LOST 3 x04

Page 6 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

trmiv

Lifer
Oct 10, 1999
14,670
18
81
Am I the only one who gets a bit angry watching this show now? Not because I think the show "sucks" or some garbage, but because I'm pissed at the situation the castaways are being put in by the "Others." I swear I want to jump through the screen and strangle Ben (Henry), every time I see the guy.
 

MixMasterTang

Diamond Member
Jul 23, 2001
3,167
176
106
How come no one has thought of the simple theory that the other island they showed Sawyer is an empty island with nothing on it, and that they are still on the same island as everyone else?
 

sash1

Diamond Member
Jul 20, 2001
8,896
1
0
Originally posted by: Zee
Originally posted by: SmoochyTX
Originally posted by: state 08
Sawyer is a daddy that cares.
Fixed.

i bet he's just getting conned by her

that's really doubtful that he was being con'd. it was a flashback. they're NOT going to go back and touch on this again most likely. the point of the flashback was to show that Sawyer isn't so one dimensional and that he does have the capacity to care for his daughter that he's never seen/met. which connects to how he acted in the episode, how he cared about Kate and didn't want her to get a pacemaker in her (even though that was a lie, but enough to convince Sawyer).

besides, if it was fake, then they can't get to the money. how was she to know he would deposit a million or whatever dollars for her daughter?
 

UpgradeFailure

Golden Member
Feb 29, 2004
1,672
0
0
Originally posted by: purbeast0
Originally posted by: UpgradeFailure
Originally posted by: purbeast0
I think it's pretty safe to assume that the village was on the island where the plane crashed, and that this new jail island is on another seperate island, and that the other island shown to sawyer is legit and in the fact that the main LOST characters are on that other island, the the Others (and jack, sawyer, and kate) are on this 2nd island. put these into place.

- michael took jack, sawyer, hurley, and kate to a dock when they were captured at the end of s2. they were on a dock that had boats. i would say it's safe to say after they captured them, they took em on the boat and now are on this other island.
- sayid and jin took a boat to get to find them, so they most likely couldn't get there by foot, so it is safe to assume it's on another island after this past episode.
- the others wanted that boat badly, which would tell us they NEED it for something.

so I dunno, it seems very plausible to me, and I don't think there is any underground tunnel going from one to the other.

also check these pics of the map on the blast door on the hatch...

v1
v2

Look at the little "veins" on the map, behind all of the Dharma stuff. it looks like they could possibly be little rivers/water ways between different pieces of land. so I truly think that there is more than 1 island, and probably more than 2 islands. jack, sawyer, and kate are probably in "The Swan" right now.

The Others wanted the boat so bad (Desmonds) because if our side of the island has a boat, that means they can get to the Jail island. No boat=no threat.

What do you mean kate/s/j are in the Swan though? We already know about the swan and that's on our island of course...

What if those "Rivers" on the map are really underground pathways?

Oh I didn't realize the main LOST island was the Swan. I was just pointing out that it was one of the islands that was completely surrounded by the "paths" on that map. The paths COULD be underground tunnels, however given the scope of the map and the scope of the size of the island(s) they seem more likely to be bodies of water IMO.


The circles on the map are not islands. They are hatches. The swan is the hatch Desmond was in, and Locke was pushing the button in.
The Arrow is the Hatch the Tail enders went into. The staff is the one Clarie was taken to. The middle one is the Pearl where Ekko and Locke saw that other video. We haven't seen the rest yet.
 

iamme

Lifer
Jul 21, 2001
21,058
3
0
Originally posted by: MixMasterTang
How come no one has thought of the simple theory that the other island they showed Sawyer is an empty island with nothing on it, and that they are still on the same island as everyone else?

i was thinking the same thing, but then what i don't get is how the Lost castaways never saw the second island during seasons 1 and 2??
 

flashbacck

Golden Member
Aug 3, 2001
1,921
0
76
Originally posted by: UpgradeFailure
Originally posted by: 49erinnc
I thought the image in the previews looked like a guy wearing an eye patch as well. My first thought was some sort of pirate. And I'm almost wondering if he's connected to the old pirate ship that contained the dynamite in last season. We never really learned much about that ship and it was odd that it was wrecked, deep within the island.

Eyepatch person= person with glass eye from the Arrow hatch? That was my thought at least.

wow, good memory!
 

cKGunslinger

Lifer
Nov 29, 1999
16,408
57
91
Originally posted by: slayer202
Originally posted by: iamme
Originally posted by: slayer202
Originally posted by: iamme
also, who do you guys think has the tumor?

Benjamin is the obvious answer. could be another deception. they knew that Jack would see the x-rays.

first, when talking about one episode, it connects with 10 other ones, so you can't stay on JUST this episode.

second, I think it is Ben. Why would they fake it? I think this is what Ben was talking about to Jack in a past episode about what he had to do to get off the island. I find it very convenient that he is a world famous spinal surgeon though. Maybe the crash wasn't desmonds fault?

i don't have any problem with talking about previous episodes, as they relate to the current episode. it's just irritating when every episode thread has at least a few people who whine and moan about the show's pace, plot, direction, etc, etc. we now have a thread for that conversation.

anyways, to answer "why would they fake it?"......i wouldn't put any deception past the Others or anyone in the Dharma Initiative. the Others had costume makeup and elaborate scenarios to fool the castaways. who knows. *shrug*

btw, Jack said it was a male in his 40s. first instinct was Benjamin. thinking it over, Locke could fit the description.

preview shows jack telling someone that they have a tumor and that its going to kill them. looks like hes talking to ben

It looks like Ben is the one with the tumor, but could also be a ruse. Perhaps it is Lock's tumor, and that's why he couldn't walk prior to crashing on the island. Maybe it healed from the island's "magic powers." Or maybe it moved enough to allow him to walk, but is still going to kill him and Jack is meant to save him. Lock could be the whole reason every single person on the island is there. :boggle:
 

Homerboy

Lifer
Mar 1, 2000
30,890
5,001
126
It looks like Ben is the one with the tumor, but could also be a ruse. Perhaps it is Lock's tumor, and that's why he couldn't walk prior to crashing on the island. Maybe it healed from the island's "magic powers." Or maybe it moved enough to allow him to walk, but is still going to kill him and Jack is meant to save him. Lock could be the whole reason every single person on the island is there. :boggle:

Your ideas intrigue me... I would like to subscribe to your newsletter.

 

Gunslinger08

Lifer
Nov 18, 2001
13,234
2
81
Originally posted by: trmiv
Am I the only one who gets a bit angry watching this show now? Not because I think the show "sucks" or some garbage, but because I'm pissed at the situation the castaways are being put in by the "Others." I swear I want to jump through the screen and strangle Ben (Henry), every time I see the guy.

Absolutely. I would kill every single "Other" as soon as I possibly could.
 

lyssword

Diamond Member
Dec 15, 2005
5,630
25
91
This is interesting, they are developing Sawyers' character
And OMGBBQWTF? Desmond can see teh futuer! :D :D
 

Cattlegod

Diamond Member
May 22, 2001
8,687
1
0
Anyone thought that the island is actually the only island and where they were looking was just the backside of the island i.e. packman style?

That would explain why everyone who tries to leave the island just ends up running into it again unless you leave by a certain area that ben said to Michael when he let them go.
 

JoeFahey

Platinum Member
Jan 15, 2005
2,163
1
0
Everyone here is talking as if the village shown in the first episode of this season (book club village), is on a different island than the one that the planes crashed on. However, when you watch the camera zoom out, you can see that both are on the same island, meaning, when Ethan ran to the crash site, he didn't need to to go on a sub, or underground or something.
 

MixMasterTang

Diamond Member
Jul 23, 2001
3,167
176
106
Originally posted by: JoeFahey
Everyone here is talking as if the village shown in the first episode of this season (book club village), is on a different island than the one that the planes crashed on. However, when you watch the camera zoom out, you can see that both are on the same island, meaning, when Ethan ran to the crash site, he didn't need to to go on a sub, or underground or something.

That still doesn't determine whether the place they are holding Kate, Sawyer and Jack is on a different island, or the same island, and if it is a different island how they get back and forth.
 

Smartazz

Diamond Member
Dec 29, 2005
6,128
0
76
Originally posted by: MixMasterTang
How come no one has thought of the simple theory that the other island they showed Sawyer is an empty island with nothing on it, and that they are still on the same island as everyone else?

I think I've heard this theory before.
 

JoeFahey

Platinum Member
Jan 15, 2005
2,163
1
0
Originally posted by: MixMasterTang
Originally posted by: JoeFahey
Everyone here is talking as if the village shown in the first episode of this season (book club village), is on a different island than the one that the planes crashed on. However, when you watch the camera zoom out, you can see that both are on the same island, meaning, when Ethan ran to the crash site, he didn't need to to go on a sub, or underground or something.

That still doesn't determine whether the place they are holding Kate, Sawyer and Jack is on a different island, or the same island, and if it is a different island how they get back and forth.

I just remembered discussion on how Ethan got to the crash in the estimated time Ben gave him, and that he had to take a boat or something.

But with the prison island, I am guessing a sub(what Jack might have been on) or just a simple boat.

What I cant wait for, is to find out something HUGE. I mean, what the others are there for. How they know stuff from the real world. There are just so many amazing ways this could end up. However, I think the writers will drag this on as long as they can, since it is still popular.
 

Smartazz

Diamond Member
Dec 29, 2005
6,128
0
76
Originally posted by: JoeFahey
Originally posted by: MixMasterTang
Originally posted by: JoeFahey
Everyone here is talking as if the village shown in the first episode of this season (book club village), is on a different island than the one that the planes crashed on. However, when you watch the camera zoom out, you can see that both are on the same island, meaning, when Ethan ran to the crash site, he didn't need to to go on a sub, or underground or something.

That still doesn't determine whether the place they are holding Kate, Sawyer and Jack is on a different island, or the same island, and if it is a different island how they get back and forth.

I just remembered discussion on how Ethan got to the crash in the estimated time Ben gave him, and that he had to take a boat or something.

But with the prison island, I am guessing a sub(what Jack might have been on) or just a simple boat.

What I cant wait for, is to find out something HUGE. I mean, what the others are there for. How they know stuff from the real world. There are just so many amazing ways this could end up. However, I think the writers will drag this on as long as they can, since it is still popular.

Episode 7 is about Juliette, but I think that's next year's episode, right after the cut off. She probobly knows a lot about the others.
 

JoeFahey

Platinum Member
Jan 15, 2005
2,163
1
0
Originally posted by: Smartazz
I'm curius to know who was on the television screen in the pearl.

Anyone have a screen shot of that, or a link to a clip of the promo?
 

TangoJuliet

Diamond Member
Jul 2, 2006
5,595
1
76
I have a bunch of theories....much of what I've read on different sites and came to these conclusions

(may contain spoilers so if you dont want to see them...dont read)


*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

The others are scientists sent to the island in the late 70's to do secret scientific experiments. The island is at top-secret facility shielded from the rest of the world by an EM field. This EM field would explain why Ben (Henry) told Michael to follow a bearing and not a heading when leaving the island. Also would explain why Desmond just sailed back to the island.

The others created an advanced EM presence on the island which they call the Cerberus System. It has the ability to enter into the minds of the survivors, scan their memories and pasts, gathers intel for The Others. Then it plays off of those memories and feeds on their fears. It does not attack who can be deemed "good" (by the Others' definition). It kills the "threats" or the "bad people" it comes into contact with. This EM presence is known as the smoke monster.

The button controlled some type of EM field. I am not sure if it was part of the smoke monster or part of the EM field that surrounds the island. Because it was blown up the island will lose its magical healing powers meaning Rose's cancer will return and Locke will lose use of his legs. I have not read this anywhere but I do feel that the others were doing some sort of time travel. This is evident by the fact that Desmond can now see the future. And also in the past episode with the rabbit......I've found this

From Stephen King's "On Writing," in which he discusses how writing is like a sort of time travel/telepathy relationship with the audience:

"Look-here's a table covered with a red cloth. On it is a cage the size of a small fish aquarium. In the cage is a white rabbit with a pink nose and pink-rimmed eyes. In its front paws is a carrot-stub upon which it is contentedly munching. On its back, clearly marked in blue ink, is the numeral 8."

Lastly....I do believe there is only 1 island and that when Ben took Sawyer up to the peak it was simply a snowglobe effect. The guy with the patch is actually an other from a differnt hatch. Someone will be killed in the next episode - my guess is Mr. Ecko or possibly Rose. Other assumptions: Jack's dad is the real Sawyer, Claire is Jack's half sister, The real Henry Gale was an associate of Penny Widmore who she sent on a mission to find Desmond, and Widmore Corps supply food drops on the island and constructed the research stations.

The series will conclude when they get to the middle of the map but who knows when that will happen. They still need to find a couple more hatches and need to explain more of the character's backgrounds. I'm guessing atleast 7 seasons before they come close.
 

smack Down

Diamond Member
Sep 10, 2005
4,507
0
0
To funny last week everyone here is like the polar bears came from the jail cages. LoL so the polar bears swam to the other island?
 

loup garou

Lifer
Feb 17, 2000
35,132
1
81
Originally posted by: smack Down
To funny last week everyone here is like the polar bears came from the jail cages. LoL so the polar bears swam to the other island?

Originally posted by: loup garou
Originally posted by: UpgradeFailure
So if the cage that Swayer is in, is for a Polar Bear, how did it get to the other island? Can they swim that well? It seemed pretty far to me.
Polar bears are excellent swimmers and can often be seen in open waters miles from land.

Although they were probably put on the other island for a reason...
 

ThePresence

Elite Member
Nov 19, 2001
27,727
16
81
Sometimes I think the writers are just as "lost" as we are, and make this up as they go along, without some master plot.
 

Smartazz

Diamond Member
Dec 29, 2005
6,128
0
76
Originally posted by: alkohoLiK
I have a bunch of theories....much of what I've read on different sites and came to these conclusions

(may contain spoilers so if you dont want to see them...dont read)


*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*

The others are scientists sent to the island in the late 70's to do secret scientific experiments. The island is at top-secret facility shielded from the rest of the world by an EM field. This EM field would explain why Ben (Henry) told Michael to follow a bearing and not a heading when leaving the island. Also would explain why Desmond just sailed back to the island.

The others created an advanced EM presence on the island which they call the Cerberus System. It has the ability to enter into the minds of the survivors, scan their memories and pasts, gathers intel for The Others. Then it plays off of those memories and feeds on their fears. It does not attack who can be deemed "good" (by the Others' definition). It kills the "threats" or the "bad people" it comes into contact with. This EM presence is known as the smoke monster.

The button controlled some type of EM field. I am not sure if it was part of the smoke monster or part of the EM field that surrounds the island. Because it was blown up the island will lose its magical healing powers meaning Rose's cancer will return and Locke will lose use of his legs. I have not read this anywhere but I do feel that the others were doing some sort of time travel. This is evident by the fact that Desmond can now see the future. And also in the past episode with the rabbit......I've found this

From Stephen King's "On Writing," in which he discusses how writing is like a sort of time travel/telepathy relationship with the audience:

"Look-here's a table covered with a red cloth. On it is a cage the size of a small fish aquarium. In the cage is a white rabbit with a pink nose and pink-rimmed eyes. In its front paws is a carrot-stub upon which it is contentedly munching. On its back, clearly marked in blue ink, is the numeral 8."

Lastly....I do believe there is only 1 island and that when Ben took Sawyer up to the peak it was simply a snowglobe effect. The guy with the patch is actually an other from a differnt hatch. Someone will be killed in the next episode - my guess is Mr. Ecko or possibly Rose. Other assumptions: Jack's dad is the real Sawyer, Claire is Jack's half sister, The real Henry Gale was an associate of Penny Widmore who she sent on a mission to find Desmond, and Widmore Corps supply food drops on the island and constructed the research stations.

The series will conclude when they get to the middle of the map but who knows when that will happen. They still need to find a couple more hatches and need to explain more of the character's backgrounds. I'm guessing atleast 7 seasons before they come close.

Remember when Desmond said "we're stuck in a blood snowglobe." Maybe you could be right about Sawyer looking at their own island and he got conned again.