Timmyotule,
I have the FIC9500 Pro card from newegg and it works great for me. I am CPU limited I think, running an AMD 1.4G t-bird, but I can play Q3 with all settings maxed with no slowdowns at all. You would do good to get the Zalman heatpipe cooler, I have one on the way because the fan on this card is fairly loud.
EDIT: BTW redwolf321, prior to getting the 9500, I purchased a saphire 9000Pro from newegg and it sucked big time. Would only do agp2x with no fast writes, and gave off this burning smell. But since it was newegg I RMA'd it with no problem. Don't know if all the saphire cards are like that, maybe I just got a bad one.