• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

How I'd fix the economy.

Page 4 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Originally posted by: darkswordsman17
Originally posted by: Knight7
the way i look at it, at least he has ideas on what to do to fix it, if you pay attention, 5000 tax break on an american car is pretty sweet, that would save some of the rednecks from getting fired from the factories in new mexico, and the low payed mexicans they manage. the paying people debt part, only rich people have debts thats more than 10k. that would take the working class out of a big interest 10k debt that over 5 years would be 20k, which is a lot when u only make 25-30k a year before taxes. and Shit they just gave 700 billion dollars to these jews in wall street, outta my and your tax money so why can we get a piece? if i had that stupid hat on my head im sure it will be a different story.

What classifies an American car? The Chrysler's made in Mexico? The GMs made in Canada? The Toyotas made in America?

You're a dumbass if you think its only rich who have more than 10k in debt. There are a lot of people who didn't have money to buy a house who were given loans for 100k+, and there are a lot of people who have 15-20k in student loans on top of a few thousand in credit card debt. That doesn't include the ones that also probably owe 10k on their car on top of some of that.

talkin about credit card debt. for a average person to make a 10k debt it would take a lil while. and even if they have it, mostly it was getting things they needed, no some face treatment in some Chinese Korean spa, those school loans u mentioned and the car loans would qualify u for the break that AMDHUNTER is proposing, also a car loan as long as u can prove u use that car for business, going to work or working in it, you should be able to qualify a 5000 break would drop the payments on school loans and car loans by some dollars.
 
Originally posted by: amdhunter
Originally posted by: Queasy
amdhunter should run for Congress. His idea is just as looney as the current $850billion/$1trillion+ "Stimulus Plan" that is going through Congress now which is nothing more than a transfer of wealth from the politically unconnected to the politically well-connected.

🙂

On second thought, I support amdhunter's plan over the current "Stimulus Plan". At least his plan puts money in the taxpayer's pocket instead of the politician's.
 
Originally posted by: Knight7
Originally posted by: darkswordsman17
Originally posted by: Knight7
the way i look at it, at least he has ideas on what to do to fix it, if you pay attention, 5000 tax break on an american car is pretty sweet, that would save some of the rednecks from getting fired from the factories in new mexico, and the low payed mexicans they manage. the paying people debt part, only rich people have debts thats more than 10k. that would take the working class out of a big interest 10k debt that over 5 years would be 20k, which is a lot when u only make 25-30k a year before taxes. and Shit they just gave 700 billion dollars to these jews in wall street, outta my and your tax money so why can we get a piece? if i had that stupid hat on my head im sure it will be a different story.

What classifies an American car? The Chrysler's made in Mexico? The GMs made in Canada? The Toyotas made in America?

You're a dumbass if you think its only rich who have more than 10k in debt. There are a lot of people who didn't have money to buy a house who were given loans for 100k+, and there are a lot of people who have 15-20k in student loans on top of a few thousand in credit card debt. That doesn't include the ones that also probably owe 10k on their car on top of some of that.

talkin about credit card debt. for a average person to make a 10k debt it would take a lil while. and even if they have it, mostly it was getting things they needed, no some face treatment in some Chinese Korean spa

exactly. lmy debt it due to a job change and home improvement. the only part of it that would be considered luxury was my laptop after my computer died

 
How to fix the economy:
Tempory adjustment in tax table.

Up to $50,000 exempt from federal income tax.
Raise taxes 10% on those making more than $100,000

I don't believe in wealth redistribution, but this would fix the economy.
You give money to people who are going to spend it (the working class).
 
Originally posted by: UDT89
Originally posted by: Knight7
Originally posted by: darkswordsman17
Originally posted by: Knight7
the way i look at it, at least he has ideas on what to do to fix it, if you pay attention, 5000 tax break on an american car is pretty sweet, that would save some of the rednecks from getting fired from the factories in new mexico, and the low payed mexicans they manage. the paying people debt part, only rich people have debts thats more than 10k. that would take the working class out of a big interest 10k debt that over 5 years would be 20k, which is a lot when u only make 25-30k a year before taxes. and Shit they just gave 700 billion dollars to these jews in wall street, outta my and your tax money so why can we get a piece? if i had that stupid hat on my head im sure it will be a different story.

What classifies an American car? The Chrysler's made in Mexico? The GMs made in Canada? The Toyotas made in America?

You're a dumbass if you think its only rich who have more than 10k in debt. There are a lot of people who didn't have money to buy a house who were given loans for 100k+, and there are a lot of people who have 15-20k in student loans on top of a few thousand in credit card debt. That doesn't include the ones that also probably owe 10k on their car on top of some of that.

talkin about credit card debt. for a average person to make a 10k debt it would take a lil while. and even if they have it, mostly it was getting things they needed, no some face treatment in some Chinese Korean spa

exactly. lmy debt it due to a job change and home improvement. the only part of it that would be considered luxury was my laptop after my computer died
home improvement? what your house was falling on top of you? or your wife just didnt like the tile on the kitchen floor? what ever reason u had you did not plan on changing jobs and having to make less money. so now wouldnt u agree that after all those years of u paying your taxes and "working hard" u deserve a at least 10k debt on the account of your choice?
 
One idea I would like to see is to make income earned through a severance package be tax free at the federal level or at least tax deferred.

I, along with a shit ton of other people in the country, got laid off last month. It really sucks balls to have to pay a shit ton of income tax on a severance pay. I paid nearly $4000 in taxes; that much money would be pretty damn helpful to get thru a few more months if need be. I think by not taxing, or at least deferring taxes, on severance package that may provide a sort of 'free' (it is a lost of tax revenue) and instant assistance to those that lost a job and were lucky enough to get a severance.

Also having the government subsidize or pay for COBRA could be a helpful benefit.
 
Let's bail out irresponsible people with responsible people's money, yay.

Fuck no, your plan basically says you don't have to take responsibility in life, we will bail you out when shit hits the fan.
 
Originally posted by: Knight7
Originally posted by: darkswordsman17
Originally posted by: Knight7
the way i look at it, at least he has ideas on what to do to fix it, if you pay attention, 5000 tax break on an american car is pretty sweet, that would save some of the rednecks from getting fired from the factories in new mexico, and the low payed mexicans they manage. the paying people debt part, only rich people have debts thats more than 10k. that would take the working class out of a big interest 10k debt that over 5 years would be 20k, which is a lot when u only make 25-30k a year before taxes. and Shit they just gave 700 billion dollars to these jews in wall street, outta my and your tax money so why can we get a piece? if i had that stupid hat on my head im sure it will be a different story.

What classifies an American car? The Chrysler's made in Mexico? The GMs made in Canada? The Toyotas made in America?

You're a dumbass if you think its only rich who have more than 10k in debt. There are a lot of people who didn't have money to buy a house who were given loans for 100k+, and there are a lot of people who have 15-20k in student loans on top of a few thousand in credit card debt. That doesn't include the ones that also probably owe 10k on their car on top of some of that.

talkin about credit card debt. for a average person to make a 10k debt it would take a lil while. and even if they have it, mostly it was getting things they needed, no some face treatment in some Chinese Korean spa, those school loans u mentioned and the car loans would qualify u for the break that AMDHUNTER is proposing, also a car loan as long as u can prove u use that car for business, going to work or working in it, you should be able to qualify a 5000 break would drop the payments on school loans and car loans by some dollars.

That's a valid point. However, even if you wipe that debt away, are people really in any place to afford their current situation? How long before they've got another 10k because they're not living within their means? Will they gain any incentive to save for the future?

Hell, I heard so many people say it wasn't until $4/gallon gas that they did anything about budgeting expenses or thinking about carpooling or anything to save money, and that is in a place where a car is basically a necessity (there's not a large public transportation infrastructure here and job distances can easily be 10 miles+ with a gamut of weather conditions that makes riding a bike not feasible) and should have been figured into their finances. They didn't have any budget for routine maintenance or say a random flat tire.
 
i think the reason why people got to were we are now is because of how things were 5-10 years back, in 2004-2005 i had a job that i was making easy 2500-3000 a week, (this is before taxes), at that point i walked to a dealer and said i want this car dont cared what it cost. just 6 months after i switched jobs beacuse that company i worked for closed down and i got stuck with a 700+ insurance payment on a car that after the first year wasnt worth what i pay. Because of that now there is no way in hell i would go on a car loan for 5-6 years, basically learn from your mistakes. thats another thing, why do i have to be stuck with a 50k loan on a car if after the first year the value goes under half of what i pay?
 
Those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it.

You cannot recover from a recession or depression by printing more money (runaway inflation anyone?) giveaways, government projects, or bailouts. The only way to do it is to generate new private sector jobs. You do that by getting rid of capital gains and corporate taxes. They are, in effect, just taxes on consumers anyhow and make us less competitive on the world market.
 
Originally posted by: Knight7
i think the reason why people got to were we are now is because of how things were 5-10 years back, in 2004-2005 i had a job that i was making easy 2500-3000 a week, (this is before taxes), at that point i walked to a dealer and said i want this car dont cared what it cost. just 6 months after i switched jobs beacuse that company i worked for closed down and i got stuck with a 700+ insurance payment on a car that after the first year wasnt worth what i pay. Because of that now there is no way in hell i would go on a car loan for 5-6 years, basically learn from your mistakes. thats another thing, why do i have to be stuck with a 50k loan on a car if after the first year the value goes under half of what i pay?

Because no one forced you buy the car? Why should I have to pay off your debt because you were too stupid to think about the future or bought something you couldn't actually afford (just because you were making enough to pay for it at the time does not mean you could afford it)?
 
Originally posted by: Amused
Those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it.

You cannot recover from a recession or depression by printing more money (runaway inflation anyone?) giveaways, government projects, or bailouts. The only way to do it is to generate new private sector jobs. You do that by getting rid of capital gains and corporate taxes. They are, in effect, just taxes on consumers anyhow and make us less competitive on the world market.

That is a huge failure in the mindset of traditional conservative voters.

You cannot go through the economic cycle backwards by giving the money to the corporations first and then hoping they will create jobs. A company will not create more jobs unless they see an increase in demand for their products, in order to do this the money needs to go to the consumer first and the the increase in demand for products will create jobs.

When given a handout, companies will not in unison go out and create jobs hoping that every other company on earth will create jobs also hoping that this will all at one indirectly create an increase in demand for their products.

That's going through the economic cycle backwards. It doesn't sound fair or nice, but if you want to stimulate the economic give low income and middle class (under $50k household income ) either tax breaks or money and they will spend it.
 
Originally posted by: darkswordsman17
Originally posted by: Knight7
i think the reason why people got to were we are now is because of how things were 5-10 years back, in 2004-2005 i had a job that i was making easy 2500-3000 a week, (this is before taxes), at that point i walked to a dealer and said i want this car dont cared what it cost. just 6 months after i switched jobs beacuse that company i worked for closed down and i got stuck with a 700+ insurance payment on a car that after the first year wasnt worth what i pay. Because of that now there is no way in hell i would go on a car loan for 5-6 years, basically learn from your mistakes. thats another thing, why do i have to be stuck with a 50k loan on a car if after the first year the value goes under half of what i pay?

Because no one forced you buy the car? Why should I have to pay off your debt because you were too stupid to think about the future or bought something you couldn't actually afford (just because you were making enough to pay for it at the time does not mean you could afford it)?

well thats my point, no one told you to go spend money on a laptop or remodeling your house just cause your wife didnt like the kitchen tiles and cabinets you werent planning on getting fired or let go. shit just happens, and even if you can still pay your debt why not get some help from your own tax money? or you rather give it to the jews in wall street?
 
Originally posted by: amdhunter
1) Wipe out everyone's Credit Card Debt -- the Government will pay it all. One time only up to $10k.

2) Bail out people with bad mortgages (by paying their debt up to that point), but they will not be allowed to keep the homes. They'd have 3 Months to save money and relocate or be forced back into their original agreements.

3) Raise Credit Ratings for everyone by 100 points, original credit scale remains the same.

4) Give everyone a $5000 rebate good only towards the purchase of an American Made Automobile.

5) For those people who are still messed up after all this help; ship them to Mexico.

What do you guys think?

You realize that would add $45 trillion to the national debt?
 
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: amdhunter
1) Wipe out everyone's Credit Card Debt -- the Government will pay it all. One time only up to $10k.

2) Bail out people with bad mortgages (by paying their debt up to that point), but they will not be allowed to keep the homes. They'd have 3 Months to save money and relocate or be forced back into their original agreements.

3) Raise Credit Ratings for everyone by 100 points, original credit scale remains the same.

4) Give everyone a $5000 rebate good only towards the purchase of an American Made Automobile.

5) For those people who are still messed up after all this help; ship them to Mexico.

What do you guys think?

Can we amend this to include any automobile made in America?

lol no some mercedes or bmw dont qualify
 
Originally posted by: Knight7
Originally posted by: darkswordsman17
Originally posted by: Knight7
i think the reason why people got to were we are now is because of how things were 5-10 years back, in 2004-2005 i had a job that i was making easy 2500-3000 a week, (this is before taxes), at that point i walked to a dealer and said i want this car dont cared what it cost. just 6 months after i switched jobs beacuse that company i worked for closed down and i got stuck with a 700+ insurance payment on a car that after the first year wasnt worth what i pay. Because of that now there is no way in hell i would go on a car loan for 5-6 years, basically learn from your mistakes. thats another thing, why do i have to be stuck with a 50k loan on a car if after the first year the value goes under half of what i pay?

Because no one forced you buy the car? Why should I have to pay off your debt because you were too stupid to think about the future or bought something you couldn't actually afford (just because you were making enough to pay for it at the time does not mean you could afford it)?

well thats my point, no one told you to go spend money on a laptop or remodeling your house just cause your wife didnt like the kitchen tiles and cabinets you werent planning on getting fired or let go. shit just happens, and even if you can still pay your debt why not get some help from your own tax money? or you rather give it to the jews in wall street?

That wasn't me, and so what I said applies to that all the same. Its not my fault you didn't even think about that when thinking about the future. If you're going to own a car or house you need to take into account that there will be maintenance costs involved and so you should take that into account when figuring if you can actually afford it or not. You should always take into account what would happen if you lost your job as well when figuring your budget.

Is the racism really necessary?
 
Originally posted by: darkswordsman17
Originally posted by: Knight7
Originally posted by: darkswordsman17
Originally posted by: Knight7
i think the reason why people got to were we are now is because of how things were 5-10 years back, in 2004-2005 i had a job that i was making easy 2500-3000 a week, (this is before taxes), at that point i walked to a dealer and said i want this car dont cared what it cost. just 6 months after i switched jobs beacuse that company i worked for closed down and i got stuck with a 700+ insurance payment on a car that after the first year wasnt worth what i pay. Because of that now there is no way in hell i would go on a car loan for 5-6 years, basically learn from your mistakes. thats another thing, why do i have to be stuck with a 50k loan on a car if after the first year the value goes under half of what i pay?

Because no one forced you buy the car? Why should I have to pay off your debt because you were too stupid to think about the future or bought something you couldn't actually afford (just because you were making enough to pay for it at the time does not mean you could afford it)?

well thats my point, no one told you to go spend money on a laptop or remodeling your house just cause your wife didnt like the kitchen tiles and cabinets you werent planning on getting fired or let go. shit just happens, and even if you can still pay your debt why not get some help from your own tax money? or you rather give it to the jews in wall street?

That wasn't me, and so what I said applies to that all the same. Its not my fault you didn't even think about that when thinking about the future. If you're going to own a car or house you need to take into account that there will be maintenance costs involved and so you should take that into account when figuring if you can actually afford it or not. You should always take into account what would happen if you lost your job as well when figuring your budget.

Is the racism really necessary?

no one saying its your fault if you saved money and were responsible fine, that just mean more money for the dumbasses who need it. the jew thing everybody knows wallstreet is controlled by them, im not being racist, i got a color tv at home.

 
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: amdhunter
1) Wipe out everyone's Credit Card Debt -- the Government will pay it all. One time only up to $10k.

2) Bail out people with bad mortgages (by paying their debt up to that point), but they will not be allowed to keep the homes. They'd have 3 Months to save money and relocate or be forced back into their original agreements.

3) Raise Credit Ratings for everyone by 100 points, original credit scale remains the same.

4) Give everyone a $5000 rebate good only towards the purchase of an American Made Automobile.

5) For those people who are still messed up after all this help; ship them to Mexico.

What do you guys think?

You realize that would add $45 trillion to the national debt?

300 million * $5000 = 1.5 trillion.

Another 3 trillion for his 10K debt reduction.

What about me, I don't have any debts? Can I get a 10K check? 10K prepayment towards my CCs will be ok.

Don't really need a new car, but to pocket $5K I'm sure I could buy one and resell it..
 
Originally posted by: amdhunter
Originally posted by: Brainonska511
Originally posted by: amdhunter
Originally posted by: Kyle
and where does the money come from? Plunging the country further in debt is not really a solution...

The government can just print all the money needed. Why should we go under debt when we have perfectly good printing presses?

Zimbabwe did that too and look where it got them.

No, Zimbabwe got that way because they have no real economy, 3rd world living conditions, no infrastructure and a bunch of douchebags running wild raping and pillaging.

The USA would NEVER turn into a Zimbabwe no matter how hard they tried.
have you ever heard of Detroit?
*ducks*
 
Originally posted by: thehstrybean
Originally posted by: amdhunter
Originally posted by: mAdMaLuDaWg
Originally posted by: amdhunter
Originally posted by: Kyle
and where does the money come from? Plunging the country further in debt is not really a solution...

The government can just print all the money needed. Why should we go under debt when we have perfectly good printing presses?

And what about people like myself who have lived responsibly and saved? What do I get besides more inflation??

Good job on being responsible. Unfortunately, you being responsible doesn't help things. Helping those that caused this mess will help things.

Inflation won't take place. In fact, competition will increase because of all the people looking to spend a little bit again, lowering prices across the board.

You obviously understand...nothing.
You can't print money without causing inflation. If you print it, the value goes down. The more of something there is, the less it's worth.

Yeah, just like the nintendo wii. they keep making more.. and the value..

no, wait..

hrmmm

 
Back
Top