• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

My 5 year old just got sent to the Dean's office for saying "I'll kill you"

Page 5 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

So what age would it not be acceptable for a kid to say "i'll kill you!!!!"

8 years old?? 10 years old???


also wondering if the kid's teacher used red ink in class....
 
Originally posted by: WhiteKnight
Originally posted by: CPA
Originally posted by: WhiteKnight
Unfortunately it's a sad state of affairs that we are living with regarding violence in schools. That having been said, I don't think that the teacher was out of line at all. There have been cases within the past few years where children of your son's age actually have shot and killed people at school. Is it unfortunate and somewhat ridiculous to treat a five year old like that? Yes. Did the teacher do the right thing? Unfornately, I'd also say yes. Imagine how you'd feel if your son were killed by some other kid who made similar statements that were undocumented and just handled by the teacher in the classroom.

Please link a news story of a 5 year old purposely shooting kids at school.

Here's the one I was thinking about. It was a 6 year old.

link
link
link

so there was a "case" of a problem 7 year old shooting a classmate who was shown by a 17 year old on how to use a gun. While I appreciate the attempt to back up your claim, this type of situation was a one time exception. Plus, sunnyD's child has not had a history of bad behavior and violence like this kid did. Not to mention the 2 year age difference which is huge in children's brain development.
 
Originally posted by: Zebo
pfft..I don't call lucrative $24,000 (starting pay in our PSD) but to each his own... all you need is a baccalaureate degree in pretty much anything. Hell you can get 3x + more lucrative in governemnt fields with same benies and not even a degree...PO, FF, iron worker etc// and prolly less dangerous too, what with school shootings and all.😛
There is a STEEP salary climb., which gets to an average of $53,535 in my district, which just got out of state receivership.

They also get SERS or STRS, instead of our POS, Social Security crap:
  • All School District employees are covered by the state-wide School Employees Retirement System of Ohio (SERS) or the State Teachers Retirement System (STRS).
Can't fire 'em without an Act of Congress, no matter how much they suck, and their work days aren't sh\t:
  • On the other hand, it is apparent that teachers are counting every minute they are at school in reporting their workweek. Since teachers report working 38 hours a week at school during the school day and most district contracts specify that teachers? entire school day runs about seven and a half hours ? or about 37 to 38 hours a week ? it is clear that the reported working day includes lunch breaks and preparation periods. If teachers use much of their lunch break and preparation period to relax, eat lunch, and socialize ? which is the norm in my experience as it is in almost any line of work ? they are actually teaching, planning, and grading about six and a half hours a day in school, or about 33 hours a week. Accepting at face value teachers? self-reports about their workload at home and with students after school, the typical teacher is working about 45 hours a week, all told. This is perfectly respectable but hardly unusual. - Text
My dad is a retired teacher, so I KNOW how much effort is, and isn't put into lesson plans and grading papers.
 
Boy you really done your HW, go for it!!! I bet you'd have good students, long as some parent does'nt sue you for browbeating one of thier children.😛
 
Originally posted by: MrChad
Originally posted by: Ornery
Hah, teaching sounds "worth it" to me! Between the teacher's union & tenure, assuring you a lucrative, 180 day work year, wage increases no matter what financial state the school is in, and not having to pay into the F'ed up SS system, it would totally be worth putting up with a little friction!

Teachers do get three months off, but they also work about 60 hours a week when you include lesson planning and grading papers and tests.

Sometimes more than 60... well more than 60.

Since I just finished a graduate class on this very issue, allow me to summarize $2000 worth of education:

It's not completely about safety and the fear of columbine...
It's about the fear of lawsuits in a very litigious society. Such comments = automatically sent to office. Otherwise, suppose the kid is still mad after school (or even gets mad over a completely separate incident that occurs later) - you've got 20 witnesses that student A threatened student B, even if it seemed harmless; but following a fight, and a parent looking for easy $$$, you've got a lawsuit.

I was amazed at the number of lawsuits brought up against schools. I didn't know before. There are people out there who see schools as an easy target for suits.
 
Another fine example of public school education.

Tell your kid that what he said was wrong and leave it at that. Your kid didn't even know what it meant! I remember saying something like that to my mom once, except it was like "i'll kill the teacher" or something. I didn't even know what it meant until my mom told me not to say it and explained what it was.
 
unfortunately, that's the world we live in.

hopefully, the school doesn't get out of hand and do anything drastic.

the way i see this situation, the parents should sit down with their kids and parents on both sides should communicate with each other and the teacher. no reason to blow this out of proportion. in kindergarten, kids could pick up this kind of language just watching Cartoon Network.
 
Yep - so now my son knows of a new way to get even more attention. Thank you muchly to the school for emphasizing a behavior we don't want.
 
Originally posted by: SunnyD
Yep - so now my son knows of a new way to get even more attention. Thank you muchly to the school for emphasizing a behavior we don't want.

Yes, blame the school. You can't possibly take personal responsibility for your parenting, can you?
 
Originally posted by: DAGTA
Originally posted by: SunnyD
Yep - so now my son knows of a new way to get even more attention. Thank you muchly to the school for emphasizing a behavior we don't want.

Yes, blame the school. You can't possibly take personal responsibility for your parenting, can you?

No, I blame you exclusively for his behavior. Did you even read the OP or are you just here to nef?
 
Originally posted by: CPA
Originally posted by: WhiteKnight
Originally posted by: CPA
Originally posted by: WhiteKnight
Unfortunately it's a sad state of affairs that we are living with regarding violence in schools. That having been said, I don't think that the teacher was out of line at all. There have been cases within the past few years where children of your son's age actually have shot and killed people at school. Is it unfortunate and somewhat ridiculous to treat a five year old like that? Yes. Did the teacher do the right thing? Unfornately, I'd also say yes. Imagine how you'd feel if your son were killed by some other kid who made similar statements that were undocumented and just handled by the teacher in the classroom.

Please link a news story of a 5 year old purposely shooting kids at school.

Here's the one I was thinking about. It was a 6 year old.

link
link
link

so there was a "case" of a problem 7 year old shooting a classmate who was shown by a 17 year old on how to use a gun. While I appreciate the attempt to back up your claim, this type of situation was a one time exception. Plus, sunnyD's child has not had a history of bad behavior and violence like this kid did. Not to mention the 2 year age difference which is huge in children's brain development.

4 year old
5 year old
Another 4 year old

I'm not saying that this is a common occurence by any means. I'm just saying that it's possible and the teacher shouldn't be blamed. This is why zero tolerance policies are called zero tolerance. I don't know anything about the school that the OP's son attends, but perhaps they have already had staff training that directs teachers to pass up cases like this.
 
Originally posted by: SunnyD
Now seriously, kindergarten, 5 year old... why the hell was this not handled in the classroom by the teacher? Especially if the context was playing (which at this point the whole context is still uncertain).


whatever, your stupid kid deserved to be sent to the principal's office. now he learns how serious this kind of thing is. what if another kid threatened to kill your son?
 
Originally posted by: MrChad
Originally posted by: Ornery
Hah, teaching sounds "worth it" to me! Between the teacher's union & tenure, assuring you a lucrative, 180 day work year, wage increases no matter what financial state the school is in, and not having to pay into the F'ed up SS system, it would totally be worth putting up with a little friction!

Teachers do get three months off, but they also work about 60 hours a week when you include lesson planning and grading papers and tests.

No, good teachers work 60 hours per week.
 
My little cousin would say sh!t, it was one of the few words in her limited vocabulary. But once she'd yell it out, she'd giggle because all the adults would look at her. She didn't know what it meant, she just knew she'd get attention if she said it.
 
wow. you want to be quick to blame the school system for the sh!t spewing out of your own kid's mouth?

never once in my entire upbringing have i ever uttered the words, "I'll kill you."

work with your kid and stop blaming the damn school system.

you're pissing me off for passing the blame here.
 
Oh please, stop trying to blame the school for your own lack of parenting skills. As kids sure we all said dumb stuff, but I doubt that anyone here has ever said "I'll kill you" in KINDERGARTEN! You and your wife apparently need to learn how to watch your mouths around your kid. Speaking of which, why in the hell is your wife saying "I'll kill you" in the first place?

Theres 1 teacher and 25+ children. They spend about 1 hour per WEEKDAY, while you spend hours with your child individually everyday. At least I hope you are. Teachers are there to educate your children with necessary SCHOOL skills. They aren't there to babysit your child and bring them up for you. Its your own damn responsiblity to discipline your child and FURTHER educate your child on what he should and shouldn't say.

It's hilarious how all the people here are quick to blame the school for becoming so political correct. How about parents do their own damn job because then the school wouldn't have to deal with such BS in the first place. Problems at school are more often than not a result of problems at HOME. Everyone is quick to the blame school system for failing in educating children when they should be looking at themselves.
 
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: sygyzy
Home schooling does look attractive. Look into it, for everyone's sake.

Yeah, you are pretty much guaranteed that your kid will grow up knowing less than you do.

Another misconception.
 
20 or 30 years ago this would be no big deal. But 20 or 30 years ago 5 year children didn't kill people, and these days there have been incidents of children at that age killing playmates. I certainly would feel uncomfortable if my 5 year old came home and told me that another kid said he was going to kill him. I would be pissed.....🙁
 
Originally posted by: Dragnov
Oh please, stop trying to blame the school for your own lack of parenting skills. As kids sure we all said dumb stuff, but I doubt that anyone here has ever said "I'll kill you" in KINDERGARTEN! You and your wife apparently need to learn how to watch your mouths around your kid. Speaking of which, why in the hell is your wife saying "I'll kill you" in the first place?

Theres 1 teacher and 25+ children. They spend about 1 hour per WEEKDAY, while you spend hours with your child individually everyday. At least I hope you are. Teachers are there to educate your children with necessary SCHOOL skills. They aren't there to babysit your child and bring them up for you. Its your own damn responsiblity to discipline your child and FURTHER educate your child on what he should and shouldn't say.

It's hilarious how all the people here are quick to blame the school for becoming so political correct. How about parents do their own damn job because then the school wouldn't have to deal with such BS in the first place. Problems at school are more often than not a result of problems at HOME. Everyone is quick to the blame school system for failing in educating children when they should be looking at themselves.

And you obviously aren't a parent either.

I will be the first to admit my parenting skills aren't perfect. Then again, if anyone ever does, I will call them a liar immediately. However such language is not used in my home, and never has been - as new evidence brings to light. However, I do entrust my son to the school system from 8am to 3pm on a daily basis. The school is responsible for his wellbeing AND his behavior during those hours.

So no, you're right. The school is not a baby sitter. It is infact a surrogate parent during those hours, which is supposed to at least be supporting my role as a parent.
 
I agree that teachers these days are so eager to jump the gun and not talk to the parents first. I have a friend who has kids and this one time one of the kids a 4 year old happend to find one match and lit it up to show his brother and sisters.
The kid that was in kindergarten talked to the teacher that he saw a match light up and the teacher jumped the gun and called child services on them. They were under child services monitor for 6 months (a child services visits and stay with them for about 2 hours everyday for 6 months teaching them how to parent kids) and another 6 months kinda of like on probation saying that they don't know how to take care of their children.

I was just thinking why was this not taken up with the parents first to let them know that one of their kids talked about it in class. I mean how stupid is that. Wouldn't you want to confirm it with the parents or talk to the parents about it first before even calling child services on them just because a kid said something that either A, was true or B, making up stories or C, a different story as to what happended. Maybe the kid was lighting a birthday cake for all they know. But they will believe a kid rather then a grown up. How sad these days. 🙁

How about this, heres a good idea. Find someone you really hate with kids. Pay the kid to lie to a teacher or cop about the parents sexually abusing them, touching them, abusing them, doing nasty stuff to them, etc.. With all these eager gun jumper the those people that you hate will definately go to jail. Problem solve to get rid of people you hate. 🙂

But anyways,

I guess there is alot of dumb people in this world instead of people that uses common sense first. It's kind of like guilty until proven innocent and not innocent until proven guilty.

I guess the world is just coming to an end or something nowadays.
 
Originally posted by: nakedfrog
You should have blamed it on him watching Full Metal Jacket every day before bed 😛

haha yeah have the kid grab his junk and yell "THIS IS MY RIFLE THIS IS MY GUN, THIS IS FOR FIGHTING THIS IS FOR FUN!"
 
Back
Top