ahhh damn you guys, my computer is already really fast, what am I doing !
I'll see how the newer games feel with the GTX 460, and if I really feel like upgrading I should probably go for SSD first.
the cheapest i could find was 199.99 for i5 2500 and 92.26 for Asus P8H67-M LX
(only a $10 difference between 2400 and 2500)
Microcenter in store only pricing.