Poll: my first poll: Armageddon VS Deep Impact

[The Wildcard]

Armageddon simply and stupidly because it has Liv Tyler...lol.

 

[Wah]

Armageddon was so bad it made me wanna puke.

 

[dennilfloss]

I hate Bruce Willis with a passion, ever since Moonlighting when I was wishing that Cybil Shepard would shoot the bastard. So, as you can guess, I did not see Armageddon (I will not pay to watch a Bruce Willis movie, he almost ruined Pulp Fiction for me and that was on TV, where I can fast forward his scenes).

I did like Deep Impact and it is quite realistic. I also like the character development in it. I was expecting something as nauseous as the kiddie movie Independance Day but I was pleasantly surprised.

Atomic Punk (Van Halen)

 

[Spoooon]

Deep Impact was pretty cheesy in my opinion.

Another thing about Deep Impact: why was the scientist in such a huge rush to get the news out? He was acting like the Earth was going to be destroyed in the next 5 minutes if he didn't do something about it. Lame stuff. And Tea Leoni is just not good in the movie.

And yes, Armageddon has it's share of bad parts, but atleast it was entertaining.

 

[NFS4]

Armageddon

 

[EmperorNero]

pretty cool space wallpapers @ the deep impact site.

 

[jacobnero6918]

I saw Deep Impact and it was alright, then I rented the Armageddon DVD and was so disappointed. The special effects were horrible. They had to make it as dark as possible so you couldn't see how bad they were. There were a couple good scenes in it though like the golf scene and when he chases Ben affleck around with a shotgun.

A better movie is the Fifth Element, what a blast that flick is.

 

[loup garou]

I think Carnosaur is better than either of those. Yuk.

 

[Harv22222]

Armageddon hands down. How realistic is it when you can out run a wave that high, get real. When the earth gets hit like that nothing lives remember. Wait we can live if we run up this tall hill, hahaah ya right.

 

[damocles]

Armageddon, i just thought it was better written and directed

 

[ManSnake]

Deep Impact is an okay movie, Armageddon sucks monkey's nuts!

 

[damocles]

A better movie is the Fifth Element, what a blast that flick is.

In my opinion, that goes without saying

 

[Linh]

hmm, i liked both of them. Never really sat around and thought how realistic they were though.

 

[snow patrol]

OMG - I can't believe ten people (so far) have voted for Deep Impact. That has to be just about THE worst movie I have ever had the displeasure of watching. It really was offensively sh!t :|

Armageddon was actually not that bad, although by no means a 'great' movie. Maybe 'good' or 'ok'...

 

[snow patrol]

The 5th element was a load of horse bollocks as well!

 

[FrogDog]

Armageddon to me, was pretty bad. It was full of stupid wise-cracks and stuff. Even when they're in space, they're still joking around! Deep Impact had a better story, and was way more realistic.

 

[kami]

what are you talking about? 5th element was a fun movie.

 

[fluxquantum]

deep impact. it had a better story line.

 

[Dedpuhl]

Take the movies for what they were: entertainment.

Armageddon was able to keep my attention the whole way. Deep Impact's storyline seemed to drag. That's my two cents....

 

[NucleusWDS]

What a load of sh!t - Deep Impact ... a BLACK President !!! ... Come on PLEASE !!!

Some time away from here will help you think about what you just said.

AnandTech Moderator

 

[XL]

Armageddon

 

[JeremyJoe]

they both suck and both unrealistic....we wouldnt be able to see a meter that big until it is too late.....im talking ablt not seeing it 10 seconds before it hits earth cause it would be moving too fast

 

[JayPatel]

<< What a load of sh!t - Deep Impact ... a BLACK President !!! ... Come on PLEASE !!! >>



nucleus are you saying that you think that American Presidents can only be white and not black? If yes then you are one hell of an ignorant punk!!! and not to mention one hell of a racist

 

[EmperorNero]

jaypatel, don't bother wasting your time on such a fvcking dumbass - it's not worth the trouble.


personally, I thought one of the best part of the movie was the black president - gives you something to think about. like someone said, deep impact is the intellectual version of armageddon.

 

[JayPatel]

yes the one redeeming quality of the movie was Morgan Freemans depiction of an American President....

Deep Impact seemed too much like a made for tv movie than rather a full blown movie production

Armageddon is so cliched...yet i like the movie so much it remains one of my all time faves...