POLL: Fantasy Football Trade Evaluation

[spanky]

THE POLL IS FOR WHICH TEAM HAS THE ADVANTAGE AFTER THE TRADE... NOT WHO HAS THE BETTER PLAYERS BEFORE THE TRADE


is this trade one sided or... ?

Team A
Micheal Pittman (TB)
Anthony Thomas (Chi)
Kurt Warner (StL)
Ricky Williams (Mia)

FOR

Team B
Ladell Betts (Was)
Rod Gardner (Was)
Warrick Dunn (Atl)
Drew Bledsoe (Buf)

 

[bunker]

Team A
Micheal Pittman (TB) - Uselss
Anthony Thomas (Chi) - Useless
Kurt Warner (StL) - Bordering on useless
Ricky Williams (Mia) - Good

FOR

Team B
Ladell Betts (Was) - Getting many carries, not good, but not useless
Rod Gardner (Was) - I was at the game yesterday, Ramsey likes throwing to him
Warrick Dunn (Atl) - Good
Drew Bledsoe (Buf) - After yesterday, fsckin' great.

Decent sized advantage for team B here.

 

[spanky]

Originally posted by: bunker
Team A
Micheal Pittman (TB) - Uselss
Anthony Thomas (Chi) - Useless
Kurt Warner (StL) - Bordering on useless
Ricky Williams (Mia) - Good

FOR

Team B
Ladell Betts (Was) - Getting many carries, not good, but not useless
Rod Gardner (Was) - I was at the game yesterday, Ramsey likes throwing to him
Warrick Dunn (Atl) - Good
Drew Bledsoe (Buf) - After yesterday, fsckin' great.

Decent sized advantage for team B here.

don't u mean team a, since team b is recieving all those "useless" players

 

[waylman]

Originally posted by: spanky

Originally posted by: bunker
Team A
Micheal Pittman (TB) - Uselss
Anthony Thomas (Chi) - Useless
Kurt Warner (StL) - Bordering on useless
Ricky Williams (Mia) - Good

FOR

Team B
Ladell Betts (Was) - Getting many carries, not good, but not useless
Rod Gardner (Was) - I was at the game yesterday, Ramsey likes throwing to him
Warrick Dunn (Atl) - Good
Drew Bledsoe (Buf) - After yesterday, fsckin' great.

Decent sized advantage for team B here.

don't u mean team a, since team b is recieving all those "useless" players

he's saying team b is the better team

 

[bunker]

Originally posted by: spanky

Originally posted by: bunker
Team A
Micheal Pittman (TB) - Uselss
Anthony Thomas (Chi) - Useless
Kurt Warner (StL) - Bordering on useless
Ricky Williams (Mia) - Good

FOR

Team B
Ladell Betts (Was) - Getting many carries, not good, but not useless
Rod Gardner (Was) - I was at the game yesterday, Ramsey likes throwing to him
Warrick Dunn (Atl) - Good
Drew Bledsoe (Buf) - After yesterday, fsckin' great.

Decent sized advantage for team B here.

don't u mean team a, since team b is recieving all those "useless" players

Doh! You are correct, team A is getting the advantage. Had it backwards and voted backwards as well.

 

[spanky]

Originally posted by: waylman

Originally posted by: spanky

Originally posted by: bunker
Team A
Micheal Pittman (TB) - Uselss
Anthony Thomas (Chi) - Useless
Kurt Warner (StL) - Bordering on useless
Ricky Williams (Mia) - Good

FOR

Team B
Ladell Betts (Was) - Getting many carries, not good, but not useless
Rod Gardner (Was) - I was at the game yesterday, Ramsey likes throwing to him
Warrick Dunn (Atl) - Good
Drew Bledsoe (Buf) - After yesterday, fsckin' great.

Decent sized advantage for team B here.

don't u mean team a, since team b is recieving all those "useless" players

he's saying team b is the better team

so doesn't that mean in the poll, he should have voted "advantage: team a"? is my poll confusing, or my thread?

 

[Xenon]

The trade basically boils down to Ricky Williams for Dunn and Bledsoe since the other players involved are pretty much waiver wire material. Really hard to say, but usual convention is the team that gets the best player usually wins any trade. So, I'd say advantage team B in that trade for getting a premier running back for an above average running back and quarterback.

 

[waylman]

Originally posted by: spanky

Originally posted by: waylman

Originally posted by: spanky

Originally posted by: bunker
Team A
Micheal Pittman (TB) - Uselss
Anthony Thomas (Chi) - Useless
Kurt Warner (StL) - Bordering on useless
Ricky Williams (Mia) - Good

FOR

Team B
Ladell Betts (Was) - Getting many carries, not good, but not useless
Rod Gardner (Was) - I was at the game yesterday, Ramsey likes throwing to him
Warrick Dunn (Atl) - Good
Drew Bledsoe (Buf) - After yesterday, fsckin' great.

Decent sized advantage for team B here.

don't u mean team a, since team b is recieving all those "useless" players

he's saying team b is the better team

so doesn't that mean in the poll, he should have voted "advantage: team a"? is my poll confusing, or my thread?

yes, it's really confusing, b/c I voted for "team B" b/c they have the better team. However, after the trade, "team A" would have the advantage.

 

[AvesPKS]

I'd stick with the B-team material, but then I'm partial to Washington.

 

[spanky]

Team A just wants ricky... everyone else is just filler (as xenon stated). however, Team B is getting a starting QB (bledsoe replaced maddox) and WR/RB (gardner replaces thomas). dunn will replace williams... which is a downgrade, but dunn should still put up decent numbers. so xenon was close... basically this is a trade of

williams for bledsoe, gardner, & dunn

 

[Xenon]

Originally posted by: spanky
Team A just wants ricky... everyone else is just filler (as xenon stated). however, Team B is getting a starting QB (bledsoe replaced maddox) and WR/RB (gardner replaces thomas). dunn will replace williams... which is a downgrade, but dunn should still put up decent numbers. so xenon was close... basically this is a trade of

williams for bledsoe, gardner, & dunn

Hmm...maybe. I guess I'm underestimating the value of Gardner, especially with the emergence of Patrick Ramsey. How many teams are in your league? How many slots?

 

[spanky]

we got 10 teams in my league. here is what our starting rosters look like.

 

[gleong]

Originally posted by: spanky
THE POLL IS FOR WHICH TEAM HAS THE ADVANTAGE AFTER THE TRADE... NOT WHO HAS THE BETTER PLAYERS BEFORE THE TRADE


is this trade one sided or... ?

Team A
Micheal Pittman (TB)
Anthony Thomas (Chi)
Kurt Warner (StL)
Ricky Williams (Mia)

FOR

Team B
Ladell Betts (Was)
Rod Gardner (Was)
Warrick Dunn (Atl)
Drew Bledsoe (Buf)

so, it's basically: ricky williams for gardner/dunn/bledsoe

seems lopsided, but based on the starting rosters, I can see why Team B would trade all those players for williams...his team is pretty deep, so he's trading his bench players for a star player.

 

[new2AMD]

In all trades....you have to give something to get something. So if it is worth giving up 3 players for 1 then who cares what anyone on the outside thinks?

 

[Xenon]

Looks like that trade could plug some holes for you. Seems like a good trade for both teams.

 

[spanky]

i think its a fair trade. however, i just wasn't sure how the rest of the league would react... since it's ricky williams on the trading block. i was just wondering if there would be league wide outrage... thus causing my trade to be veto'ed. hopefully it won't