Landlord ain't gettin' me! UPDATE: She tried to get me!!

KEV1N

Platinum Member
Jan 15, 2000
2,932
1
0
Like many people about this time of year, I had to move out of an apartment. I've had experience with this landlord trying to rip me off for VARIOUS things, so I scrubbed and cleaned and toiled over the apartment for two days. And like the nerd I am, I have photographic evidence which culminates in a web photo album.

Now if you were a landlord, would you return my security deposit?


Pics

I apologize if this post isn't coherent or interesting. I got some good whiffs of oven cleaner.

----------------------------------
Update, 9/9/03

I wanted to see her take my deposit. I wanted her to tell me in what sh!tty condition my apartment was left. I then wanted to show her the pictures and see her try to back out or lie to my face with photographic evidence right there. Well I got my wish!

Today, I got the letter from the complex. In it, was a generous $235.04 of our $530 deposit! Let the games begin!

Fsck the phone tag. I showed up 15 minutes after I got that letter and went straight into her office.

Manager: Why hello Kevin! How are you doing?
Me: I?m good! I?m here to see you because I have an issue with the deposit.
Manager: How can I help you?
Me: Why was I charged $294.96 to renovate my unit?
Manager: Well I didn?t do the inspection personally, so I?d have to pull your file.
Me: Could you?
::Manager returns with file::
Manager: Well it looks like there?s miscellaneous housecleaning charges.
Me: Yeah, that?s what it says on the invoice. I got down on my hands and knees and scrubbed every visible surface of that apartment.
Manager: Well, no matter how hard you clean, there will always be some charges.
Me: I?m obviously not a professional, but I know that I cleaned the apartment pretty well. I know that there wasn?t $300 worth of dirt left there, for sure.
Manager: Again, I wasn?t there.
Me: Can we look at some pictures?
Manager: I don?t have any?
Me: Can we look at my pictures?
Manager: Sure..

I hand her the URL to my web album. I?ve written it on a piece of paper to make it clear.

Manager: What?s that squiggly?
Me: It?s a tilde.
Manager: Tillduh??
Me: It?s right next to the one?
Manager: Uhhh

I walk over and show her the key.

Me: You hold shift and push that key.
Manager: Ok. L I U K.. E

The issue here isn?t that she is such a fscking moron that she didn?t know what a tilde was, because she obviously knew what that squiggly was. The point is that she is that type of person to stall to the very last minute detail.

Manager: Wow, hmm. It looks like a lot of random circles on this wall
Me: That?s from the flash. The color depth of your monitor is not deep enough to represent the change in shade
Manager: OK.. hmm. OK. Hmm.
Me: Click the right arrow to look at them all.
Manager: Hmm, OK. Hmm. OK. Well maybe the kitchen drip pans were dirty and the surface of the stove was dirty.
Me: Look at page 4. I have a photo of the stove.
Manager: Hmm. Ok.

The manager looks at this picture:
http://wwwcsif.cs.ucdavis.edu/~liuke/apt_pics/pages/DSCF0141.html

Manager: Well, it looks like maybe underneath the top shell might have been dirty. Did you clean that?
Me: Yes, but I don?t have a photo. Let?s say that it?s dirty. Is it $300 dirty? Can we use a little common sense?
Manager: Well I guess not. There seems to be spots?.
Me: I think we?re wasting our time here. I need to talk to someone else.
Manager: What you can do is email me these photos and I will send them to my regional manager. I have to go to my regional manager to make any adjustments.

This is obviously stalling again.

Me: OK. I?ll do that right now. May I use your computer lab?
Manager: Certainly!

She lets me into the computer lab which is adjacent to the manager?s office. I have to wait a while because there are 4 machines, all occupied. There is a girl waiting to use the computers too.

Girl: Is your thing quick?
Me: You can go ahead. I just need to cool down.
Girl: Why?
Me: Well it?s just the manager. You see?

I explain to her my deposit fiasco and all my previous bad experiences with the manager. This takes about 5 minutes.

Me: So this place is running a fscking scam pretty much. So when you move out, you?d better take a lot of pictures because it?s almost guaranteed that she?ll try to rob you.

Everybody was listening to me. That?s like 5 tenants in there.. you think, 5 apartments x $300 scammed deposit? I?ve liberated $1500 of their money by arming them with my experience. I was talking deliberately loudly.

Me: So I need email to her this link to all my photos. You can see them if you want and you can be the judge. If she doesn?t give me all my money back she is going down.

Literally 5 seconds after I said that, the computer lab door creaks open.

Manager: I can help you right here Kevin.

We walk back to her desk.

Manager: What I can do for you is adjust this cleaning charge here and remove this carpet charge. So you get your entire deposit back.

Me: Great. Thank you. (Thinking to self: Die)

Manager: I?m not too good at math. So since you already have that check.. how much do I owe you?

You can?t be serious. Good lord.

Me: My deposit is $530. I have a check for $235.04. Subtract that from $530.

Manager: Oh, OK. I?m not too good at math. Alright. I will send you a check.

Me: In seven days?

Manager: OK, in seven days.

Me: I?m not asking for anything in writing now because if I don?t get that check in seven days, you?ll definitely be hearing from me in several different ways.

Manager: I?m not a dishonest person! You can trust me!

There was pure hatred; hatred from within. I hadn?t felt that way in a long time. I seriously wanted to cut her face. I would?ve done it too if I had a sharp enough implement. I didn?t respond to her comment and I grit my teeth audibly.

Manager: I haven?t ever not done nothing I said I was going to do, have I?

I stood up right there and extended my hand for a handshake.

Me: I?ll watch the mail. Thanks.

I?m glad I took those pictures. I?m also glad that I get really mad over large sums of money.
 

narzy

Elite Member
Feb 26, 2000
7,006
1
81
LOL, what EXACTLY is he trying to stiff you with (whats his excuse other then being a fat disgusting slob who steals peoples money?) that is THE CLEANEST appartment I've ever seen.
 

KEV1N

Platinum Member
Jan 15, 2000
2,932
1
0
Originally posted by: narzy
LOL, what EXACTLY is he trying to stiff you with (whats his excuse other then being a fat disgusting slob who steals peoples money?) that is THE CLEANEST appartment I've ever seen.

She has been known to falsely accuse tenants of late payments (I have experienced this first hand and so have my neighbors). Not to mention we transferred to this apartment from another apartment within the complex, and she took our entire deposit during that move. It definitely wasn't as clean as it is this time, but then again it wasn't far off. Basically, I don't trust her one bit and neither do any of my neighbors. I swear if one penny gets taken off my deposit, I will cut her
 

Lonyo

Lifer
Aug 10, 2002
21,938
6
81
Did you take pics when you moved in so you can compare the 2 in case she tries to rip you off? After pics are useless without before pics.
 

wyvrn

Lifer
Feb 15, 2000
10,074
0
0
When you vacuumed, you didn't leave the carpet pile all in one direction. That's a $30 deduction right there!
 

Karsten

Platinum Member
Oct 9, 1999
2,192
0
0
Originally posted by: wyvrn
When you vacuumed, you didn't leave the carpet pile all in one direction. That's a $30 deduction right there!

yeap ;) work on that vacuum technique!
 

tm37

Lifer
Jan 24, 2001
12,436
1
0
You will never get your deposit back.

I never clean apartments, I figure hell if they are going to charge me I might as well leave is messy.

My last place in San DIego (El Cajon) I got back 5 dollars :D
 

DainBramaged

Lifer
Jun 19, 2003
23,454
41
91
Originally posted by: tm37
You will never get your deposit back.

I never clean apartments, I figure hell if they are going to charge me I might as well leave is messy.

My last place in San DIego (El Cajon) I got back 5 dollars :D

My grandfather gives deposits back all the time if they are deserved. All you have to do is clean throughly and make sure the carpets are clean. If you trashed out the carpet, just rent a carpet cleaner. No biggie.
 

dxkj

Lifer
Feb 17, 2001
11,772
2
81
Originally posted by: Lonyo
Did you take pics when you moved in so you can compare the 2 in case she tries to rip you off? After pics are useless without before pics.

doesnt really matter..... the pictures he took there shows it in perfect condition, what would the before pictures show? The carpet was really purple and the walls were pink? :p
 

Ylen13

Banned
Sep 18, 2001
2,457
0
0
you do not have to scrubbe the appartment super clean. All it have to be is reasonable clean.
 

KEV1N

Platinum Member
Jan 15, 2000
2,932
1
0
We'll see.. I'll update this when the deposit comes back. If it does!! Har har!
 

RaiseUp

Banned
Dec 7, 2002
1,273
0
0
We own Several Apartments and I must say You did a great job. We would like to have tenants like you. One Time a Renter just left and stained the carpet, broke the windows etc.
 

DanceMan

Senior member
Jan 26, 2001
474
0
0
Originally posted by: spidey07
No.

Because I don't have to give it to you.

Uh-Huh. You think...

In some states, if you show that you have left the apartment reasonably clean (which means that normal wear and tear are *not* counted against you), you are lawfully entitled to your full deposit amount back within some set time (usually 30-60 days, I think). If it is not returned to you in that time, then the landlord is liable for treble the amount (x3) of the security deposit.

Also some state require that the security deposit be placed into a joint-owned bank account between tenant and landlord (NJ required this).

DanceMan
 

spidey07

No Lifer
Aug 4, 2000
65,469
5
76
sure,

if you want to go thru the trouble of small claims court.

-edit- oh yeah, laws vary greatly from state to state.
 

SuperTool

Lifer
Jan 25, 2000
14,000
2
0
bleh. one time I got screwed out of a chunk of my deposit for leaving a stain inside the oven. It was one of those really stuck on stains. I cleaned it, but there was still a shade of it left. And I never even used the oven once the whole time I lived there. Not much of a cook.
 

SuperTool

Lifer
Jan 25, 2000
14,000
2
0
Also, for people moving, I recommend aptratings
You can leave a nasty review of your apartment complex if they screw you. I wouldn't trust the positive reviews as fast as the negative ones, since the managers sometimes post there too.
 

przero

Platinum Member
Dec 30, 2000
2,060
0
0
I worked for apartment complexes for the last 17 years. Here in Baton Rouge, La. most of the larger complexes refund your deposit less the cost of "professional carpet cleaning"(about $35.00). Your carpet looks that clean. For all the different complexes I work at - Yep, you would get it all back. Provided, of course, you fulfilled the terms of your lease. They don't jack with deposit much down here. Maybe the "mom and pop" properties do, but not the larger outfits.
 

KEV1N

Platinum Member
Jan 15, 2000
2,932
1
0

RalphWiggum

Senior member
Feb 20, 2001
466
0
0
good luck getting that deposit back. IF your landlord is as bad as you say, she'll probably expect the oven interior and fridge cleaned also. Our landlord expected us to clean under the fridge, and that was after we had spend all day cleaning. Also, make sure your bathroom/tub is clean too... Ours was annoyed we didn't get it perfectly white again.
 

KEV1N

Platinum Member
Jan 15, 2000
2,932
1
0
Originally posted by: RalphWiggum
good luck getting that deposit back. IF your landlord is as bad as you say, she'll probably expect the oven interior and fridge cleaned also. Our landlord expected us to clean under the fridge, and that was after we had spend all day cleaning. Also, make sure your bathroom/tub is clean too... Ours was annoyed we didn't get it perfectly white again.

Yep, cleaned the oven, fridge, and bathroom. I have pics of everything except the interior of the oven (forgot).

If you're interested in what happened last year, I found the archived post.

http://forums.anandtech.com/messageview.cfm?catid=38&threadid=874425&FTVAR_MSGDBTABLE=arc