Originally posted by: ntdz
I agree, I'm 100% against affirmative action.
You'd have to be an idiot to be against affirmative action.
Originally posted by: ntdz
I agree, I'm 100% against affirmative action.
Originally posted by: Forsythe
Originally posted by: ntdz
I agree, I'm 100% against affirmative action.
You'd have to be an idiot to be against affirmative action.
Originally posted by: Aelius
How about not taking money from special interest groups and treating everyone the same regardless of race, color or even language.
Point is the system is racist. Racist either against one or another group. Maybe I'm wrong but to me it seems the system is sometimes stacked against whites or even males.
Here in Canada it's also a problem but not only do we have to put up with these things but also the language issue.
What you don't speak French? Ooops you cannot apply for a whack of government jobs and you cannot be a manager almost anywhere if you don't speak French.
Although the language issue with French isn't a problem in Western Canada. Almost nobody speaks French there. It's actually more likely that you gota speak a version of Chinese to get a job or get ahead.
Natrually me saying this it probably gets perverted by some retards that I'm some sort of skinhead or KKK members.
Ummm no. How about equality? Oh right how could you ever get political contributions if all things were equal. heh
Originally posted by: BBond
Originally posted by: AnyMal
Originally posted by: BBond
No one seems to remember when "affirmative action" meant all the work went to whites.
why don't you refresh our memories?
Why don't you pick up a book on American history and READ?
Even our "national past time" wasn't open to non-whites until 1947. WTFU. Stop denying the past. And stop excusing it.
Originally posted by: Forsythe
I don't see what's wrong when making judgements based on peoples skin color. As long as there is a reason for that.
A very very large portion of crime in the states are comitted by blacks. That's why there's affirmative action, to work against the negative social heritage.
Whether it's working or not i do not know, but atleast someone is trying.
Originally posted by: stratman
Originally posted by: Forsythe
I don't see what's wrong when making judgements based on peoples skin color. As long as there is a reason for that.
A very very large portion of crime in the states are comitted by blacks. That's why there's affirmative action, to work against the negative social heritage.
Whether it's working or not i do not know, but atleast someone is trying.
The problem with making judgements based on skin colour is that those who don't fit (mis)conceptions of them will feel marginalized and may well feel wrongly accused when they are judged. It encourages the status quo. If everyone assumes I'm a criminal because of my skin colour, I may as well be one: I'll be treated the same either way.
Originally posted by: Steeplerot
Affirmitive action is a dilemma, kinda like rent control, regardless black students have been headed to black schools more now and minoritys are down in a lot of white schools.
The white students have better high schools and not the stigma of being black to deal with in a still racist country.
Axing it was not a good idea IMO. As previous poster pointed out the whites of this country made this problem.
A recent article about decline of minoritys in schools.
I am not so sure bringing it back in it's old form is the answer but tossing the idea away of reaching out a hand to underprividged americans away is pig-headed. And the whining from neocons in this country that helping make sure a balance is struck is racist in itself is nothing but more thinly veiled racist circular logic.
AA in some form is still nessasary,as racism in this country is alive and well.
just look at this forum.
Originally posted by: g8wayrebel
Originally posted by: Steeplerot
Affirmitive action is a dilemma, kinda like rent control, regardless black students have been headed to black schools more now and minoritys are down in a lot of white schools.
The white students have better high schools and not the stigma of being black to deal with in a still racist country.
Axing it was not a good idea IMO. As previous poster pointed out the whites of this country made this problem.
A recent article about decline of minoritys in schools.
I am not so sure bringing it back in it's old form is the answer but tossing the idea away of reaching out a hand to underprividged americans away is pig-headed. And the whining from neocons in this country that helping make sure a balance is struck is racist in itself is nothing but more thinly veiled racist circular logic.
AA in some form is still nessasary,as racism in this country is alive and well.
just look at this forum.
The white people in this country didn't make this problem. The slaves were taken captive and sold by native tribes(ie. Uncles and brothers of the enslaved) to the traders. The only reason it is an issue in this country and not in others is because it has been dwelled upon for decades. The issue has all but disappeared in the other nations of similar stature to the US during the slave trade days. Why is that? Concession after concession to no avail by the government and the sympathetic.. It is a drum that will comtinue to be beat as long as it yields results. As long as the drum is beating , so will be the resentment and the racist attitudes." We" didn"t do it, and we don't want to pay for it. It is a fact of world history , not US history,and should be taught as such.
AA is not necessary in this or any other civilized capitoist country. Personal responsibility and civic duty are necessary. When that is the norm in the black community , the attitudes will change and the respect will follow. You can argue and apologize all you want , but until that happens, racism will continue to be fueled by the constant "black" cry. No other race or creed in this country who has integrated into this country faces these issues today on a grandf scale. It is only the "Afro-American" members of society who seem unable( I believe unwilling ) to integrate in to the system.Even with the fallout of 9-11 on the Middle Eastern citizens , in particular the Muslim sects, have been able to maintain respect and coexist peacefully.African citizens who come here today are disgusted with what they find to be the "black community" here. It isn't really a race issue , but one of an attitude shared only by native black citizens and the sympathizers or antagonists of those very ideas. As long as the attitude is allowed to continue , so will the problems. It is used by politicians and profiteers on both sides to continue the derision and division while benefiting from it at the same time.
Here's a real breakthrough for you. How about not commiting felonies in the first place.As usual , the stats are scewed. Bring in some real numbers that represent a true segment of society by percentages, You just may learn something and maybe even realize where the attitudes come from.
How about making changes in the justice system so that the evidence actually gets presented. Screw precedent. Just because a judge in a preivious case made a bad decision shouldn't mean another judge has to follow his lead.
This country is all aboout ME! How can I get re-elected, how can I get away with what I did, how can I get what you have, how can I get rich so I don't have to work. Face it, we live in an apathetic superaffluent country. Screw you , how can I get what I want?
Of course after spouting all this you make no comment about the studies on race/jobs. A litle tougher to advance in the work force as a group when you chances are 50% less from the start.Originally posted by: g8wayrebel
Originally posted by: Steeplerot
Affirmitive action is a dilemma, kinda like rent control, regardless black students have been headed to black schools more now and minoritys are down in a lot of white schools.
The white students have better high schools and not the stigma of being black to deal with in a still racist country.
Axing it was not a good idea IMO. As previous poster pointed out the whites of this country made this problem.
A recent article about decline of minoritys in schools.
I am not so sure bringing it back in it's old form is the answer but tossing the idea away of reaching out a hand to underprividged americans away is pig-headed. And the whining from neocons in this country that helping make sure a balance is struck is racist in itself is nothing but more thinly veiled racist circular logic.
AA in some form is still nessasary,as racism in this country is alive and well.
just look at this forum.
The white people in this country didn't make this problem. The slaves were taken captive and sold by native tribes(ie. Uncles and brothers of the enslaved) to the traders. The only reason it is an issue in this country and not in others is because it has been dwelled upon for decades. The issue has all but disappeared in the other nations of similar stature to the US during the slave trade days. Why is that? Concession after concession to no avail by the government and the sympathetic.. It is a drum that will comtinue to be beat as long as it yields results. As long as the drum is beating , so will be the resentment and the racist attitudes." We" didn"t do it, and we don't want to pay for it. It is a fact of world history , not US history,and should be taught as such.
AA is not necessary in this or any other civilized capitoist country. Personal responsibility and civic duty are necessary. When that is the norm in the black community , the attitudes will change and the respect will follow. You can argue and apologize all you want , but until that happens, racism will continue to be fueled by the constant "black" cry. No other race or creed in this country who has integrated into this country faces these issues today on a grandf scale. It is only the "Afro-American" members of society who seem unable( I believe unwilling ) to integrate in to the system.Even with the fallout of 9-11 on the Middle Eastern citizens , in particular the Muslim sects, have been able to maintain respect and coexist peacefully.African citizens who come here today are disgusted with what they find to be the "black community" here. It isn't really a race issue , but one of an attitude shared only by native black citizens and the sympathizers or antagonists of those very ideas. As long as the attitude is allowed to continue , so will the problems. It is used by politicians and profiteers on both sides to continue the derision and division while benefiting from it at the same time.
Here's a real breakthrough for you. How about not commiting felonies in the first place.As usual , the stats are scewed. Bring in some real numbers that represent a true segment of society by percentages, You just may learn something and maybe even realize where the attitudes come from.
How about making changes in the justice system so that the evidence actually gets presented. Screw precedent. Just because a judge in a preivious case made a bad decision shouldn't mean another judge has to follow his lead.
This country is all aboout ME! How can I get re-elected, how can I get away with what I did, how can I get what you have, how can I get rich so I don't have to work. Face it, we live in an apathetic superaffluent country. Screw you , how can I get what I want?
Originally posted by: g8wayrebel
You are correct. I do assign no guilt to "white" people for importing slaves. It was acceptable at that time.
I'm sorrry if you can't accept that this and other countries have seen the error in that and moved on. Many other people have been persecuted and or discriminated against that have overcome the issues to be successful. It is time for the black people to let history be history and work toward the future.
As far as the hiring practices go , the only resolution for it is to take on the struggle internally and change the way black people are seen. The perceptions aren't that far from reality for the majority.
Those that rise above the issues need to lead others in success to change the perception. The absolute worst thing you can be in the black community is a successful light skinned black.
They have as much a stereotype problem within the ranks as the nation as a whole does. They as a people need to fix it.
Giving them concessions exacorbates the situation. It is not , nor will it ever be a solution.
When you find that they argue as citizens , and not as black people , you will also find they get a lot more attention. There is no support for the community by the community. Exploitation and undermining of success for a few to profit and the rest to be oppressed is the reality for now.
Change that and you will have a good start. Although I regularly hear "the white man keeping a brother down" in this city , I also see the brother doing just that. Success in the world is not accepted by the black people.
You have to be an "Uncle Tom" to accept the ways of society and succeed. When you change that and the black people make a concerted effort to join and be a part of the society as a whole , you will see a drastic difference.
Drugs treat depression. Leadership and education fix oppression.By education , I mean realizing and accepting things as they are and changing them, in conjunction with schooling in the three R's. No matter how much you see injustice in the way things are , or how wrong it is , it is the black people who have to fix it.
Telling people to change the way they act will never result in anything but resentment without a catalyst. If no changes are evident , no chage in attitude will be present. While this stands true for both sides , it is the blacks who are on the downside of the equation and need to overcome the very thing I just stated where attitude and change are concerned.
The only thing I can say is that with leadership and the ear of a large majority , it is possible for tem to "suck it up" and overcome the issues. It may not be fast , or even show positive effect for those who start it today , but overtime it can be done. It is wrong that it is this way , but it is they who have the gains to be made , so it is they who need to overcome the difficulties in making the changes.\
Originally posted by: Starbuck1975
Typical...this country is unable to engage in any healthy discussions about race relations because to criticize minorities is to be labeled a racist...many of the problems that minorities face in today's society are due largely to the problems that exist in their own communities, but we aren't allowed to talk about that.Its usually because the filth is racist.
The flaw in your argument is the people trying to better themselves are the ones applying for jobs and they are being rejected at a disproportionate rate because they are black. Remember these are blind resumes and the people in these studies are trained to make the same presenation. The results are alarmingly the same. These are the results you are choosing to ignore. Oh that right if we just "suck it up" these things will change.Originally posted by: g8wayrebel
You are correct. I do assign no guilt to "white" people for importing slaves. It was acceptable at that time. I'm sorrry if you can't accept that this and other countries have seen the error in that and moved on. Many other people have been persecuted and or discriminated against that have overcome the issues to be successful. It is time for the black people to let history be history and work toward the future.
As far as the hiring practices go , the only resolution for it is to take on the struggle internally and change the way black people are seen. The perceptions aren't that far from reality for the majority. Those that rise above the issues need to lead others in success to change the perception. The absolute worst thing you can be in the black community is a successful light skinned black. They have as much a stereotype problem within the ranks as the nation as a whole does. They as a people need to fix it. Giving them concessions exacorbates the situation. It is not , nor will it ever be a solution. When you find that they argue as citizens , and not as black people , you will also find they get a lot more attention. There is no support for the community by the community. Exploitation and undermining of success for a few to profit and the rest to be oppressed is the reality for now. Change that and you will have a good start. Although I regularly hear "the white man keeping a brother down" in this city , I also see the brother doing just that. Success in the world is not accepted by the black people. You have to be an "Uncle Tom" to accept the ways of society and succeed. When you change that and the black people make a concerted effort to join and be a part of the society as a whole , you will see a drastic difference. Drugs treat depression. Leadership and education fix oppression.By education , I mean realizing and accepting things as they are and changing them, in conjunction with schooling in the three R's. No matter how much you see injustice in the way things are , or how wrong it is , it is the black people who have to fix it. Telling people to change the way they act will never result in anything but resentment without a catalyst. If no changes are evident , no chage in attitude will be present. While this stands true for both sides , it is the blacks who are on the downside of the equation and need to overcome the very thing I just stated where attitude and change are concerned. The only thing I can say is that with leadership and the ear of a large majority , it is possible for tem to "suck it up" and overcome the issues. It may not be fast , or even show positive effect for those who start it today , but overtime it can be done. It is wrong that it is this way , but it is they who have the gains to be made , so it is they who need to overcome the difficulties in making the changes.
Originally posted by: KidViciou$
JESUS CHRIST! YOUR ASSIGNING NO GUILT TO WHITE PEOPLE FOR IMPORTING AFRICANS?!?!?!! the only reason the other tribes captured and sold captives is because their was a MARKET FOR IT!!!!
Originally posted by: g8wayrebel
You are correct. I do assign no guilt to "white" people for importing slaves. It was acceptable at that time. I'm sorrry if you can't accept that this and other countries have seen the error in that and moved on. Many other people have been persecuted and or discriminated against that have overcome the issues to be successful. It is time for the black people to let history be history and work toward the future.
As far as the hiring practices go , the only resolution for it is to take on the struggle internally and change the way black people are seen. The perceptions aren't that far from reality for the majority. Those that rise above the issues need to lead others in success to change the perception. The absolute worst thing you can be in the black community is a successful light skinned black. They have as much a stereotype problem within the ranks as the nation as a whole does. They as a people need to fix it. Giving them concessions exacorbates the situation. It is not , nor will it ever be a solution. When you find that they argue as citizens , and not as black people , you will also find they get a lot more attention. There is no support for the community by the community. Exploitation and undermining of success for a few to profit and the rest to be oppressed is the reality for now. Change that and you will have a good start. Although I regularly hear "the white man keeping a brother down" in this city , I also see the brother doing just that. Success in the world is not accepted by the black people. You have to be an "Uncle Tom" to accept the ways of society and succeed. When you change that and the black people make a concerted effort to join and be a part of the society as a whole , you will see a drastic difference. Drugs treat depression. Leadership and education fix oppression.By education , I mean realizing and accepting things as they are and changing them, in conjunction with schooling in the three R's. No matter how much you see injustice in the way things are , or how wrong it is , it is the black people who have to fix it. Telling people to change the way they act will never result in anything but resentment without a catalyst. If no changes are evident , no chage in attitude will be present. While this stands true for both sides , it is the blacks who are on the downside of the equation and need to overcome the very thing I just stated where attitude and change are concerned. The only thing I can say is that with leadership and the ear of a large majority , it is possible for tem to "suck it up" and overcome the issues. It may not be fast , or even show positive effect for those who start it today , but overtime it can be done. It is wrong that it is this way , but it is they who have the gains to be made , so it is they who need to overcome the difficulties in making the changes.
Originally posted by: Tommunist
would it not make more sense to base affirmative action on social status? it seems that affirmative action is working on the assumption that most minorities need help b/c they are at a disadvantage socially. it seems fair to say that some non-minorities have this same disadvantage (and that some minorities do not have the disadvantage) so why not actually target people that need help?
