

[no0b]

Seems too picturesque for me must be rendered.

Also too much detail in the parts that should be fuzzier. The hall way along the left and right of the picture has too much detail. If it was real I would expect less detail because of the amount of light coming through the window.

 

[mobobuff]

I first thought it was real from the moment I loaded it.

 

[ATLien247]

Real...

 

[ndee]

What would be the point of posting a real picture?

 

[Juice Box]

Im pretty familiar with renderings... and im 99% sure this is rendered


and I also think ive seen this pic online before

 

[Czar]

Originally posted by: ndee
What would be the point of posting a real picture?

well the last two I posted were real, just to spice it up a bit


and yes this is rendered
I'll try to find something as hard as this tomorrow, well actually I have already found a few already but I will post them tomorrow

 

[Cristatus]

wow, that's a pretty good rendering then. especially the rug at the bottom of the stairs...

 

[Czar]

Originally posted by: logic1485
wow, that's a pretty good rendering then. especially the rug at the bottom of the stairs...

that is precisely what makes a good render if you want realism, that is those little things

 

[Baked]

It's rendered. Or your digicam sucks.