Worth it, probably not to most people. But to me I went with both Plextors you mentioned and don't regret it one bit. They have been a major force in PC optical drives for a while and have always proven to be highly reliable so I will continue to pay the premium. Sometimes you can find a good deal on them, IIRC, I saw them as low as $109.99 after a rebate, some may have found them even cheaper.