As mentioned, you could get a prepaid card to sign up an ebay account and get something like this:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/Gigabyte-GA...115?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item3cc9ac8ba3
Not bad for a new board. And you are buying from a seller with very good rating. There is a reason this Gigabyte boards are holding their value to well.
Reluctantly, I must agree. For obvious reasons, P67 is the worst of three chipset choices for that CPU. Maybe that explains the BIOS problem; maybe it doesn't.
IIRC, even early Z68 boards came with a question-mark about Ivy-Bridge compatibility. For whatever reason -- we could imagine some, too -- initial board releases were followed by a "Gen3" release. For instance, my P8Z68-V Pro board was followed by a P8Z68-V Pro/Gen3.
Long ago in my ancient PC history, in the days of Prince Conroe, Earl of Kentsfield, Lord Wolfdale and the Duke of Yorkfield, NVidia was still a chipset maker. But the 680i chipsets wouldn't grant entrance to Duke Yorkfield: only Wolfdale was allowed in the castle. Worse, though, there was an "optimal" BIOS version released about the time Kentsfield was stepping up from B3 to G0. The G0 BIOS didn't play well with Lord Kentsfield. On the upside, King Intel and the wicked Queen NVidia allowed you to stick the Duke into a 780i motherboard.
At least these hassles are less problematic, now that NVidia is out of the chipset business and the NVidia-Intel dispute is -- well -- just ancient history.
But considering that P67 was sort a of a "preemie:" -- arriving too soon for the full Sandy Bridge features (Graphics 3000) -- The $100+ investment in a Z68 board will not be much lost of you can either keep the computer for a couple years, or find someone else who wants to do just that -- for a couple Franklins -- more, or less.