Originally posted by: daniel1113
Originally posted by: arcas
The thing that kills me about steam-based authentication for single-player games is that now you're dependent upon the parent company not going bankrupt. If Vivendi were to go bankrupt 2 years from now and turn off the authentication servers, you're screwed. Will these authentication servers still be around 5-10 years from now? Just like I sometimes watch old movies, sometimes I go back and play old games. For instance, I still occasionally play Myst, Riven and Doom that I occasionally fire up.
But let's not be so extreme. Let's say something happens in Vivendi's network center that simply knocks them offline for a few days (say a construction crew cuts a fiber cable outside the building). You're screwed. Nevermind the fact that you paid for the game; you still can't play. You can forget about playing single-player HL2 anywhere where network connectivity might not exist (in an airport, on an airplane or bus, etc). Hell, once on a two-vehicle trip from Kentucky to North Carolina, we set up a WAN between vehicles and played games. I realize HL2 is single-player but in the broader sense, this sort of setup won't work with games that require some sort of authentication with a company server.
I have no problem with online games requiring a network connection since that's the point of the game. I'm more dubious of games that require a network connection only so that you can obtain permission to play it.
Don't worry. There will be a crack for the game in no time, so if Vivendi goes out of business and doesn't provide some sort of update to eliminate the authentication, software pirates will.
Also, the chances of something happening to Vivendi's network center is pretty small. Not only that, but I'm sure they have backup systems spread across the country (or world, even). They will never be down for days at a time. But, even if they are, who cares? It's a freaking game. You can wait 36 hours to play.