Originally posted by: Nothinman
The pivx.com list that I was talking about, applied to IE not Moz, just making that clear.
But even so it would have been a rogue organization running it and wouldn't have a chance of having the same bugs as MS' internal bug tracker, making it just about worthless.
"Rogue organization"? It was (is) a 3rd-party security consulting firm.
Certainly you are right, it wouldn't have been nearly as "complete" as any internal bug-tracking list from MS itself, but that list is certainly MS-private, whereas this other list served a valuable purpose - letting end-users know, that there is a list of known security defects in the software in question.
I'm guessing that MS didn't exactly like the fact that other companies were pointing out serious defects in their "pride and joy", IE, because some users might get smart, and stop using it.
You know, one of the key events that helped end slavery in this country, was that they (the slaves) started to educate themselves, even against the will of their masters, and of the structures of society in general, that supported the oppression of the slaves, and assisted their masters.
I see the laws protecting the corporate masters, and keeping the users (feudal servants/slaves) uneducated at the same time.
If you are not allowed to "look under the hood" youself, nor is anyone else allowed to communicate what they have found out, then how can anyone educate themselves (with regards to technological systems)?
This present time really is the "new age of feudalism". Open-source OSes like Linux, are very much like the revolutions, that finally allowed peasant landowners to own their own "homes". It's really sad, and a disturbing blow to "freedom", when so many in industry and gov't are arguing directly against allowing private ownership of one's own computer and the software (OS) that drives it, instead attempting to mandate that one "lease" that OS from a gov't-approved "feudal lord" (aka MS).
We really need to have a "F the Dmca day" - call it "Worldwide reverse-engineering day", and every techie should pick a piece of software or something technology related, and reverse-engineer it, and disclose the results that they find out to the world, *regardless* of any sort of legal prohibitions against the discovery of such knowledge.