- Nov 6, 2005
- 20,984
- 3
- 0
I may be a voracious reader of tecno-geek but am short on hands on experience. I had a
amd X2 4000+ processor, an OS of XP pro, and a MSI board that did not support overclocking. It was stable for a little over a year, then all of a sudden my computer developed a habit of crashing, and losing the entire OS in the process. So I replaced the Sata HDD, memtest 86 showed no ram errors, so I reinstalled the OS, and 4 days later it lost the OS. Did it again and it waited another 5 days to totally lose the OS. I should also specify I very good power supply that tested slightly above spec, temperatures were all normal, and had reloaded boas stock settings.
So I took it to a computer shop to find out what was wrong, and the computer shop was baffled also. So they gave it back to me, I again had to reinstall the OS, and it lasted another 4 days before crashing and losing the OS.
At that point I bit the bullet figuring its was motherboard or processor. So I had the computer shop, replace the mobo with a GA-g31m-es2l motherboard and an intel e5200 processor, got my windows XP pro full OS reinstalled, and now it looks like I again have a stable computer.
My original one GB of ram was not compatible with the new board, but my computer shop gave me a single stick of new kingston 2 GB ps5300 ram they had laying around as a free sample. Did I forget to mention the computer shop I dealt with was owned by a honest man?
Right now the new computer runs at the specified 2.5 GHZ, even though its smoothly downclocks to a 6x multiplier under no load. At idle real temps shows a CPU idle temp of 37C, it goes up to never more than 55C running prime 95, adn no alarms for HDD temps or other problems. Video and sound are on board and I have no need for faster video or
better sound.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now that the boundary conditions are out of the way, I have some over clocking questions
I wish to pursue on only a beer budget.
1. Since my big bottle neck seems to be the only Pc5300 ram, what kind of a percentage gain could I expect to see ( In terms of boot speed or run speed ) if I added another stick of identical ram thus allowing me to use the dual channel DDR2 the board is capable of?
2. Would it be worth me trying to try a mild overclock the this computer with only PC5300 ram. Or will I rapidly hit a wall where its not worth it?
3. If I scrapped the ram and replaced it with 2 sticks of PC6400 or better ram, and overclocked, what percentage of gain in terms of boot speed and run speed might I expect
If I shot for only 3 GHZ processor speed stable? I know the e5200 can hit 4 GHZ on air, but I am not greedy. And free speed is free speed.
4. Or should I leave well enough alone?
amd X2 4000+ processor, an OS of XP pro, and a MSI board that did not support overclocking. It was stable for a little over a year, then all of a sudden my computer developed a habit of crashing, and losing the entire OS in the process. So I replaced the Sata HDD, memtest 86 showed no ram errors, so I reinstalled the OS, and 4 days later it lost the OS. Did it again and it waited another 5 days to totally lose the OS. I should also specify I very good power supply that tested slightly above spec, temperatures were all normal, and had reloaded boas stock settings.
So I took it to a computer shop to find out what was wrong, and the computer shop was baffled also. So they gave it back to me, I again had to reinstall the OS, and it lasted another 4 days before crashing and losing the OS.
At that point I bit the bullet figuring its was motherboard or processor. So I had the computer shop, replace the mobo with a GA-g31m-es2l motherboard and an intel e5200 processor, got my windows XP pro full OS reinstalled, and now it looks like I again have a stable computer.
My original one GB of ram was not compatible with the new board, but my computer shop gave me a single stick of new kingston 2 GB ps5300 ram they had laying around as a free sample. Did I forget to mention the computer shop I dealt with was owned by a honest man?
Right now the new computer runs at the specified 2.5 GHZ, even though its smoothly downclocks to a 6x multiplier under no load. At idle real temps shows a CPU idle temp of 37C, it goes up to never more than 55C running prime 95, adn no alarms for HDD temps or other problems. Video and sound are on board and I have no need for faster video or
better sound.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now that the boundary conditions are out of the way, I have some over clocking questions
I wish to pursue on only a beer budget.
1. Since my big bottle neck seems to be the only Pc5300 ram, what kind of a percentage gain could I expect to see ( In terms of boot speed or run speed ) if I added another stick of identical ram thus allowing me to use the dual channel DDR2 the board is capable of?
2. Would it be worth me trying to try a mild overclock the this computer with only PC5300 ram. Or will I rapidly hit a wall where its not worth it?
3. If I scrapped the ram and replaced it with 2 sticks of PC6400 or better ram, and overclocked, what percentage of gain in terms of boot speed and run speed might I expect
If I shot for only 3 GHZ processor speed stable? I know the e5200 can hit 4 GHZ on air, but I am not greedy. And free speed is free speed.
4. Or should I leave well enough alone?
