Ehh ... I have Luigi's, Panhandlers, Rosati's, JJ Twig's, Giuseppe's as well as chains like Pizza hut and dominos in the town of about 12K in which I live. (There is a Papa Murphy's too...)
Luigi's pizza is fvckin awesome, owned by a 50-60 year old Italian American, everything is uber delicious. Also has kick ass italian beef as well as Lasagna. My only complaint, is that they are frugal with their sauce there, but, I often add sliced tomatoes to the pizza, and IMO, sliced tomatos are way better than pizza sauce....
Best pizza: Double Decker or Deep Dish with Italian Beef, Onions, Green Peppers, and tomato slices.
Panhandler's Pizza is very delicious. Best Stuffed pizza in town IMO. But overall, not quite as good as Luigi's.
Best pizza: Stuffed sausage, green pepper, onion, mushroom
Rosati's is a "chain" with like 20-30 restaurants.
Pretty much everything is good, but they don't get me excited like Luigi's or Panhandlers.
JJ Twigs is more or less a bar that has pizza, not a fan of their pizza, but It's better than some places.
Never been to Giuseppe's, have so many choices, and such a huge fan of Luigi's that I dunno if I ever will go here.
Pizza hut and Dominos are garbage IMO. But, I haven't had Domino's since the 90s, and I've heard that they have changed their pizza's around a lot.
Best "cheap" pizza, IMO, is Little Caesar's. I have to drive like 15 minutes to get to one of them though, but for $5 a piece, lots of cheese, tasty sauce, and decent crust ... it's hard to go wrong.