alkemyst
No Lifer
Chaco Flip-Flops are awesome. I've had them for 5+ years and they are barely broken in. They may cost 2-3x as much as Reefs, but they last forever.
If your sandals are lasting you 5+ years and barely broken in, you don't get out much.
If one is looking for sandals, hit up a IWS or any beach-local surf shop and you usually can't go wrong.
Tevas are very popular for a very good reason.