Well, yeah, Dixy's death itself isn't a big deal (no offense). The problem is that it's a 3v3 once we can ask questions. The best-case scenario I see for team good is...
Day 3: The mafia has DixyCrat killed. The weak villager has been recruited by team good. It's 3 vs 3.
Day 4: We ask "Is ALIVE the crazy scientist?" and "Is X a hitman?" and it is confirmed that X is one. We vote to lynch X. The godfather attempts to... ok, actually, reviewing the roles again if the godfather tries to recruit the cop, he dies right? I take it back; in this case team good could win quite easily.
Actually, somehow I completely neglected the significance of the madman as well, although I guess it doesn't matter until the jailer is dead. Suddenly the game seems more up-for-grabs by either team.