is it a good thing to shield your children from alcohol?

Page 3 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

IronWing

No Lifer
Jul 20, 2001
73,135
34,439
136
I also disagree with the posters who think that giving alcohol to children will somehow inoculate them to alcoholism or alcohol abuse later in life. Alcohol isn't a vaccine.
 

IronWing

No Lifer
Jul 20, 2001
73,135
34,439
136
Originally posted by: Howard
Originally posted by: cKGunslinger
Originally posted by: meltdown75
Originally posted by: TallBill
Anything that you "shield" a person from will ultimately be discovered, enjoyed, and abused.
:thumbsup:

I know! That why I have hardcore porn, loaded guns, razor blades and cocaine sitting on my coffee table. Fuck those stupid parents that "shield" their kids from "life!"
Yes, because if it's not on your coffee table your kids won't be able to get it.

The question isn't whether or not kids will ever <enter vice of your choice>; the question is whether or not they think their parents approve, disapprove, or are indifferent to the behavior and whether they view partaking as the norm.
 

0roo0roo

No Lifer
Sep 21, 2002
64,795
84
91
Originally posted by: ironwing
I also disagree with the posters who think that giving alcohol to children will somehow inoculate them to alcoholism or alcohol abuse later in life. Alcohol isn't a vaccine.

its not, but it takes the thrill of the forbidden out of it for certain. i was offered a small glass of wine on occasion when i was small. i didn't see what the fuss was about.

sure some will turn into drunks, but that would have probably happened regardless.
 
S

SlitheryDee

The only true protection is knowledge and self control. Both can be taught, but both require exposure to the thing in question. Lack of that exposure leaves nothing but a mysterious and attractive void that cannot be filled with comments and warnings about the thing, but only the thing itself. Best to fill that void in circumstances where the responsibilities that come with it can be properly demonstrated.
 

IronWing

No Lifer
Jul 20, 2001
73,135
34,439
136
Originally posted by: SlitheryDee
The only true protection is knowledge and self control. Both can be taught, but both require exposure to the thing in question. Lack of that exposure leaves nothing but a mysterious and attractive void that cannot be filled with comments and warnings about the thing, but only the thing itself. Best to fill that void in circumstances where the experience and the responsibilities that come with it can be properly passed on.

Yet, I've never had gay sex.
 
S

SlitheryDee

Originally posted by: ironwing
Originally posted by: SlitheryDee
The only true protection is knowledge and self control. Both can be taught, but both require exposure to the thing in question. Lack of that exposure leaves nothing but a mysterious and attractive void that cannot be filled with comments and warnings about the thing, but only the thing itself. Best to fill that void in circumstances where the experience and the responsibilities that come with it can be properly passed on.

Yet, I've never had gay sex.

Then your parents have failed you. :(


Edit: ^^ I have no idea how "You know you want to" :p became that...SlitheryDee needs rest...
 

IEC

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Jun 10, 2004
14,602
6,088
136
Originally posted by: l0cke
I've got a friend who is going to college this month and it will be his first time away from his parents. They try to shield him from everything. They don't let him drive even though he has his liscense and he has to come home by 10pm on weekends.

Can you imagine what he will do when he gets to college?

I've seen it more than ten times in the four years I was in college... sometimes, they don't come back...
 

Finalnight

Golden Member
Mar 5, 2003
1,891
1
76
Originally posted by: SlitheryDee
The only true protection is knowledge and self control. Both can be taught, but both require exposure to the thing in question. Lack of that exposure leaves nothing but a mysterious and attractive void that cannot be filled with comments and warnings about the thing, but only the thing itself. Best to fill that void in circumstances where the responsibilities that come with it can be properly demonstrated.

Hmm, never had a sip of alcohol, yet I have no attaction to that "mystery".

Originally posted by: Spartan Niner
Originally posted by: l0cke
I've got a friend who is going to college this month and it will be his first time away from his parents. They try to shield him from everything. They don't let him drive even though he has his liscense and he has to come home by 10pm on weekends.

Can you imagine what he will do when he gets to college?

I've seen it more than ten times in the four years I was in college... sometimes, they don't come back...

Yeah, that is just stupid, driving is a skill built up by experience and experience only.
 

irishScott

Lifer
Oct 10, 2006
21,562
3
0
If you do, you have to do it right. I was taught extensively about every drug on the planet via public schooling in 6th - 7th grade. My parents never really did much aside from the errant comment, but there was no exposure to these things at my house. I have never gotten drunk to date (although I have no problem getting a little tipsy), have never even thought about smoking, and am only now considering trying MJ once just to see what it's like. Under no circumstances would I start a habit of the latter.

Point is, you educate without exposure; and things tend to work out well if/when the exposure comes. Goes for most things in life.
 

Pheran

Diamond Member
Apr 26, 2001
5,740
35
91
Originally posted by: ironwing
I'm going to disagree with dang near everybody in this thread. Having a no alcohol rule in the house isn't really a shield from knowledge or exposure, as the kids will know about alcohol from TV, movies, friends, etc. It does send a strong message that their parents don't approve of drinking.

Which would make no sense, since I don't disapprove of responsible drinking.
 

fleabag

Banned
Oct 1, 2007
2,450
1
0
Originally posted by: loki8481
Originally posted by: rudder
My dad is German so I have been around beer as long as I can remember. At first I thought I should hide it from my kids... but then thought about all the kids I knew growing up whose parents would not let them have sugar. They would come over and gorge themselves on a box of cookies.

No point in keeping it a mystery from the kids. Teach them responsibility and all will be good.

:thumbsup:

growing up, food in my house was like what I guess drugs/alcohol were in my friends' houses. I'd probably have gotten in more trouble for bringing home a half-empty bottle of coke in my backpack than coming home drunk off my ass. it all let to me being 400+ pounds in my mid 20's.

I've become such an ocd eater since I've been losing weight that I'm like perpetually worried about screwing with my kids heads if I have kids someday.

I don't know if you're exaggerating or being sarcastic but what ever.. That's the thing though, how do you teach your kids to eat well and understand that junk food is OK occasionally but not be extreme and have them end up in the deep end from doing both extremes. I've seen family households where the parents bring home junk food everyday and the kids much on it, becoming obese slobs and like you've said where these kids are deprived of this stuff and end up as the same obese slobs as you worked so hard to prevent them from being...?
 

miketheidiot

Lifer
Sep 3, 2004
11,060
1
0
Originally posted by: spidey07
That's one way to have an alcoholic kid. It's one of the reasons other countries don't have such a big problem with alcohol abuse as the states, kids are exposed to it early, drink it early and understand moderation.

this is a pretty unamerican post, what are you a marxist?
 

miketheidiot

Lifer
Sep 3, 2004
11,060
1
0
Originally posted by: MovingTarget
No binging, heavy drinking, etc.

Then again, being raised Catholic probably helped. :p
huh?

being raised catholic woudl make you a heavy drinker :beer:
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
AFAIK the statistics show that parents who drink are more likely to have kids who drink. This is one of the reasons I stopped (main was tired of headaches the next day). I'm not evangelical about it and don't ridicule the habit like I do smoking, and it's ok if people drink at my house, but I just don't do it.

The problem with the "show them alcohol in moderation" crowd is that many people don't drink in moderation, dare I say most? Having a few beer every night is not moderation, I would say that's an unnatural reliance. Dito on cranking through a six pack on Saturday night. Kids see these behaviors and what they see seems natural to them.

In any case, there are so many variations from the norm (dry household producing a binge drinker or growing up around an alcoholic perhaps scaring a kid away from the same) that it's hard to read too much into any of this anyway. I aim to be a good role model for my kids and in my case my life appears better without any alcohol, so that's what they'll see. Whereas others are still asleep, no beer the night before let me get up at 5:30 and go for a run, so that's what they see.
 

AyashiKaibutsu

Diamond Member
Jan 24, 2004
9,306
4
81
Let your kids have a sip of dark beer every once in a while when they're little. They'll think it's the nastiest thing in the world and will be hesitant about trying it more later. Better than waiting till their 16 and their friends are encouraging them to chug as fast as possible and then they won't even remember how nasty the stuff tastes after the fact. Repeat a few times and their used to the taste and on their way to becoming alcoholics (maybe).
 

Fingolfin269

Lifer
Feb 28, 2003
17,948
34
91
Originally posted by: Ackmed
Originally posted by: TallBill
Anything that you "shield" a person from will ultimately be discovered, enjoyed, and abused.

This is a false, and ignorant statement. Dont try to pass off your opinions, as facts.

I wasnt exposed to alcohol at all. And I dont drink to this day, I can count the beers Ive had on one hand, and Im 34. I was exposed to smoke (both parents smoked).. and dont smoke, and have never even tried it. Not a puff. I was exposed to dip/chew, but have never tried it. I wasnt exposed to drugs growing up, and I have never done an illegal drug. So in short, I dont drink, smoke, dip, or do drugs. Being exposed and not exposed equally to these products.

You cant base what someone will do 100% of the time, by how they were brought up. Most people with opinions on things such as this, dont even have kids.

Damn man what's the craziest thing you did in high school/college? Cow tipping?
 

onlyCOpunk

Platinum Member
May 25, 2003
2,532
1
0
you can try to shield your children all you want, but when they are 16 and at a party and everyone is yelling "chug chug chug" you better believe they are going to chug their beer.
 

Sea Moose

Diamond Member
May 12, 2009
6,933
7
76
Originally posted by: onlyCOpunk
you can try to shield your children all you want, but when they are 16 and at a party and everyone is yelling "chug chug chug" you better believe they are going to chug their beer.

:laugh: yup
 

Tremulant

Diamond Member
Jul 2, 2004
4,890
1
0
My parents let me drink with them during dinner and at parties. Even though we've always had alcohol in the house, they are social drinkers and really only keep it for parties.

I'm not a big fan of alcohol (or any drugs -- I don't like the feeling that I'm out of control), but I don't mind having a few drinks with friends. I just stop before I get shitfaced and can't remember anything (which has happened in the past, so I've learned my limits).
 

oogabooga

Diamond Member
Jan 14, 2003
7,806
3
81
Originally posted by: Sea Moose
Originally posted by: onlyCOpunk
you can try to shield your children all you want, but when they are 16 and at a party and everyone is yelling "chug chug chug" you better believe they are going to chug their beer.

:laugh: yup

:beer: :beer: :beer: ;)

People need to learn that not talking about things doesn't make them disappear. Your kids will find out one way or another about booze - From that perspective you'd think it'd be better you explain it then their friends.
 

Miramonti

Lifer
Aug 26, 2000
28,653
100
106
Its more important for kids to be healthy psychologically than anything else.

For example encouraging them in ways that strengthen a healthy self-esteem etc. Many kids do things to be cool, but in general they are in a better spot if they already feel good about themselves before confronted with the many pressures while growing up.

Its also better imo to teach them about issues associated with drinking and drugs, rather than blanketing the topic of drinking and drugs as 'an evil issue' and thus wrongly try and shelter kids from the realities of them.