How can a system be completely stable when overclocking?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Toro 45

Diamond Member
Oct 12, 1999
4,263
0
76
Originally posted by: Unkno
yea, i've read and thought about the 1T command rate....to eliminate this variable, i ran the same latencies (2.5-3-2-5 1T) on stock as overclocked but with the mem frequency at 200; there's no BSOD (knocks on wood)


if it's the powersupply, shouldn't it fail during the stress testing since that's when most of the power is drawn


what i'm thinking about trying is setting my cpu at 2560Mhz and with the same mem latencies (2.5-3-2-7 1T) but this time running a 133 mem divider making my ram freq at 169....this should isolate the problem if it's my ram


Better yet back the cpu down to 2555mhz and see if that takes care of your blue screens, if it does then you can decide if it is worth 5 extra mhz. to continue trouble shooting and possibly replacing the psu, etc...
 

Unkno

Golden Member
Jun 16, 2005
1,659
0
0
alright, so in an attempt to isolate the problem....i am first gonna try Toro's suggestion and run the cpu at 255fsb x 10 (2550Mhz) let's just hope it won't blue screen
 
May 5, 2006
96
0
0
Originally posted by: Parasitic
I'd bump up the voltage on the memory and drop the timing slightly. Try 2.65v and CAS 2.5-3-3-7.

I doubt the RAM is the problem, though I think a bump to 2.7v would be prudent. My 2GB Plats do 233 @ 2.5-3-2-5 with 2.7v and no stability issues in the last 6 months (OCZ recommends 2.7v and no more for their "stable" 220MHz overclock settings). I'm also running a x2 3800+ on a A8N-SLI Premium. It's currently at 281x9 and 333 div for 230MHz on RAM. I'd vote for PSU...
 

Unkno

Golden Member
Jun 16, 2005
1,659
0
0
Originally posted by: Link
Originally posted by: lopri
The first thing comes up to my mind is the PSU.

Asus A8N and Antec PSU made in 2005 are known to have problems.

great....i never even heard of this before...i still have warranty on my psu and mobo at the place where i bought it (extended warranty)...

if it was the psu or mobo, anyway to prove/test/show that its defected?


btw, i'm my A8N-E is a Rev. A3 and i'm using the newest bios 1013...
 

WobbleWobble

Diamond Member
Jun 29, 2001
4,867
1
0
Originally posted by: Unkno
Originally posted by: Link
Originally posted by: lopri
The first thing comes up to my mind is the PSU.

Asus A8N and Antec PSU made in 2005 are known to have problems.

great....i never even heard of this before...i still have warranty on my psu and mobo at the place where i bought it (extended warranty)...

if it was the psu or mobo, anyway to prove/test/show that its defected?


btw, i'm my A8N-E is a Rev. A3 and i'm using the newest bios 1013...

The problem was with the NeoHE line of PSUs, so I don't think it would be a compatibility issue with your Smart Power 2.0
 

Unkno

Golden Member
Jun 16, 2005
1,659
0
0
Originally posted by: WobbleWobble
Originally posted by: Unkno
Originally posted by: Link
Originally posted by: lopri
The first thing comes up to my mind is the PSU.

Asus A8N and Antec PSU made in 2005 are known to have problems.

great....i never even heard of this before...i still have warranty on my psu and mobo at the place where i bought it (extended warranty)...

if it was the psu or mobo, anyway to prove/test/show that its defected?


btw, i'm my A8N-E is a Rev. A3 and i'm using the newest bios 1013...

The problem was with the NeoHE line of PSUs, so I don't think it would be a compatibility issue with your Smart Power 2.0


yea, i've never heard anything wrong with the antec psu except with the P150 case that came with the neohe psu while using asus mobos.....but the problem was fixed in a few moths
 

Unkno

Golden Member
Jun 16, 2005
1,659
0
0
here's somewhat of an update.......it seems that my system blue screens whenever i exit out of standby (while overclocked and stock settings)....does this have anything to do with my instability?
 

Lonyo

Lifer
Aug 10, 2002
21,938
6
81
Originally posted by: Jeff7181
BSOD's are almost always hardware related... since your don't get them when your stuff isn't overclocked, it's a safe assumption that your overclock is making it unstable, regardless of what you think running Prime 95 for multiple days tells you. This really isn't the big mystery it's being made out to be...

Stock speed = no crashes
Overclocked = crashes

Solution = LOWER THE CLOCK SPEED

You can often get BSOD with stock clocks, it just requires some driver issues, but most of the BSOD's I've had due to driver issues happen on boot right after installing the driver, and not during general use.
So yeah, most likely to be a hardware instability causing a BSOD if it occurs during use and not boot.
 

Elfear

Diamond Member
May 30, 2004
7,163
819
126
Originally posted by: Unkno
here's somewhat of an update.......it seems that my system blue screens whenever i exit out of standby (while overclocked and stock settings)....does this have anything to do with my instability?

Maybe video card drivers than?? Which Catalyst drivers are you using?


I had a really weird issue like this a while back when I was running an MSI Neo4 board. It would Prime and run Memtest all day long but when I tried to do normal apps it would bsod. After tons of troubleshooting I finally tracked it down to the sata locks not working. If the FSB got raised over a certain amount my sata drives would freak out. Not sure if your Asus board has similiar known issues but it might be worth looking into. You could test this by running your chip at 256x8 with a 133 or 166 divider. That should take your cpu and ram out of the equation as long as they will play nice with that particular multi/divider combo.
 

newmachineoverlord

Senior member
Jan 22, 2006
484
0
0
Originally posted by: Unkno
here's somewhat of an update.......it seems that my system blue screens whenever i exit out of standby (while overclocked and stock settings)....does this have anything to do with my instability?


Am I understanding this correctly to indicate that every single time you come out of standby mode you get a BSOD, regardless of whether or not you are overclocking? If so, you need to resolve that issue first. Until you are truly stable at stock speed you cannot be stable overclocked. My first thought would be to disable advanced power management and tell it not to go into standby mode, but that's more sidestepping the problem than fixing it. You may need another thread.

Generally it's best to avoid overclocking RAM as much as possible. The whole point of buying fast ram is to allow higher fsb speeds with locked multipliers. Keep your ram either underclocked or at stock speed while testing higher cpu speeds, that way you eliminate that variable.

What are your cpu temps while overclocked and at stock speed? Is there variation in room temperature? Is there anything else on that circuit that draws a load? Coming out of standby would cause a spike in power demand on the psu. Perhaps try unplugging all of the drives other than C: to reduce power demand. If it doesn't crash then you know the problem is either the PSU (most likely) or the other drives or the mains power could be insufficient during peak demand hours. You haven't gotten any brownouts or dimming lights, have you? You could have temperature/power fluctuations due to the summer heat.

Standby issues aside, the standard procedure is to lower memory speeds to stock and decrease the cpu overclock by the smallest increments possible until you find one that is truly stable. Once you reach that point, you can probably go back up one or two increments by increasing the voltage slightly, but it may not be worth the trouble.
 

Unkno

Golden Member
Jun 16, 2005
1,659
0
0
it gets a BSOD when exiting standby regardless of being overclocked or stock settings.

well, currently the temps are okay (idle temps--cpu:39C, gpu:44C, ambient:28C)

i'm running a ups with AVR, so brownouts or any other thing shouldn't matter

I only have one drive and one optical drive....psu should handle the load


I'm not really sure if this standby BSOD has anything to do with the BSOD that I get when overclocked....may be completely different

Someone mentioned that it may be my video card. Under device manager, there's an unknown device (not sure why it didn't get installed properly) with a location that states "on RADEON X800 Series"....I have already tried doing a full uninstall (remove old drivers then using drivercleaner) and then doing a full install but it still hasn't really fixed the unknown device problem. I've tried clicking on "Reinstall Driver..." or "Update Driver..."; it points to the location of "C:\ATI\SUPPORT\6-6_XP-2K_DD_33678\2KXP_INF" but then it doesn't find the driver. Could this be why i get BSOD when exiting standby?
 

Unkno

Golden Member
Jun 16, 2005
1,659
0
0
btw, i also have a front panaflo fan to help keep the temps down in the sonataII
 

Unkno

Golden Member
Jun 16, 2005
1,659
0
0
New update: the blue screen when exiting standby may be caused by the amd dual optimizer, and i'm pretty sure it's not the same one from the overclock


So....for the past week or two...i've still been testing the system...it seems that the system is STILL unstable (bsod) at 255FSB x 10 Multiplier with a ~213 mem frequency (vDimm at 2.6)

What i'm testing now is back at the original 256FSB and this time i'm testing the command rate (since asus is known to have some problems with this; the default is also set to 2T). The ram frequency is at 213 at 2.6V....
 

Sh0ckwave

Junior Member
Sep 14, 2005
10
0
0
Why not try putting your vcore up to about 1.5 and vdimm to 2.7 or 2.8

I suspect that wont fix it though, because technically it would need more volts in full load than idle...
 

tcG

Golden Member
Jul 31, 2006
1,202
18
81
Originally posted by: Sh0ckwave
because technically it would need more volts in full load than idle...

Not quite sure where you got that.

 

Sh0ckwave

Junior Member
Sep 14, 2005
10
0
0
Originally posted by: tcG
Originally posted by: Sh0ckwave
because technically it would need more volts in full load than idle...

Not quite sure where you got that.
Obviousely CPUs need more power when they are working :confused:

Anyway the point was he gets BSODs when at idle so more volts might not help.
 

Kwint Sommer

Senior member
Jul 28, 2006
612
0
0
Originally posted by: Sh0ckwave
Originally posted by: tcG
Originally posted by: Sh0ckwave
because technically it would need more volts in full load than idle...

Not quite sure where you got that.
Obviousely CPUs need more power when they are working :confused:

Anyway the point was he gets BSODs when at idle so more volts might not help.


I think TcG was trying to point out that under full load it needs more current but runs at the same voltage regardless.


Speaking of V=I*R, for the materials in a CPU the resistance increases as the temperature decreases so why will you get the best overclocks when at crazily low temps. like -120C ? I can see giong to something like -40C helping because removing the heat allows for vastly increased voltages but beyond a certain point I would think that the resistance of the pathways would simply get too high.
 

myocardia

Diamond Member
Jun 21, 2003
9,291
30
91
Originally posted by: Unkno
...shouldn't testing with prime95 for like 30hours be enough for a stable system at idle that isn't even on 24/7?

One of the biggest problem that conflicts any possible explaination is why my system doesn't blue screen while being stress tested with prime95/memtest86 but it blue screens sometimes during idle...

Can my ram be the problem even if it is memtest86 stable? The stock latencies were 2-3-2-5 , so i set it to 2.5-3-2-5

Thanks for all the replies!
I bet I know what your problem is-- it's the same thing it took me awhile to figure out about my MSI K8N Neo Plat-- when I put the cpu under load, the voltage stays very, very close to where I want it. But, when it's idling, the vcore fluctuates enough to cause BSOD's, since the memory controller is located on the cpu die. I've actually seen the voltage go down .05v, when going from load to idle.

That means you'll need to raise your vcore .025-.05v, if you don't want to drop your overclock. Of course, you should try giving your RAM a bit more voltage, or at least going to 2½-3-3-5 or -6 timings, just as a test. I have the same RAM, and I have to give it 2.70v, to keep from BSODing at stock speeds. Of course, that's all I give it when I'm not at stock speeds, I just raise the timings a bit.
 

Unkno

Golden Member
Jun 16, 2005
1,659
0
0
yea....the vCore on my board does flucatuate a lot.....(set at 1.4V but it can go from 1.33-1.44).........just out of curiousity, are the fluctuations caused by the motherboard or the psu (i'm guessing the mobo). Even if it does fluctuate a lot...then shouldn't it BSOD almost instantly when the vcore drops during prime95/gaming?
 

Sh0ckwave

Junior Member
Sep 14, 2005
10
0
0
Originally posted by: Unkno
yea....the vCore on my board does flucatuate a lot.....(set at 1.4V but it can go from 1.33-1.44).........just out of curiousity, are the fluctuations caused by the motherboard or the psu (i'm guessing the mobo). Even if it does fluctuate a lot...then shouldn't it BSOD almost instantly when the vcore drops during prime95/gaming?
Yeah, the vcore fluctuations are mostly caused by the motherboard not the PSU.

Some voltmods should fix it... :D
 

Unkno

Golden Member
Jun 16, 2005
1,659
0
0
yea....i should mention that the vCore usually only fluctuates between 1.376-1.408 (using cpuz)....it rarely goes to 1.33 (only seen it when i leave the comp on for a few hours and check the minimum vCore under speedfan; so i'm not entirely sure if its accurate because it's speedfan)
 

aka1nas

Diamond Member
Aug 30, 2001
4,335
1
0
I had that same board and case/PSU. I also had random BSODs every few days or so, even if runnign stock. After replacing just about everything else, it turned out to tbe the board. replaced it with a DFI model and it has been crash free since.

Make sure that the chipset fan on the board is working correctly as some A8N series boards have issues with it failing. The heatsink on the VRMs is not glued on very well and may be loose.

It may also be an issue with newer Antec PSUs and the A8n series, though that may only be the NeoPower that have the issue.