I have never seen Michal offer support that didn't amount to a complete non-sequitur. He rarely draws his own inferences and conclusions, he parrots the ones he finds on extremist sites, and when he does attempt to draw his own they are so stupid they are painful to read. I think you vastly overestimate his capacity.
There's no doubt he's swimming in Kool-aid and seeks only to convince himself that his Kool-aid is the only "true ocean," but his vocabulary seems richer and his bullet-point -type posts seems to indicate that there is logical activity present.
I'm not saying he's |smart|. If this is me:
...michal is pretty much:
It may not be much in an absolute sense and he won't get anywhere the way he's currently using it, but at least there's the possibility of getting an appraising *ting ting ting* out of the tool.
This is how I see Matt:
He gets more out of it than michal does from his because he uses it better. But going by the feedback from his tool he's always gonna be fuzzy on the details.
It's quite possible that michal will do nothing but fortify the house of lies he's made for himself, hiding cognitive dissonance in shadows and contrasting paint schemes such that he will die a small-minded, bitter man; and so Matt will have achieved more up to the point he is now than michal will have in his entire life; but if we're talking about potential, I'd rate michal's higher.
Meanwhile, it seems to me that Matt fully understands all of these concepts but is limited by apathy.
I see stupidity where you see apathy. Intelligence can't help but peek out occasionally. A smart person just can't help but put things together, and this comes out in what they say and how they say it.
Even if their premises are fiction they're still working at a high level to assemble them. Matt? I detect no peaks. Just constant output at an elementary school level.
Matt isn't limited to partisan thinking so there's a wider range to his output; but height? He never goes above some very low platforms, and remains baffled that there's anything higher even when you break out the kindergartners' stepladder.