Brees is out for me this week, and someone got Foles from under me on Waiver last night. She texted me this morning thinking I'd actually trade for him. Yeeeeeah, no thanks.
So, do I gamble on Eli @ Min, or Freeman vs. Giants?
I've also got the following available:
Henne vs. SD, Ben vs. Baltimore, Bradford @ Carolina, Dalton @ Detroit, Tennehill vs. Buffalo, Flacco @ Pittsburgh, Geno vs. NE, Weeden @ GB, and Glennon @ Atl
I am currently sitting Vick on my bench as QB2. It's not looking likely that he'll start, but I may keep him until the end of the week before dropping him for one of the others above. Ya never know.
Tannehill, read my above post (he's 6th in QB rating on PFF), he's poised to turn into a really good QB. Considering Miami's defense is a plus play against Buffalo's QB Merry Go Round, Tannehill should get plenty of time to work. Also consider that Buffalo's run defense is 8th on the year so Miami will be forced to throw more against Buffalo's average secondary. Thaddeus Lewis (+1.2) and Brian Hoyer (+1.8) posted plus positive recent games and Tannehill is better than both. In addition, Tannehill's only been pressured on 1/3 of dropbacks (9th best), but oddly enough all of his pressures = sacks and he leads the league in being sacked. This is definitely something he can correct by checking down faster and/or recognizing when to throw the ball away. For example, RG3/Brees/Rodgers have around the same time to throw before pressure but have thrown it away 2-2.5X more instead of taking the sack (8-10 vs Tannehill's 4). Luckily Buffalo is #21 in Pass Rush to match up with Tannehill's average Pass blocking which should be highly favorable.
My 2nd vote is Weeden who has an ideal matchup since GB stuffs the run and he will be forced to pass against GB's crappy secondary. In addition, GB has the 3rd worst pass rush so Weeden should have a good amount of time to throw. This will be another QB matchup like GB/Ravens last week and Weeden/Cleveland have a decent chance of winning. Also keep in mind that Flacco (+1.2) and Tannehill (+4.4) have posted + numbers against Green Bay so it's time for Weeden to follow their lead. The only downside is that Weeden is the least accurate in the league under pressure (33%) so GB will be blitzing to exploit that and it will come down to how well Weeden can beat that.
Henne vs SD would be #3, but if the Chargers decide to run a lot like they did vs Indy, you're screwed! Keep in mind Jax has the WORST run defense in the league so this is a very real outcome. However, SD has the WORST Pass coverage in the league (Luck should have sliced and diced if his receivers didn't drop every pass to kill drives) so Henne's receivers should be open a lot. Jax's pass blocking is actually decent (13th) vs SD below average pass rush. It's just a matter of how much time of possession will Henne have to throw with SD (and all of Jax's opponents) running the ball all day.
Glennon could have a decent day, the numbers are in his favor (horrid ATL pass coverage and pass rush, TB is average in pass blocking) but he's still error prone Glennon.
Big Ben vs Flacco, not touching that game since it's a rivalry and both teams have major issues (Flacco horrendous pass protection, Big Ben goes against a monster pass rush + Ben's 7th highest sack rate under pressure).
Dalton, going up against a good pass rush (7th best) and is 41% Completion under pressure with the same sack rate as Big Ben under pressure (22%). Not ideal.
Bradford going up against an above average pass rush and very good Pass Coverage team. Even with his good OL, too risky. If Carolina gets pressure on him, he's toast at 3rd worst completion % under pressure.
Geno, bottom half OL and Pats are a great cover team. They won't get a ton of pressure on him but have proven they can shut down good QBs like Brees. Of course Talib may not play but they are still nothing to scoff at as his backup did superb. Only Logan Ryan (CB) and Steve Gregory (SS) had negative numbers but that was against Brees. Geno could try picking on Logan Ryan, he's the only weakness in that secondary. However, I don't see him having a big day even without NE's lack of a pass rush.