Is it odd that the stock cooler is beating a big typhoon in cooling a 1090? Im getting loads on the typhoon in the 60s now after a bios reflash and starting over. Was getting serious weirdness before. Now Im getting temps trough the roof. I have reseated the BT 5 times today-day off- and with 4 different pastes getting questionable loads. Switched over the the stock to see if something is up with my BT and sure enough the stock cooler did a couple of degrees better. Oh well switching to something better.
In my experience, the BT needs different airflow that a standard L-shape tower to work. It also likes fans with a lot of static pressure. There are situations where you can have excellent case airflow from front to back but kill the BT's performance by giving it a fan with poor static pressure and by forcing it to pull in air at a 90 degree angle just to breathe.
Not to say that you're doing anything wrong, really, it's just that it wants a vent and an air guide in the side of the case, or some really aggressive case fans blowing directly down onto it. Or an open-sided case.
Lets see I have a Zalman 9700NT on a shelf thats never been opened. I have two scythe Ninjas that I think wont work this board. I have a Corsair H50 that I pulled from a HTPC. I have a megahalems that I would have to mod to work.
I would go with the H50 in that situation. The Megahalems would perform better, but mods can be a hassle sometimes.
What cooler should I use? The mega is a last resort since I would have to buy a plate and mod it.... I dont know why I have such a aversion to the 9700 but I would have thought the BT would have cooled better.
The h50. The 9700NT kinda sucks (just don't let JediYoda catch me saying that). The BT can be awesome with the right fans and with a good top-down cooling setup, but for most builds that just isn't feasible given current trends in case design. Also, sadly, the BT is fairly limited in the total heat load it can handle; anything beyond 130W and its sketchy. It really does hail from a different era, which is why it was fine (if not awesome) when cooling my x2-3600+ with an open-sided case but why it might suck cooling an x6.
If AMD is shipping the same stock HSF it shipped with Phenom IIs, then it is the AVC Z7U7414001. For point of reference, check out this test of the IceAge Boss II on frostytech's AMD test platform to see how the Z7U7414001 stacked up against a huge number of other heatsinks:
http://www.frostytech.com/articleview.cfm?articleid=2461&page=4
That should give you a pretty good idea of why the BT might have had problems cooling better than the stock AVC HSF. It makes a lot of noise, but dammit, it works.