McKenzie: Who goes after Crosby?
TSN.ca Staff
6/29/2005
The top prospect in the belated 2005 NHL entry draft is indisputable, so the big questions are who's going to get the No. 1 choice overall and take Sidney Crosby, and who'll be drafted No. 2 behind Sid the Kid.
The draft lottery will answer the first question and maybe the second as well, because individual team preference is likely going to be the determining factor in who goes No. 2.
If the team picking second wants a rough and tumble, ultra-competitive defenceman who can make things happen offensively, then it will be Jack Johnson of the U.S. national under-18 program.
If the team choosing second wants a big, skilled forward with slick moves and great wheels, then it will be late bloomer Benoit Pouliot of the Sudbury Wolves.
If the team with the second pick is willing to overlook his awkward skating style and wants a big, power forward who drives the net and finishes with authority, well, then, American Bobby Ryan of the Owen Sound Attack is the man.
Those three players were the only prospects who received consideration as the next best thing to Crosby in TSN's annual draft ranking, which is based on a survey of scouting representatives from 10 NHL clubs.
TSN's consensus No. 2 pick is Johnson, the bruising blueliner who played prep school hockey with Crosby at Shattuck-St. Mary's.
But there is also considerable support for Pouliot as No. 2. A late 1986 birthdate, Pouliot, TSN's No. 3, is a year older than the others but scouts are excited over his skill set.
Ryan was the only other player to get No. 2 consideration, but not to the same extent as the other two, so he checks in at No. 4 on our list.
The only other players with an outside shot at No. 2 would appear to be No. 5 ranked Slovenian big man Anze Kopitar, a forward who played junior hockey in Sweden this season, or ultra-aggressive offensive presence Gilbert Brule of the Vancouver Giants, who battles like a big man despite his 5-foot-10, 175-pound frame.
Kopitar was ranked as high as No. 3 by one team and Brule's best was a No. 4 ranking.
The draft lottery to determine this year's order of selection is expected to have a huge impact on how things play out for the prospects in this year's draft class. That is to suggest this is a year in which there are wildly divergent views on the prospects, that once you get past the top six or seven prospects, different teams have significantly different takes on the players available.
Take Chicoutimi forward Marek Zagrapan, for instance. Two NHL clubs surveyed by TSN have him in the top 10. Two other clubs rate him as a borderline first rounder; or Swedish prospect Nicklas Bergfors, who some teams have no higher than a second-round pick while others see him as a solid shot to go in the top 20; or Guelph defenceman Ryan Parent, who one team has a top 10 pick while another has him as second rounder; which pretty much sums up Andrew Cogliano of the Jr. A St. Mike's Buzzers.
The first round will be filled with those types of divergent opinions, so the order of selection, at this point unknown, will have a huge bearing on whether the players who are touted as first rounders actually go in the first round.
There's always an element of that in any draft, but rest assured the personal preference factor is higher this year than it has been at any time in the last 10 years, so we shouldn't be surprised if, after the first five or six selections, teams go "off the board" for their respective picks.
But at the end of the day, whenever that day may be, this will be Sidney Crosby's draft.
Cheers,
Aquaman
TSN.ca Staff
6/29/2005
The top prospect in the belated 2005 NHL entry draft is indisputable, so the big questions are who's going to get the No. 1 choice overall and take Sidney Crosby, and who'll be drafted No. 2 behind Sid the Kid.
The draft lottery will answer the first question and maybe the second as well, because individual team preference is likely going to be the determining factor in who goes No. 2.
If the team picking second wants a rough and tumble, ultra-competitive defenceman who can make things happen offensively, then it will be Jack Johnson of the U.S. national under-18 program.
If the team choosing second wants a big, skilled forward with slick moves and great wheels, then it will be late bloomer Benoit Pouliot of the Sudbury Wolves.
If the team with the second pick is willing to overlook his awkward skating style and wants a big, power forward who drives the net and finishes with authority, well, then, American Bobby Ryan of the Owen Sound Attack is the man.
Those three players were the only prospects who received consideration as the next best thing to Crosby in TSN's annual draft ranking, which is based on a survey of scouting representatives from 10 NHL clubs.
TSN's consensus No. 2 pick is Johnson, the bruising blueliner who played prep school hockey with Crosby at Shattuck-St. Mary's.
But there is also considerable support for Pouliot as No. 2. A late 1986 birthdate, Pouliot, TSN's No. 3, is a year older than the others but scouts are excited over his skill set.
Ryan was the only other player to get No. 2 consideration, but not to the same extent as the other two, so he checks in at No. 4 on our list.
The only other players with an outside shot at No. 2 would appear to be No. 5 ranked Slovenian big man Anze Kopitar, a forward who played junior hockey in Sweden this season, or ultra-aggressive offensive presence Gilbert Brule of the Vancouver Giants, who battles like a big man despite his 5-foot-10, 175-pound frame.
Kopitar was ranked as high as No. 3 by one team and Brule's best was a No. 4 ranking.
The draft lottery to determine this year's order of selection is expected to have a huge impact on how things play out for the prospects in this year's draft class. That is to suggest this is a year in which there are wildly divergent views on the prospects, that once you get past the top six or seven prospects, different teams have significantly different takes on the players available.
Take Chicoutimi forward Marek Zagrapan, for instance. Two NHL clubs surveyed by TSN have him in the top 10. Two other clubs rate him as a borderline first rounder; or Swedish prospect Nicklas Bergfors, who some teams have no higher than a second-round pick while others see him as a solid shot to go in the top 20; or Guelph defenceman Ryan Parent, who one team has a top 10 pick while another has him as second rounder; which pretty much sums up Andrew Cogliano of the Jr. A St. Mike's Buzzers.
The first round will be filled with those types of divergent opinions, so the order of selection, at this point unknown, will have a huge bearing on whether the players who are touted as first rounders actually go in the first round.
There's always an element of that in any draft, but rest assured the personal preference factor is higher this year than it has been at any time in the last 10 years, so we shouldn't be surprised if, after the first five or six selections, teams go "off the board" for their respective picks.
But at the end of the day, whenever that day may be, this will be Sidney Crosby's draft.
Cheers,
Aquaman