Where do you even begin debunking such utter bullshit?
I'll just say that I incorporate the best of both bodybuilding and powerlifting into my routines and go in cycles. A decent example of such a core principle is Bradley Martyn. This dude is an absolute beast when it comes to squats and deads and yet has a thin waist, low bodyfat and an aesthetic build as well.
![]()
Yet some bodybuilders do place less importance on lifting heavy vs. aesthetics and mass. I'd say powerlifters on average exploit Newton's second law by opting to use fat as mass over muscle. Except muscle is more dense than fat, so it only gets one so far.
BTW, those pure powerlifters develop injuries faster and their larger core actually represents fattier internal organs. No thanks. I'd way rather have a lower bodyfat percentage with a greater percentage of testosterone vs estrogen as a male.
Where do you even begin debunking such utter bullshit?
I'll just say that I incorporate the best of both bodybuilding and powerlifting into my routines and go in cycles. A decent example of such a core principle is Bradley Martyn. This dude is an absolute beast when it comes to squats and deads and yet has a thin waist, low bodyfat and an aesthetic build as well.
![]()
Yet some bodybuilders do place less importance on lifting heavy vs. aesthetics and mass. I'd say powerlifters on average exploit Newton's second law by opting to use fat as mass over muscle. Except muscle is more dense than fat, so it only gets one so far.
BTW, those pure powerlifters develop injuries faster and their larger core actually represents fattier internal organs. No thanks. I'd way rather have a lower bodyfat percentage with a greater percentage of testosterone vs estrogen as a male.
If you still can't judge whether someone's on gear from the above criteria, simply compare his stats to another steroid user.
Bradley Martyn is 6'3, 260lbs, ~5% bodyfat.
Arnold Schwarzenegger in his prime was 6'2, 235lbs, 5-7% bodyfat.
So Bradley has over 30lbs more lean muscle mass than arguably the greatest bodybuilder of all-time...naturally? Probably not.
Uhh that guy is not natty. The internet hath spoken:
Why don't you see more men with the "Mr. Universe" type in powerlifting competitions, then?
Personal Preference doesn't take precedence over nature.
Uhh that guy is not natty. The internet hath spoken:
After all I wrote, the best you have is a mostly irrelevant lowest common denominator two-second quora search. For someone to even say that Bradley is @ 5% bf immediately discounts their opinion and has never seen 5% bodyfat in person. But yeah, he's part of a growing trend of combo bodybuilder/powerlifter types.
I go back and forth on whether Bradley is *completely* natural or not. But the dude is extremely tall at 6'3" has been lifting for over a decade as a *lifestyle* and has lots of place to store muscle. He basically eats, lifts and sleeps then repeats and gets mostly everything right.
Although here's another utube powerlift/bodybuild dude who can lift extremely heavy (based in ratio to his body weight) who has mostly poor execution and very little to show for it. He has neither a powerlifter of bodybuilder physique with basically twigs for arms and legs. I see a ton of guys like him in my gym who lift extremely heavy with poor form and still have small muscles.
https://www.youtube.com/user/maxxchewning/
And you cannot compare Bradley or any modern bodybuilder to an old-school guy anyway. In Schwarzenegger's day, bodybuilding was still mostly taboo and they didn't have the sheer amount of lifting awareness, knowledge, supplements and equipment of this generation. It's not even close.
Machines were also taboo back then and most serious guys scoffed at Nautilus, now those machines are everywhere. Part of the reason I was able to gain such mass was due to those machines, including great devices like Hammer Strength. I can lift way heavier without worrying about injury, like you would with free weights..
I'm talking about people who bodybuild or powerlift for pleasure, which is totally irrelevant to what a sport demands. Bodybuilding a powerlifting have totally different ideologies. Otherwise everyone would have to be on steroids too.
SP33Demon is talking about a physical body type not an occupation. Although it sounds like sour grapes or excuses to me.
But do your own social experiment, take a picture of a powerlifter and bodybuilder under 10% bf and ask a group of girls what they prefer. Not to say you won't even find a few who even prefer a dad bods, but the result would likely be resounding in favor of the bodybuilder.
1 You can't gain pure muscle indefinitely. Lots of elite lifters are on drugs. Just recently in the IPF some guys got snagged for drug use for instance. Check out Lu Xiaojun. Also popped for drug use. Lots of bodybuilders are on drugs as well.
2 As for Maxx Chewning I'd say that's partly because he wants to stay in a weight class and partly because of genetics, no? I mean, you're talking about stereotypes...? If his form was that poor, don't you think he'd be snapped up every other week? Plenty of bigger guys can't even begin to lift on his level (600 sumo dead, 295 pause bench and 455 squat) Not to mention weight classes. He's trying to be as strong as he can be in the 165lb weight class (I think that's what I heard).
3 I can agree with the machine enabling higher weight with less risk, but why not just use the lower weight and proper form and build the movement pattern up? Not to say you can't injure yourself on a machine (smith machine comes to mind).
4 My brother does purely calisthenics and boxing. He gets all the girls, lol. Some girls and guys really don't like muscular guys (lean or not).
1) It's not about building muscle indefinitely as much as exploring the boundaries of your own body. The increases might be getting more incremental, but improvements are still being made. And the science is out there to increase strength, size and recovery time without the assistance of drugs. You can get yourself within a decent range of steroids and HGH without the side effects and with enough knowledge.
2) Maxx is incredibly strong for his size; I'm not knocking him. But he hardly has anything to show for it except a very powerful central nervous system. And I think genetics are mostly bs when it comes to building size. There are several methods to employ to vastly increase contractions on pushing and pulling movements. A guy like Maxx is merely moving the weight from point a to b. His results speak volumes to this.
3) Again, I think the real thing to realize is that powerlifting is more an exercise of the central nervous system. So people who lift very heavy need more time for recovery. Therefore I go on/off between powerlifting and weightlifting. Some days I go into the gym with proper rest just wanting to see how much I can lift.
4) I agree. Women do like the superhero physique most, which means low body fat and lean muscle mass. So someone who does P90X and kickboxing might be preferred over a pure bodybuilder, who some might see as a little intimidating.
4) Most women I've met (and I'm old) do not like the unnatural, obsessive compulsive look of Mr. Olympia. It shows an extreme addictive nature which most will not equate to relationship material. In any case, red pill research has shown that women don't primarily care about physique as a top attractive indicator unless they're teenagers or early 20's (aka children). So if that is what you're aiming to attract, have at it but for all other women you better have an alpha personality and know what behavior constitutes as such.
.
1)
2) Maxx is incredibly strong for his size; I'm not knocking him. But he hardly has anything to show for it except a very powerful central nervous system. And I think genetics are mostly bs when it comes to building size. There are several methods to employ to vastly increase contractions on pushing and pulling movements. A guy like Maxx is merely moving the weight from point a to b. His results speak volumes to this.
i will just add that the more bodybuilder-like my physique becomes, the more attention I get from guys.... kind of like a lambo gets more attention from men.
women are intimidated by a guy that is "fit". they become self conscious about how they look. I have had women flat out tell me, I'd like to be with a guy like you, but would have to do it with the lights off because I would be self conscious about my body..
of course both are generalizations, but yeah, don't build the tapered physique in hopes of getting the females.
The only thing I can't go along with here is this -- he's in a specific weight class. 165lbs. Unless he decides to move up, his size will remain the same. The dude is lean so it's not like he can lose some fat and gain some muscle.
Imho, the pic above of Greg looks achievable with a decent diet and maybe a little weighted ab work. Doesn't look like much lean mass, mainly a factor lower bodyfat.
Personally I wouldn't want that build.
we are both talking about this guy here? he does not look like what I would call a bodybuilder? he just looks lean.Actually, here's the interesting part about Greg's build -- at around 8% bf as dexa measured. He obtained it through intermittent fasting (eating chocolate bars, yogurt ice cream, french fries, apples, drinking coffee etc during his feeding window) and lifting only twice a week for 45 minutes each session. lol?
But Greg's extremely proportioned with his delts being the most prominent, as it should be. Another thing he gets right is focusing on the upper chest. Other bodybuilders definitely need to take note. He incline presses almost 300lb for 6 reps and does a lot of weighted pullups - bodyweight exercises in general.
Where I disagree: he also doesn't believe in building legs much, but then it correlates with his Greek God physique goal. If I worked out for other women rather than myself, then yeah, I'd probably want that physique too.
Everyone in the gym loves to work chest and arms, very few love working the larger muscle groups like glutes, quads and back. Legs lifts are especially taxing on the central nervous system.
Here's me at 155-160 at 5'10":![]()
we are both talking about this guy here? he does not look like what I would call a bodybuilder? he just looks lean.
I have no doubt he looks lean and can make himself look bigger than he is.Yep, we're talking about the same guy. Even though that pic probably doesn't do him justice, he looks more like a bodybuilder to me than 80% of people I see at my gym. Maybe you're a member of Gold's Gym in Venice.
https://www.youtube.com/user/gog9
But again, I'd say being at 8% bf places him in the top 1 percentile of American males... with obviously very little effort. Also he is that lean all year round without any cutting or bulking cycles. Same goes for me, btw.
And until you see 8% in person, you never truly realize how much it makes muscles pop and take on a 3D look. The point being: it makes one look much larger than they really are.