Originally posted by: AreaCode707
Originally posted by: TridenTBoy3555
Home schooling sucks for Atheist/Agnostic children who realize that all churches are BS. I never wanted to be home schooled; I heard what they did... In my experience, most home schooled people I've met never end up being smart as you are. There are exceptions but the majority are not. Most of these "smart" home schooled kids come from families who are probably well-off financially and have had a good college education.
You may be one of the very few exceptions, but generally I don't think home schooled kids are better off.
I've seen the bad along with the good; the family with 9 kids whose mom was too lazy to get them ready for school so she "homeschooled" them to avoid doing any work. The oldest daughter ran away at 17. However, I know far more kids in public schools that were dealing with abuse/neglect than homeschoolers, all without teachers knowing or intervening, than I ever saw in homeschool.
Beyond that, I saw a TON of public school kids not putting effort into their work, skirting by on C's and D's, while I rarely saw any homeschoolers performing poorly academically - and not just because their parents gave them A's for everything. One of the advantages of homeschooling is that the day is as short - or as long - as you make it. You do your work and get it all right the first time, you just spent three hours in school and you have the rest of the day free. Don't do it or do it poorly and you redo it til you're done - 10 hours, too darn bad. The incentive of free time, even if it's structured free time, really does push you to take accountability for your work.
I do think atheist/agnostic kids in homeschooling probably have to put up with more religious stuff than they would in public school, but it's approximately the same as what they'd get in private school. Private schooled atheist/agnostic kids deal with it and get the education their parents are paying for. Heck, religious kids in public school often get ridiculed for their beliefs and they put up with it and get the education that's offered.
As far as your view that homeschooled kids don't come off as smart as public/private schooled kids, statistics don't agree. In 2006, the nationwide grand mean in reading for homeschoolers was at the 79th percentile. For language and math, homeschoolers were at the 73rd percentile. Look for statistics on homeschool academic success and you'll find plenty. Look for homeschool academic failure and you'll find little.
A quick Google search on homeschool college admissions will show that admissions officers generally have nothing but good to say about homeschoolers, and more colleges are coming up with ways to take homeschooling educational experience into account during the admissions process (since homeschoolers don't have the same type of AP classes/GPA that you can easily measure against high school students).
Good link - I think this is an impartial source, after a quick glance around the site. I apologize if not; I was trying to avoid posting statistics from sources that were obviously biased, like the HSLDA.
Please correct me if this is a biased source