Seems I posted just a bit too soon in that last post. You at least here show your thought process, and it is not all wrong.
He started to punishing China for dumping products
I agree he was at least trying to do that, but he failed miserably because he does not have a good grasp on how international trade works, and would not listen to anyone that disagreed with him.
I actually support the idea he was going for here, but I can't see that anything was actually accomplished but hurting our own economy at least as much as it hurt China's. And since China is a totalitarian regime it was always going to be less effective against them then us. Simply put China can suffer through more bad times then the US without the people getting pissed off and throwing the leaders out of office.
he greatly slowed illegal immigration
At least he said he did, I don't see any real numbers that would back that up. That is a theme with Trump, he made a lot of claims that he never really produced.
he had a pretty solid goal of energy independence
There is almost no difference in energy independence from the end of Trump's Presidency as there is today.
We have imported oil every year since 1940. We have exported more then we imported every year since 2019, and still export about the same today.
We have exported more energy then we use domestically since 2020, and that number has almost nothing to do with Trump policies since it has been a nearly linear curve leading to that since the around 2010, due mostly to the fracking boom, and has not significantly decreased in the Biden Administration. Overall, Trumps energy policy made almost no impact on America's energy independence, it happened under his administration but was mostly a result of policy made in earlier administrations.
Overall there has been no real significant change in energy independence under Biden, but I think some of Biden's policies could lead to more energy independence in the future, something I can't say for Trump as his policies as they were aimed at propping up old industries and even not really effective at that.