Question omg really who needs to overclock??

funboy6942

Lifer
Nov 13, 2001
15,295
391
126
I did a build for a kid that is HUGE into Fortnite, but wanted me to build him a computer "cheap" so he can have the high frames needed, we searched and got him a 240hz monitor, my X570 board, my 3200mhx 32gb ram, my 1st 6700 I had after I sold my 5700xt and after doing the boy a solid, meaning I sold him everything in my case at no profit, just so he did not have to wait for all the parts to come in, for he was heading to a tournament and needed right away, so I sold for what I could find then and wait for to replace pretty much with the same stuff I sold him because I loved what I had and did things pretty well, and at 1080P with the game as low as it could go (its how he liked to play for he wanted the frames).

Well he contacted me and told me he was selling his "system" parts to a family member, and wanted advice as to what cpu he should get on the "cheap" that would be better and I told him the 5600X, for I been watching video after video of that chip and the 6700xt and how a beast of a system it would be if he did, and anything after the 5600x would be more towards the editing side of things, but he did not listen and showed up yesterday for us to build it together and brought a 5900x :O

This was fine, so we slapped it into his new 400 buck mobo he sourced for 250, fired it up, and nothing. DUH, asked about this new mobo, he got it cheap off a dude, that bough 2 in 2019, and it has sat. So we put back in his, my, old 3600x and was able to go into bios and find out that crap was old, so installed new bios. BUT before doing that we had the perfect time to do a REAL side by side between my now "new" system running pretty much the same hardware but mine is the 3900X, and his is the 3600x, so we fired up Valley (just to try) and see if we get close. And we was nut on the same running a 4K with all the rest untouched, I got a avg of 96 fps, his was 97fps.

We then installed his 5900x to see then whats what, AND DAMN!!!!!! Just putting in that chip, nothing else changed, with bios at default settings, 199 avg FPS!!!! For a $500 upgrade, got 100 more frames, you could not do that if you went from the 6700xt to a 3090, and YES if he had this chip and a 6800, 6900 this would be even faster, but what I am saying is for only $500, and changing a cpu, I have NEVER seen changing a cpu out get that many fps jump between a single generation.

So we fired up his fortnite, ready to go holy poo man look at them fps's! and max was a lousy 150 if lucky, and this is at 1080P as low as it can run at. And then it hit me, DUH, Ryzen master and chipset drivers, and the newest video drivers (beta). Spent another half hour with that, fired back up Fortnite, and he told me he was getting around 200-300fps on the old system, running in these settings, and there was times, this time, fps was hitting 1100fps! And it really never dipped under 600, so why in the world would one need to overclock anymore, if you happen to own a 6700xt or 6XXXxT anything, and drop in a 5xxx series cpu with it, and see the massive amounts of FPS gains you would get on the cough cough cheap, vs buying a hella expensive video card but say keeping ur 3600(X), I really do not think we would of seen 100+ fps diff if he went from say the 6700XT to a 6900XT, and if he did, it would of cold well over the $500 he spent on the 3900X CPU gaining then just as much if he just upgraded his GPU to anything else. If I could ever sell my 3900X off and get what I been wanting for a while now which is the 5600X, I can report back then what gaming gains you may get going from a 5600X to a 5900X, and see how much of a FPS gain you would get then, for between my old 3600x vs my now 3900X, there was ZERO diff in "gaming/Valley" between the two.

I ended up with that 3900x, though wanted a 5600X myself, and man I need to sell my 3900X on the cheap so I can upgrade for I still am going WOW, for even in the 4k valley to be at 199fps, from 97 fps, just changing out the cpu, just WOW, and yes I did the tests on both 3 times and to a avg of the 3 tests to come out with that FPS avg for both systems, so apples to apples at first, runnit at the same time, hitting the F9 key at the same tome so I could see then, almost exact while running what each is hitting at till it was over. So no gaming better going past a 3600X to a 3900X, but I would be able to edit, and compress stuff super faster then that 3600X, but for the gaming side of things, 100+ fps, going from a 3600X to a 5900X, :O :O :O :O :O
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: scineram

legcramp

Golden Member
May 31, 2005
1,671
113
116
Well to be fair, anything before the Ryzen 5000 series was a turd for competitive gaming unless you're in the "Oh uppp the video resolution and graphic settings and they'll all run at 60fps 4k settings in cyberpunk don't upgrade CPU" crowd :p
 

VirtualLarry

No Lifer
Aug 25, 2001
56,327
10,034
126
Yeah, the 5900X is pretty-much the bee's knees, I think. I have two of them.

Unfortunately, it crashes/reboots on me when mining, and throttles when doing PrimeGrid (DC) work. But I think my 240mm AIO LC is busted, because I don't hear it anymore.
 

Leeea

Diamond Member
Apr 3, 2020
3,617
5,363
136
I have had a 5900x for a while now, and have been very happy with the results.

But I am under the impression a 5600x would yield similar performance in gaming.
 

Shmee

Memory & Storage, Graphics Cards Mod Elite Member
Super Moderator
Sep 13, 2008
7,400
2,437
146
5900X and 5800X should be better overall in gaming vs the 5600X due to extra cores, which some games do like, but also they should generally boost higher. Overclocking in the old sense doesn't really make sense on these CPUs, but you can get better performance from memory tuning, as well as better performance and efficiency from tweaking the CPU voltage curve and power limit.

Now any 5000 series Ryzen should be a nice boost in gaming over the 3000 series, due to higher clocks, but also better architecture.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bononos

bigboxes

Lifer
Apr 6, 2002
38,575
11,968
146
Well, I went from i7 4790K (Devil's Canyon) to R9 5950X in April. I thought I had a pretty badass rig back in 2014. Made me glad AMD was back.

But I think my 240mm AIO LC is busted, because I don't hear it anymore.

I used a CoolerMaster 240mm AIO back in my Devil's Canyon rig. I remember hearing the pump whine early on. That's why I decided to go with the NH-D15 this time around. Just as quiet and more reliable. I wanted quiet and stability over max oc.
 
Last edited:

StinkyPinky

Diamond Member
Jul 6, 2002
6,763
783
126
I upgraded from a 3900x to a 5900x (second hand - ebay). Between selling the 3900x and getting the 5900x second hand I was only out of pocket about $100. Totally worth it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DAPUNISHER

funboy6942

Lifer
Nov 13, 2001
15,295
391
126
5900X and 5800X should be better overall in gaming vs the 5600X due to extra cores, which some games do like, but also they should generally boost higher. Overclocking in the old sense doesn't really make sense on these CPUs, but you can get better performance from memory tuning, as well as better performance and efficiency from tweaking the CPU voltage curve and power limit.

Now any 5000 series Ryzen should be a nice boost in gaming over the 3000 series, due to higher clocks, but also better architecture.


Thats what I was trying to say in all that crap I wrote. If you have the 3000 series like I do, do NOT save ur money and buy a better graphics card, buy a 5000 series card, and the gain for price is sooooooooooooooo much better. SOMEONE BUY MY 3900X if you need to do editing and "light" gaming ;) I do not do much of that anymore, but upgraded my gear, and need some oomph more then editing crap with these 12 cores :O

NOW, I mentioned I have the 6700XT, and got it for I sold my 5700xt 2 weeks before China went in and took the farms, that made video cards then go way down (sorta) but to a point when what I sold my 5700 for, I was able to buy a new then 6700XT and was paid $50 profit to do it, and then as we all know what happened after, and now they are up there around a grand. The 6700 got a bad rap since day one, but I never felt they were bad, for I felt the change in gen between my 5700 was pretty good vs the price it vs others. But then I say videos of the 5600X paired with the 6700XT and was like WTH! No friggin way is there that much of a fps jump, and had been watching them since, till last weekend when the kid wanted the upgrade I had mentioned when he bought my system, with my old 3600x and 6700XT in it, and my gosh people, its days later, and I have never seen that, and I only got to test what fps diff there was with that benchmark and single game (yeah I know Fortnite, but he went from 300~ to over 1100 at times), but if valley, all running the same rez n all was over a 100% fps jump (and I feel I screwed up and there was more then this for at that time I had not installed the ryzen master or chipset drivers), well dang, hmm, $300-600 for a cpu and pair it with my 6700xt, or keep my 3900x selling my 6700xt, try and save for 3090TI and then get 100 more fps with my 3900 spending $2000+. I like spending $300 diff and replace my cpu and get 3090ti speed upgrade. Then few years later pop in a 6900XT :D and years after that, the 7600XT and so forth since, please tell me if I am wrong and you made it this far, that the 5000 series is the last for this type of socket and the 5000 cpu series is going to be on the newer socket with pins in it like intel, so pretty much this board is maxed out as far as a 5900X in it?
 

funboy6942

Lifer
Nov 13, 2001
15,295
391
126
I upgraded from a 3900x to a 5900x (second hand - ebay). Between selling the 3900x and getting the 5900x second hand I was only out of pocket about $100. Totally worth it.

So what kind of fps jump did you get with that X570? Was it around as massive as it was going from a 3600x to a 5900x on his 6700xt?