• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Hypothetical "eye for an eye" world?

ManyBeers

ManyBeers

Platinum Member
...person i.e. actual physical violations of a persons body that the standard of punishment will
be an"eye for an eye". If a killer murders someone and is found guilty he/she will be executed in the same fashion he/she used to kill their victim (at least as near as possible to the method used by killer). If someone assaults and beats somebody they will in turn be equally beaten and so on. I think you get the point.

So a woman is attacked by a rapist and he overpowers her and forces vaginal intercourse on her and leaves her. She suffers bruising and minor injuries but nothing that is permanent physically. What "eye for an eye" punishment is appropriate for this crime? And is it sufficient punishment?
 
Originally posted by: ManyBeers
...person i.e. actual physical violations of a persons body that the standard of punishment will
be an"eye for an eye". If a killer murders someone and is found guilty he/she will be executed in the same fashion he/she used to kill their victim (at least as near as possible to the method used by killer). If someone assaults and beats somebody they will in turn be equally beaten and so on. I think you get the point.

So a woman is attacked by a rapist and he overpowers her and forces vaginal intercourse on her and leaves her. She suffers bruising and minor injuries but nothing that is permanent physically. What "eye for an eye" punishment is appropriate for this crime? And is it sufficient punishment?
Click to expand...

Violation via old broomstick with splinters and all, after it's been sitting in water for a few days so the end is fat.

and no lube, while listening to BSB "i want it that way"
 
What if said raped woman overpowers her rapist and kills him. Will the appropriate punishment be that she gets to rape someone and that person gets to overpower her and kill her?
 
Terrible terrible idea. Let's say I get accused of brutally killing some guy. I go to trial and I'm find guilty. They then brutally and painfully kill me. 5 years later new technology is discovered with exonerates me. But guess what, you can't undo brutally torturing and killing someone, had I gone to prison they could have just let me out. There is a reason we have laws against cruel and unusual punishment.

 
Originally posted by: 2Xtreme21
What if said raped woman overpowers her rapist and kills him. Will the appropriate punishment be that she gets to rape someone and that person gets to overpower her and kill her?
Click to expand...

....

*facepalm*
 
Originally posted by: ManyBeers
...person i.e. actual physical violations of a persons body that the standard of punishment will
be an"eye for an eye". If a killer murders someone and is found guilty he/she will be executed in the same fashion he/she used to kill their victim (at least as near as possible to the method used by killer). If someone assaults and beats somebody they will in turn be equally beaten and so on. I think you get the point.

So a woman is attacked by a rapist and he overpowers her and forces vaginal intercourse on her and leaves her. She suffers bruising and minor injuries but nothing that is permanent physically. What "eye for an eye" punishment is appropriate for this crime? And is it sufficient punishment?
Click to expand...

What if said female victim gets pregnant? How you gonna knock the guy up?

Mayhaps she should get an abortion, and the "eye-for-eye" justice is that the rapist gets aborted as well?
 
Originally posted by: CrazyLazy
Terrible terrible idea. Let's say I get accused of brutally killing some guy. I go to trial and I'm find guilty. They then brutally and painfully kill me. 5 years later new technology is discovered with exonerates me. But guess what, you can't undo brutally torturing and killing someone, had I gone to prison they could have just let me out. There is a reason we have laws against cruel and unusual punishment.
Click to expand...

Totally beside the point. For the sake of argument the perp is beyond doubt guilty.
 
Originally posted by: SunnyD
Originally posted by: ManyBeers
...person i.e. actual physical violations of a persons body that the standard of punishment will
be an"eye for an eye". If a killer murders someone and is found guilty he/she will be executed in the same fashion he/she used to kill their victim (at least as near as possible to the method used by killer). If someone assaults and beats somebody they will in turn be equally beaten and so on. I think you get the point.

So a woman is attacked by a rapist and he overpowers her and forces vaginal intercourse on her and leaves her. She suffers bruising and minor injuries but nothing that is permanent physically. What "eye for an eye" punishment is appropriate for this crime? And is it sufficient punishment?
Click to expand...

What if said female victim gets pregnant? How you gonna knock the guy up?

Mayhaps she should get an abortion, and the "eye-for-eye" justice is that the rapist gets aborted as well?
Click to expand...

She doesn';t get pregnant. The gut wore a rubber. Whatever. She doesn't get pregnant or contact any disease.
 
Originally posted by: 2Xtreme21
What if said raped woman overpowers her rapist and kills him. Will the appropriate punishment be that she gets to rape someone and that person gets to overpower her and kill her?
Click to expand...

the eye for an eye punishment here calls for your head to now asplode.
 
Originally posted by: Jeeebus
Originally posted by: 2Xtreme21
What if said raped woman overpowers her rapist and kills him. Will the appropriate punishment be that she gets to rape someone and that person gets to overpower her and kill her?
Click to expand...

the eye for an eye punishment here calls for your head to now assplode.
Click to expand...

lol
 
Originally posted by: Ns1
Originally posted by: 2Xtreme21
What if said raped woman overpowers her rapist and kills him. Will the appropriate punishment be that she gets to rape someone and that person gets to overpower her and kill her?
Click to expand...

....

*facepalm*
Click to expand...

Nothing happens to her as she killed in self defense.
 
Worst idea ever. You shouldn't take "eye for an eye" literally in today's world. Just let them get their lethal injection as they normally would.
 
Originally posted by: 2Xtreme21
What if said raped woman overpowers her rapist and kills him. Will the appropriate punishment be that she gets to rape someone and that person gets to overpower her and kill her?
Click to expand...

Fail.
 
Originally posted by: Jeeebus
Originally posted by: 2Xtreme21
What if said raped woman overpowers her rapist and kills him. Will the appropriate punishment be that she gets to rape someone and that person gets to overpower her and kill her?
Click to expand...

the eye for an eye punishment here calls for your head to now asplode.
Click to expand...

Just answer the questions posed. OK
 
Originally posted by: Ns1
Originally posted by: ManyBeers
...person i.e. actual physical violations of a persons body that the standard of punishment will
be an"eye for an eye". If a killer murders someone and is found guilty he/she will be executed in the same fashion he/she used to kill their victim (at least as near as possible to the method used by killer). If someone assaults and beats somebody they will in turn be equally beaten and so on. I think you get the point.

So a woman is attacked by a rapist and he overpowers her and forces vaginal intercourse on her and leaves her. She suffers bruising and minor injuries but nothing that is permanent physically. What "eye for an eye" punishment is appropriate for this crime? And is it sufficient punishment?
Click to expand...

Violation via old broomstick with splinters and all, after it's been sitting in water for a few days so the end is fat.

and no lube, while listening to BSB "i want it that way"
Click to expand...

I was thinking have him shower in the prison. With a waxed soapbar.
 
Originally posted by: Rufus12
Worst idea ever. You shouldn't take "eye for an eye" literally in today's world. Just let them get their lethal injection as they normally would.
Click to expand...

I can think of a few dozen crimes that don't result in capital punishment but should.
 
Originally posted by: Rufus12
Worst idea ever. You shouldn't take "eye for an eye" literally in today's world. Just let them get their lethal injection as they normally would.
Click to expand...

I'm not taking anything literally. I just posed a scenario and asked a couple 0f questions.
 
Originally posted by: ManyBeers
Originally posted by: Jeeebus
Originally posted by: 2Xtreme21
What if said raped woman overpowers her rapist and kills him. Will the appropriate punishment be that she gets to rape someone and that person gets to overpower her and kill her?
Click to expand...

the eye for an eye punishment here calls for your head to now asplode.
Click to expand...

Just answer the questions posed. OK
Click to expand...

OK!


This thread is now about bagles. I prefer blueberry with light creamcheese.
 
Originally posted by: ManyBeers
Originally posted by: SunnyD
Originally posted by: ManyBeers
...person i.e. actual physical violations of a persons body that the standard of punishment will
be an"eye for an eye". If a killer murders someone and is found guilty he/she will be executed in the same fashion he/she used to kill their victim (at least as near as possible to the method used by killer). If someone assaults and beats somebody they will in turn be equally beaten and so on. I think you get the point.

So a woman is attacked by a rapist and he overpowers her and forces vaginal intercourse on her and leaves her. She suffers bruising and minor injuries but nothing that is permanent physically. What "eye for an eye" punishment is appropriate for this crime? And is it sufficient punishment?
Click to expand...

What if said female victim gets pregnant? How you gonna knock the guy up?

Mayhaps she should get an abortion, and the "eye-for-eye" justice is that the rapist gets aborted as well?
Click to expand...

She doesn';t get pregnant. The gut wore a rubber. Whatever. She doesn't get pregnant or contact any disease.
Click to expand...

You're changing the rules. In said world... my question for you is in the case that the perp raped the victim and got her pregnant... would would be the fitting punishment? (Aside from child support)

You have to take your hypotheticals all the way and not just apply it to one situation.
 
Originally posted by: SunnyD

You're changing the rules. In said world... my question for you is in the case that the perp raped the victim and got her pregnant... would would be the fitting punishment? (Aside from child support)

You have to take your hypotheticals all the way and not just apply it to one situation.
Click to expand...

Walk around with a durian fruit shoved up his ass for 9 months and then make him deliver that shit.
 
Originally posted by: Ns1
Originally posted by: ManyBeers
...person i.e. actual physical violations of a persons body that the standard of punishment will
be an"eye for an eye". If a killer murders someone and is found guilty he/she will be executed in the same fashion he/she used to kill their victim (at least as near as possible to the method used by killer). If someone assaults and beats somebody they will in turn be equally beaten and so on. I think you get the point.

So a woman is attacked by a rapist and he overpowers her and forces vaginal intercourse on her and leaves her. She suffers bruising and minor injuries but nothing that is permanent physically. What "eye for an eye" punishment is appropriate for this crime? And is it sufficient punishment?
Click to expand...

Violation via old broomstick with splinters and all, after it's been sitting in water for a few days so the end is fat.

and no lube, while listening to BSB "i want it that way"
Click to expand...

I don't think that would qualify as an"eye for an eye" punishment.
 
Originally posted by: Ns1
Originally posted by: SunnyD

You're changing the rules. In said world... my question for you is in the case that the perp raped the victim and got her pregnant... would would be the fitting punishment? (Aside from child support)

You have to take your hypotheticals all the way and not just apply it to one situation.
Click to expand...

Walk around with a durian fruit shoved up his ass for 9 months and then make him deliver that shit.
Click to expand...

:thumbsup:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top