petrusbroder
Elite Member
Dear TeAm Mates,
Edit October 6: The title of this thread has been changed because the old title (How do we want it?) implicated a policy making thread, which never was intended. Parts of the previous subtitle (Mini-teams: pro or con?) also suggested a more aggressive tone of this thread, which again was not my intention.
some weeks ago we had a ethics thread in this forum about quite a few questions and - if I may say so - it was a sucess: more than 800 views and over 200 posts.
Now an other question has come up. It is not a new one: mini-teams. What speaks for them? Are they unfair? How important id fairness, how exact should this fairness be, do mini-teams skew the fairness? Do mini-teams contribute to team-spirit, fun, mini-races or do they promote dissent?
We have quite a few of these: TaBoo, TAS, Rebel Alliance, Team Enterprise and some others.
I have - before starting the previous ethics thread - communicated with the mods and 16 of the most frequent of posters here in this forum about a thread, where such sensitive issues could be discussed in a dispassionate way. Most of those whom I asked thought the idea was good. Almost all warned me that it would be hard to keep a polite and respectful tone in this thread, because - of course - it is so easy to offend ones sensibility.
I am aware of that the mini-team idea is a very sensitive issue and therefore I respectfully ask the posters to carefully read their posts, to be aware of the "ground rules" posted below.
I also ask the readers to have an friendly attitude, to put aside old frustrations (isn't it more fun to get new ones?) and to remember: we are one great team achieving very good results. Lets try to keep it that way.
1. Please read carefully and with an open mind. Not all contributors have english as their native language and we often do not know all the subtle meanings of all words, and may so write a word which may be misunderstood. Please take that into consideration and give us the benefit of the doubt.
2. Please post using a non-offensive language. That means: no four letter words, no sexual, racial, religous or otherwise offensive slurs. If you really want to make sombody know your personal opinion, please use PM.
3. If your feelings run hot (and I think they will some time or other) please allow your self to cool down.
4. Please love your enemies, because that will drive them crazy.
5. Only write about projects and issues and not about people. That alone may make a difference on how a post is understood.
6. If someone states something as a fact, he/she should be able to offer some proof or support. That will certainly make more impact and increase our collective understanding of the issue.
7. Assumtions, opinions and guesses should be clearly stated as such.
8. Jokes are good. They certainly make the posting more fun, and that is very important. However, would it be possible to keep this thread somewhat free from serious neffing? We have a very nice thread for that!
Since I kind of feel responsible for theis thread I will try to keep an eye on it although I am not a mod.
Edit October 6: The title of this thread has been changed because the old title (How do we want it?) implicated a policy making thread, which never was intended. Parts of the previous subtitle (Mini-teams: pro or con?) also suggested a more aggressive tone of this thread, which again was not my intention.
some weeks ago we had a ethics thread in this forum about quite a few questions and - if I may say so - it was a sucess: more than 800 views and over 200 posts.
Now an other question has come up. It is not a new one: mini-teams. What speaks for them? Are they unfair? How important id fairness, how exact should this fairness be, do mini-teams skew the fairness? Do mini-teams contribute to team-spirit, fun, mini-races or do they promote dissent?
We have quite a few of these: TaBoo, TAS, Rebel Alliance, Team Enterprise and some others.
I have - before starting the previous ethics thread - communicated with the mods and 16 of the most frequent of posters here in this forum about a thread, where such sensitive issues could be discussed in a dispassionate way. Most of those whom I asked thought the idea was good. Almost all warned me that it would be hard to keep a polite and respectful tone in this thread, because - of course - it is so easy to offend ones sensibility.
I am aware of that the mini-team idea is a very sensitive issue and therefore I respectfully ask the posters to carefully read their posts, to be aware of the "ground rules" posted below.
I also ask the readers to have an friendly attitude, to put aside old frustrations (isn't it more fun to get new ones?) and to remember: we are one great team achieving very good results. Lets try to keep it that way.
1. Please read carefully and with an open mind. Not all contributors have english as their native language and we often do not know all the subtle meanings of all words, and may so write a word which may be misunderstood. Please take that into consideration and give us the benefit of the doubt.
2. Please post using a non-offensive language. That means: no four letter words, no sexual, racial, religous or otherwise offensive slurs. If you really want to make sombody know your personal opinion, please use PM.
3. If your feelings run hot (and I think they will some time or other) please allow your self to cool down.
4. Please love your enemies, because that will drive them crazy.
5. Only write about projects and issues and not about people. That alone may make a difference on how a post is understood.
6. If someone states something as a fact, he/she should be able to offer some proof or support. That will certainly make more impact and increase our collective understanding of the issue.
7. Assumtions, opinions and guesses should be clearly stated as such.
8. Jokes are good. They certainly make the posting more fun, and that is very important. However, would it be possible to keep this thread somewhat free from serious neffing? We have a very nice thread for that!
Since I kind of feel responsible for theis thread I will try to keep an eye on it although I am not a mod.