Military Recruiters must await "Opt-In"

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

BaliBabyDoc

Lifer
Jan 20, 2001
10,737
0
0
For the record, what does our current situation in Iraq have to do with being "patriotic?" Isn't it just as reasonable for someone to advocate every legal avenue of opposing an "unjust" war as it is for proponents to advertise support for the war as being "patriotic?" If both sides can use it, it's meaningless.

 

dannybin1742

Platinum Member
Jan 16, 2002
2,335
0
0
For the record, what does our current situation in Iraq have to do with being "patriotic?"

nothing, thats a typical brown shirt response.......question....(no good answer).....(think of a good response)....... "you are just unpatriotic"

its like a kneejerk reaction from the GOPies
 

BBond

Diamond Member
Oct 3, 2004
8,363
0
0
Originally posted by: BaliBabyDoc
For the record, what does our current situation in Iraq have to do with being "patriotic?" Isn't it just as reasonable for someone to advocate every legal avenue of opposing an "unjust" war as it is for proponents to advertise support for the war as being "patriotic?" If both sides can use it, it's meaningless.

"Patriotism is the final refuge of a scoundrel"
-- Samuel Johnson

 

beer

Lifer
Jun 27, 2000
11,169
1
0
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Originally posted by: beer
I hope your vacation gets extended, Rip. Even after a two-week warning, you still attach A SINGLE SENTENCE to a post even though you were BANNED for doing that exact same thing. I have nothing to say on this thread besides that.

Link

I am not even going to waste my time. Keep posting 1 sentence attachments and I won't need to waste the effort to achieve my desired ends.
 

Beowulf

Golden Member
Jan 27, 2001
1,446
0
71
I don't see too much of a problem I know at my high school recruiters were around often.Of course most recruiters are kind of useless(atleast those I met) I remember some Army recruiter trying to get my younger brother and his friends(9 of em) to join the Army instead they enlisted with the Marines.
 

Riprorin

Banned
Apr 25, 2000
9,634
0
0
Originally posted by: beer
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Originally posted by: beer
I hope your vacation gets extended, Rip. Even after a two-week warning, you still attach A SINGLE SENTENCE to a post even though you were BANNED for doing that exact same thing. I have nothing to say on this thread besides that.

Link

I am not even going to waste my time. Keep posting 1 sentence attachments and I won't need to waste the effort to achieve my desired ends.

There's an alternative to thread crapping:

moderator@anandtech.com

Link[/quote]
 

Hayabusa Rider

Admin Emeritus & Elite Member
Jan 26, 2000
50,879
4,268
126
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Liberals support 13 year olds having abortions without parental notification, yet they want to pass legislation that would prevent military recruiters from contacting students unless their parents "opt-in".

Typical nonsense and hypocrisy from the left.

Link

I can tell you this. Neither had better approach my kids without my consent, because they would have to deal with me, and that would be a distinctly unpleasant thing for them. My family does not belong to the US, the Libs or the Cons. They are mine and when someone decides to insert themselves in a way I disapprove of they are going to get an earful.
 

Riprorin

Banned
Apr 25, 2000
9,634
0
0
Fir those that are opposed to military recruitment, are you opposed to the existence of the military or just you child's participation in it?

If you think that we should have a military and you are opposed to recruitment, are you in favor of a draft to fill the ranks?
 

Steeplerot

Lifer
Mar 29, 2004
13,051
6
81
The us military the size it is compared to other nations is a holdover from the cold war and thus useless.
Of course the military industrial complex is going to go for PNAC imperialism. They are bored and overfunded.
Stay out of other countries affairs= no more terrorism, everyone is happy and we have lots of money to do what we do best: the world leader in newest ideas and tech to better the human races lot in life. Instead of just bombing out those who have not learned as much as us and ruining what they have made for themselves we should be a example!
Everyone knows in the long run you win more with honey then vinegar.
We are blessed with enough money, resources and manpower to guard our borders and be the inspiration of hope and peace to the world.
Using the blessings we have for domination and imperialism we shall just go down in history as another experiment of freedom and democracy gone wrong.
We shall never help our fellow nation states by the end of a gun -we as Americans should lead as a example of peace and goodwill -not the iron fist of the past.

This is our legacy from world wars past, so soon we have forgotten the WASTE of war.
Noone wins in the end.
 

imported_tss4

Golden Member
Jun 30, 2004
1,607
0
0
Originally posted by: shira
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Since parental consent is required to enlist, why can't recruiters at least talk to them?

Well, I'm about as liberal as they come, and I think recruiters should be able to at least speak with high school kids without parents having to give approval.

So, I guess SOME liberals aren't hypocrites after all. And that means YOU agree with me that there are some circumstances of underage abortion in which it's perfectly fine that parents shouldn't be notified, right?

(If not, then I guess YOU'RE the hypocrite. hahahahaha)

Notice, he didn't address your question.
 

cjgallen

Diamond Member
Jan 20, 2003
6,419
0
0
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Fir those that are opposed to military recruitment, are you opposed to the existence of the military or just you child's participation in it?

If you think that we should have a military and you are opposed to recruitment, are you in favor of a draft to fill the ranks?

I would like to know this as well. I recently joined the Navy myself, and I would love to see some form of mandatory service time. It would certainly make people think twice about who they're electing to lead their armed forces.
 

imported_tss4

Golden Member
Jun 30, 2004
1,607
0
0
Originally posted by: umbrella39
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Liberals support 13 year olds having abortions without parental notification, yet they want to pass legislation that would prevent military recruiters from contacting students unless their parents "opt-in".

Typical nonsense and hypocrisy from the left.

Link

Why should recruiters be held under a different light than any other telemarketer or soliciter that calls your house. This IS what we are talking about. We are not talking about recruiters having career fairs at high schools. We are talking about recruiters contacting children at home. The Federal do not call list should be extended to include calls from ALL soliciters, recruiters are no different when they are contacting you at home. I am pretty sure most kids know about the Armed Services by the time they are teenagers. If they want to serve they know where to find them.


Well, actually, I think they can be held to a different standard. It is different. I've been calls to change my long distance ever since I had long distance, but the recruiters stopped after I was out of college. They're going for a narrow demographic and once you get past that then you don't have to deal with them again (till your kids get to that age). They were annoying, yes, but its not like I had them calling every day. And any 18 year old that's has a plan in life can that doesn't involve the military can say no very easily.

Just because, I don't approve of Bush's policies doesn't make denying the military the ability to recruit a good idea.
 

imported_tss4

Golden Member
Jun 30, 2004
1,607
0
0
Originally posted by: cjgallen
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Fir those that are opposed to military recruitment, are you opposed to the existence of the military or just you child's participation in it?

If you think that we should have a military and you are opposed to recruitment, are you in favor of a draft to fill the ranks?

I would like to know this as well. I recently joined the Navy myself, and I would love to see mandatory service time. Would make people think twice about who they're electing to lead their armed forces.

My guess is they either get annoyed at the consistent phone calling or they're afraid that there kids will be talked into joining somehow. It would be nice to hear their response.
 

Steeplerot

Lifer
Mar 29, 2004
13,051
6
81
Originally posted by: cjgallen
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Fir those that are opposed to military recruitment, are you opposed to the existence of the military or just you child's participation in it?

If you think that we should have a military and you are opposed to recruitment, are you in favor of a draft to fill the ranks?

I would like to know this as well. I recently joined the Navy myself, and I would love to see mandatory service time. Would make people think twice about who they're electing to lead their armed forces.


I agree we should have a mandatory service for the national guard/coast guard. Anything else I see as unessasary in our modern world though.
The military is necessary for national defense and humanitarian, peacekeeping missions, nothing else.
Swinging your pen0r around in these days is just asking for some nuke action. -we have been damn lucky.....
 

Red Dawn

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2001
57,529
3
0
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Fir those that are opposed to military recruitment, are you opposed to the existence of the military or just you child's participation in it?

If you think that we should have a military and you are opposed to recruitment, are you in favor of a draft to fill the ranks?
Personally I'm not opposed to recruitment if the Recruiters are honest. Unfortunately Teenagers are highly impressionable and are easily swayed by sugar coated BS. I can't see where it would hurt to have a parent, teacher, counselor or guardian present when a recruiter speaks to them.

It does seem the Army is having a tough time filling it's quota of new recruits.

Army Having Difficulty Meeting Goals In Recruiting

I'm sure the fact that the odds are new recruits might get deployed to Iraq has something to do with that but it could also be that the Recruiters are being totally honest.
 

cjgallen

Diamond Member
Jan 20, 2003
6,419
0
0
Originally posted by: Red Dawn
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Fir those that are opposed to military recruitment, are you opposed to the existence of the military or just you child's participation in it?

If you think that we should have a military and you are opposed to recruitment, are you in favor of a draft to fill the ranks?
Personally I'm not opposed to recruitment if the Recruiters are honest. Unfortunately Teenagers are highly impressionable and are easily swayed by sugar coated BS. I can't see where it would hurt to have a parent, teacher, counselor or guardian present when a recruiter speaks to them.

It does seem the Army is having a tough time filling it's quota of new recruits.

Army Having Difficulty Meeting Goals In Recruiting

I'm sure the fact that the odds are new recruits might get deployed to Iraq has something to do with that but it could also be that the Recruiters are being totally honest.

Heh, I got a call from the Army recruiters after I had joined the Navy (took my oath and everything), I thought I'd hear what he has to say, so I humored a few of his questions. Well first, his cell phone went off while he was on the phone with me (some stupid rap song ringtone), so he told me to hold on and ANSWERED HIS CELLPHONE. I immediately hung up, and he called back in a minute or two.

Well, I told him that his fellow soldiers had steered me away from the Army and told me to join one of the other branches (they did, I was a contractor on Fort Hood for a year, had some really good chats with some folks), to which he responded "They're just disgruntled!" I explained that these were soldiers with 15+ years in the service who loved their job more than anybody. He didn't really have a response for that. Eventually I broke the news to him that I had already joined the Navy, he was a little upset :) but if the rest of the Army's recruiters are anything like him, they've got a long way to go to meet their quotas.

When I went up to MEPS (military entrance processing), it was interesting to see so many kids joining the MARINES, far more than the Army\Navy\AF combined. One guy was 17 years old joining the Marines (meaning his parents signed off on it). Navy had the second most recruits, followed by Army, and just ONE Air Force guy (the dipsh!t) :p Lots of nice motivated people.
 

umbrella39

Lifer
Jun 11, 2004
13,816
1,126
126
Originally posted by: tss4
Originally posted by: cjgallen
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Fir those that are opposed to military recruitment, are you opposed to the existence of the military or just you child's participation in it?

If you think that we should have a military and you are opposed to recruitment, are you in favor of a draft to fill the ranks?

I would like to know this as well. I recently joined the Navy myself, and I would love to see mandatory service time. Would make people think twice about who they're electing to lead their armed forces.

My guess is they either get annoyed at the consistent phone calling or they're afraid that there kids will be talked into joining somehow. It would be nice to hear their response.

I'm sorry but who in this thread so far has said they were against military recruitment? Unwanted phone calls on the line that I pay for is my issue. When the guvment starts paying for that bill they can call all they want. Until then, don't call my house.

I am all for recruitment drives and job fairs etc. I think every high school in America should make it mandatory to sit through an assembly for an hour or two and allow the recruiters to give their "pitch" as it were. Would that be an acceptable solution to putting some sort of limits on recruiter/telemarketing?

 

imported_tss4

Golden Member
Jun 30, 2004
1,607
0
0
Originally posted by: umbrella39
Originally posted by: tss4
Originally posted by: cjgallen
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Fir those that are opposed to military recruitment, are you opposed to the existence of the military or just you child's participation in it?

If you think that we should have a military and you are opposed to recruitment, are you in favor of a draft to fill the ranks?

I would like to know this as well. I recently joined the Navy myself, and I would love to see mandatory service time. Would make people think twice about who they're electing to lead their armed forces.

My guess is they either get annoyed at the consistent phone calling or they're afraid that there kids will be talked into joining somehow. It would be nice to hear their response.

I'm sorry but who in this thread so far has said they were against military recruitment? Unwanted phone calls on the line that I pay for is my issue. When the guvment starts paying for that bill they can call all they want. Until then, don't call my house.

I am all for recruitment drives and job fairs etc. I think every high school in America should make it mandatory to sit through an assembly for an hour or two and allow the recruiters to give their "pitch" as it were. Would that be an acceptable solution to putting some sort of limits on recruiter/telemarketing?


Didn't say you were against recreuitment. Just wondered how you thought they could make their recruitment goals when you don't allow them to talk to your kids. Was it because you thought your 18 year old wasn't intelligent enough to make up his own mind or was it because you were annoyed about getting phone calls, or was it something else I hadn't though of.

"Unwanted phone calls on the line that I pay for is my issue. When the guvment starts paying for that bill they can call all they want. Until then, don't call my house."

Unless they're calling your cell phone, you don't pay for recieved calls, only calls made when using a land line. So if that's your beef, then they should be allowed to call your home phone number.
 

Deptacon

Platinum Member
Nov 22, 2004
2,282
1
81
Originally posted by: arsbanned
F'ing right. Some moronic Army recruiter called here the other night. I enjoyed that. I really did. No, you cannot talk to my daughter. Sending my child off to be cannon fodder for GWB's reckless and pointless war is not a good thing. I hope you neocons don't like it.

and what do you have any say init? if she is 18 you have to right to tell her what she can and can not do? does that make me cannon fodder? numbnutts

 

Deptacon

Platinum Member
Nov 22, 2004
2,282
1
81
Originally posted by: Steeplerot
Originally posted by: glenn1
F'ing right. Some moronic Army recruiter called here the other night. I enjoyed that. I really did. No, you cannot talk to my daughter. Sending my child off to be cannon fodder for GWB's reckless and pointless war is not a good thing. I hope you neocons don't like it.

What, have you so ill-prepared your daughter for adult life that she can't resist the charms of a man in uniform? Or are you worried that your child might be more patriotic than you are and sees it as service to the country rather than being "cannon fodder" ? When people like you are involved I actually trust the children to know what's better for themselves than you do, parents taking rash actions like yours often cause their children to act precisely opposite to what you would wish just because they know it would hack you off. I don't think anyone should join the military who doesn't wish to, but you acting in this fashion leads me to believe you're a sad, scared little man. It would be sweet irony indeed if your daughter joined the service and wound up winning the Medal of Honor or Distinguished Service Cross.


:roll: Young people have better things to do the die for oil. seen how crappy the recruiters are doing latley?
I dare them to call here, my girlfriend would have a few things to tell them where to stick their oil war too.
(But I am sure it would be nothing new to them.)

YOU LIberlas are fr4eaking PRICELESS..... Talk smakc al lday, crap on bush al lday, but are the biggest fvcking PU$$IES in the world..... hahahahah no wonder no one repsects any of you...thats fine...i dont want you in my army...you wouldnt make it a week through basic....

 

cjgallen

Diamond Member
Jan 20, 2003
6,419
0
0
Men can't opt-out of SSS (but I'm sure some people would LOVE that). Phone calls aren't going to hurt you.

My parents did the same thing. Navy and Army were always calling our house. My dad would always answer and tell them "They're not interested," never asked if I wanted to talk to them.

That didn't stop me from walking into the recruiting office :) better take away your kid's car keys, or they might do the same thing!
 

Deptacon

Platinum Member
Nov 22, 2004
2,282
1
81
Originally posted by: BBond
Originally posted by: Tylanner

If you think this war will bring any financial(oil) gain to the USA, you have a few screws loose.

Iraq is not an imperial undertaking....


Tell that to Halliburton. :roll:


haliburton drives trucks and builds square buildings for our troops to live in....and the occasional pipeline over there...they also serve food to the troops, move ammo for ther troops, and setup computer netowkrs of rthe troops......they also oversee rebuilding roads, and schhols for iraq.... why know why i know, cause im going to be wokring for them in 6 months over there.... DONT BELIVE EVERYTHING YOU READ BBond....so yeah BBond explain to me....what does haiburton have to do with it?
 

BBond

Diamond Member
Oct 3, 2004
8,363
0
0
Originally posted by: Deptacon
Originally posted by: BBond
Originally posted by: Tylanner

If you think this war will bring any financial(oil) gain to the USA, you have a few screws loose.

Iraq is not an imperial undertaking....


Tell that to Halliburton. :roll:


haliburton drives trucks and builds square buildings for our troops to live in....and the occasional pipeline over there...they also serve food to the troops, move ammo for ther troops, and setup computer netowkrs of rthe troops......they also oversee rebuilding roads, and schhols for iraq.... why know why i know, cause im going to be wokring for them in 6 months over there.... DONT BELIVE EVERYTHING YOU READ BBond....so yeah BBond explain to me....what does haiburton have to do with it?

Yeah, right, Halliburton is second in line only to Mother Theresa. :roll:

Tylaner suggested that anyone who believes this war is bringing profit to the USA has "a few screws loose."

Halliburton is profiting from this war. They have been accused of overcharging for meals and services never delivered as well as bribery and indeed have been found to be overcharging U.S. taxpayers who are funding this excercise in futility -- yet the military decided to let them keep the money they cheated us out of. ;)

Clearly, someone in the USA is profiting from this invasion.

Read all about it. :)

Halliburton Watch

 

arsbanned

Banned
Dec 12, 2003
4,853
0
0
Originally posted by: BBond
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Originally posted by: arsbanned
F'ing right. Some moronic Army recruiter called here the other night. I enjoyed that. I really did. No, you cannot talk to my daughter. Sending my child off to be cannon fodder for GWB's reckless and pointless war is not a good thing. I hope you neocons don't like it.

The Army recruiter was "moronic" in what respect?

Expecting somone's high school aged kid to risk their life in Iraq to cover the complete and utter incompetence of George W. Bush.

His family covered for him all of his life, now he expects OUR families to cover for him too?

No way. Tell the recruiter to call the White House and ask for Jenna and Barbara if he needs recruits.

Exactly. Jenna and Barbara would make fine recruits. :thumbsup:

Originally posted by: glenn1
F'ing right. Some moronic Army recruiter called here the other night. I enjoyed that. I really did. No, you cannot talk to my daughter. Sending my child off to be cannon fodder for GWB's reckless and pointless war is not a good thing. I hope you neocons don't like it.

What, have you so ill-prepared your daughter for adult life that she can't resist the charms of a man in uniform? Or are you worried that your child might be more patriotic than you are and sees it as service to the country rather than being "cannon fodder" ? When people like you are involved I actually trust the children to know what's better for themselves than you do, parents taking rash actions like yours often cause their children to act precisely opposite to what you would wish just because they know it would hack you off. I don't think anyone should join the military who doesn't wish to, but you acting in this fashion leads me to believe you're a sad, scared little man. It would be sweet irony indeed if your daughter joined the service and wound up winning the Medal of Honor or Distinguished Service Cross.

Exactly, I didn't raise someone foolish enough to even consider wanting to get killed for an idiot like George Bush. She's going to a premier school. I'm not sad or scared. I am angry.
Heh, right, Distinguished Service Cross in an unjustified and immoral war. Great. That would be lovely. :disgust:
 

BBond

Diamond Member
Oct 3, 2004
8,363
0
0
Originally posted by: Deptacon


YOU LIberlas are fr4eaking PRICELESS..... Talk smakc al lday, crap on bush al lday, but are the biggest fvcking PU$$IES in the world..... hahahahah no wonder no one repsects any of you...thats fine...i dont want you in my army...you wouldnt make it a week through basic....

Macho Man
The Village People

Body...wanna feel my body?
Body...such a thrill my body
Body...wanna touch my body?
Body...it's too much my body
Check it out my body, body.
Don't you doubt my body, body.
talkin' bout my body, body,
check it out my body

Every man wants to be a macho macho man
to have the kind of body, always in demand
Jogging in the mornings, go man go
works out in the health spa, muscles glow
You can best believe that, he's a macho man
ready to get down with, anyone he can

Hey! Hey! Hey, hey, hey!
Macho, macho man (macho man)
I've got to be, a macho man
Macho, macho man
I've got to be a macho! Ow....

Macho, macho man
I've got to be, a macho man
Macho, macho man (yeah, yeah)
I've got to be a macho!

Body, its so hot, my body,
Body, love to pop my body,
Body, love to please my body,
Body, don't you tease my body,
Body, you'll adore my body,
Body, come explore my body,
Body, made by God, my body,
Body, it's so good, my body


You can tell a macho, he has a funky walk
his western shirts and leather, always look so boss
Funky with his body, he's a king
call him Mister Eagle, dig his chains
You can best believe that, he's a macho man
likes to be the leader, he never dresses grand

Hey! Hey! Hey, hey, hey!
Macho, macho man
I've got to be, a macho man
Macho, macho man
I've got to be a macho! (all right)

Macho, macho man (yeah, yeah)
I've got to be, a macho man
Macho, macho man
I've got to be a macho! All Right!

Ugh! Macho..baby!
Body, body, body wanna feel my body,
Body, body, body gonna thrill my body,
Body, body, body don'tcha stop my body,
Body, body, body it's so hot my body,

Every man ought to be a macho macho man,
To live a life of freedom, machos make a stand,
Have their own life style and ideals,
Possess the strength and confidence, life's a steal,
You can best believe that he's a macho man
He's a special person in anybody's land.

Hey! Hey! Hey, hey, hey!
Macho, macho man (macho man)
I've got to be, a macho man
Macho, macho man
I've got to be a macho! (dig the hair on my chest)

Macho, macho man (see my big thick mustache)
I've got to be, a macho man
Macho, macho man
I've got to be a macho! (Dig broad shoulders)

Macho, macho man (dig my muscles!)
I've got to be, a macho man
Macho, macho man
I've got to be a macho!

Macho, macho man
I've got to be, a macho man
Macho, macho man
I've got to be a macho! HEY!