Gun for self defense while traveling and small hands.

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

TallBill

Lifer
Apr 29, 2001
46,017
62
91
Originally posted by: xSauronx

i think some states honor permits from others, but its not shared between all states (and some states dont honor others at all, i havent looked into all of it in a year or so)

thing is, for general concealed carry some places are really strict on where you can carry. in NC theres really not anywhere outside of personal property or the highway where it isnt a no-no to have a concealed weapon. many places have signs, and the rest are public places where you cant legally carry anyway.

Having a sign doesn't make it illegal. If walmart has a sign "no concealed carry" all they can do is kick you out. But then you didn't do a great job of concealing.
 

MikeMike

Lifer
Feb 6, 2000
45,885
66
91
some of u here have to realize that fbb's closest encounter to a gun was probably at his friends house looking at them in the gun case.... he most likely has no idea wtf to o with one...
 

middlehead

Diamond Member
Jul 11, 2004
4,573
2
81
Originally posted by: JulesMaximus
Originally posted by: Schadenfroh
What kind of dangerous animals might you be running into while camping? If it is a full-grown bear, then you will need some heavier fire power (unless you are an excellent shot even when beset upon unexpectedly) than something you will need to bring down a mad dog, otherwise you will just make it mad, like Mongo.
My Glock 9mm will take down a Grizzly yo.
But only if you hold it sideways.
 

theblackbox

Golden Member
Oct 1, 2004
1,650
11
81
glock is by far the best small pistol for self defense. the big advantage is the fact that it is one of the few pistols that can be drawn and fired without the worry of a safety or having to cock the pistol like a revolver. glock has also improved the safety of the holstered pistol, making it safe all the way around.
any of the subcompacts, the g26(9mm), g27(40),g30(45),g31(357), g32(357 magnum) are all great pistols. i would recommend the g26 over the others for control and capacity. using a standard mag with the handle extender, you get a very capable pistol for self defense at close range, and reliability. while the bigger caliber pistols have more stopping power, they offer less control for an inexperienced shooter.
The 26 is also a very easy pistol to conceal. even with the standard mag you get 10+1 shots. It is more then enough of a detterent for wildlife, and very capable as a deterrent for the human kind too.

as far as carrying a concealed weapon, be sure to know the laws. in some states if private property puts up signs, if you are caught carrying a concealed weapon, you can face charges. they may only be misdemeanor, but they are still charges. Plus, some states will put you on a person of interest list that the police can access and treat you as a threat if pulled over. Thanks colorado.
 

jlee

Lifer
Sep 12, 2001
48,518
223
106
Originally posted by: theblackbox
glock is by far the best small pistol for self defense. the big advantage is the fact that it is one of the few pistols that can be drawn and fired without the worry of a safety or having to cock the pistol like a revolver. glock has also improved the safety of the holstered pistol, making it safe all the way around.
any of the subcompacts, the g26(9mm), g27(40),g30(45),g31(357), g32(357 magnum) are all great pistols. i would recommend the g26 over the others for control and capacity. using a standard mag with the handle extender, you get a very capable pistol for self defense at close range, and reliability. while the bigger caliber pistols have more stopping power, they offer less control for an inexperienced shooter.
The 26 is also a very easy pistol to conceal. even with the standard mag you get 10+1 shots. It is more then enough of a detterent for wildlife, and very capable as a deterrent for the human kind too.

as far as carrying a concealed weapon, be sure to know the laws. in some states if private property puts up signs, if you are caught carrying a concealed weapon, you can face charges. they may only be misdemeanor, but they are still charges. Plus, some states will put you on a person of interest list that the police can access and treat you as a threat if pulled over. Thanks colorado.

Don't forget the Glock 36- single-stack .45. It doesn't look a lot smaller than the 30, but it feels it.
 

jacob0401

Platinum Member
Jul 31, 2001
2,185
0
76
Originally posted by: xSauronx
Originally posted by: BeauJangles
Originally posted by: Schadenfroh
What kind of dangerous animals might you be running into while camping? If it is a full-grown bear, then you will need some heavier fire power (unless you are an excellent shot even when beset upon unexpectedly) than something you will need to bring down a mad dog, otherwise you will just make it mad, like Mongo.

It depends on where you are, but bears, cougars, wolverines, etc. They're all pretty dangerous if you run into them and a gun goes a long way to either scaring them off (in the case of a bear) or shooting them on sight (in the case of a wolverine, which is probably the scariest little mother fucker on earth).

As for the OP, your issue is going to be applicable law in the state you're traveling in. I know that without a permit you can buy any weapon made before 1899 or any replica. You can own them and keep them in your house without issue. You can also transport them to and from a range to shoot.

Once you start driving around with it, though, you're going to need a carrying permit. Those are harder to obtain and the laws vary state-to-state. It can also take months to go through all the red tape. That means you'd have to plan out your trips in advance, apply for a permit in each state, and hopefully be approved before you even set foot out the door.

i think some states honor permits from others, but its not shared between all states (and some states dont honor others at all, i havent looked into all of it in a year or so)

thing is, for general concealed carry some places are really strict on where you can carry. in NC theres really not anywhere outside of personal property or the highway where it isnt a no-no to have a concealed weapon. many places have signs, and the rest are public places where you cant legally carry anyway.

The best way may be here. Apply for CCW in a state that has reciprocity with a lot of other states. Utah is a good one. Otherwise look into open carry laws and other associated laws detailing the manner of carry for each state here: http://www.nraila.org/GunLaws/.



 

theblackbox

Golden Member
Oct 1, 2004
1,650
11
81
oh, sorry, i forgot to add. if you plan on camping in national parks in a tent you might want to rethink carrying a pistol. federal laws regarding firearms in national parks aren't as forgiving as county and state laws.
over the last two years, i have spent 13 months hiking and camping all over the US and not once needed my pistol. On the AT i did not carry it, of course, but we did have it in our RV this year.
i live in the mountains and we have frequent visits at our house by mountain lions and bears, and as long as you don't rub food all over yourself or impede on them, they'll leave you alone.
unless you walk into a grizzly protecting a fresh kill, you are pretty safe when hiking and camping as long as you follow basic hiking rules regarding safety and food control.
The whole time on the AT, never had a worry. If you do the PCT, might be different, encroachment by people has forced the kittys there to react different to people.

Word of advice, if you are attacked by a cougar, hope whoever you are with has a pistol. You most likely won't see the attack coming, and once involved, the pistol will probably be the last thing on your mind.



Here is a pic from our first snow this year, and our first visitor tracks:

cat tracks in driveway

Plus, let me add this about gun safety and use. While anyone can carry a gun, it takes a lot to actually understand the impact of pulling the trigger, and the repercussions of actually using the weapon to kill something in a moment of heightened stress. it is not easy, and is something that can stick with you for a long time. Do as much range time as you can and learn from someone experienced, glad to hear you have a police friend. You should never have to rely on a weapon when encountering wildlife, a lot of people run into bears and other animals every day and walk away without conflict. if you go into it with a gun thinking it will protect you, most likely you will adversly impact the enviroment and you also could face charges if you kill a bear or mountain lion even if you were under threat.
Here in colorado a lot is weighed into home break ins of wild animals, and if you kill a bear that comes into your house, the local law enforcement and the dow look at it and consider if it was justified, and have the ability to press charges if they don't feel it was justified. I don't remember any recent times when someone was charged, but it can happen.

 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,418
19,827
146
Originally posted by: fuzzybabybunny
Originally posted by: Amused
Have you tried the Walther PPK/S?

ah, yes. the ppk/s is also one of the guns that fits me very well :)

You cannot do much better than a PPK/S for a compact sidearm. One of the most accurate and reliable small handguns I've ever owned.

I strongly suggest it.
 

Fritzo

Lifer
Jan 3, 2001
41,920
2,161
126
Where are you travelling to that is so dangerous you feel you need to carry a weapon?
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,418
19,827
146
Originally posted by: Fritzo
Where are you travelling to that is so dangerous you feel you need to carry a weapon?

What are you saying that is so important you feel the need to have freedom of speech?
 

theblackbox

Golden Member
Oct 1, 2004
1,650
11
81
about the ppk/s , with your choice of 32 or 380, be sure to carry two extra magazines and if approached by a wild animal fire as many shots in the air as possible, reloading as needed and scream and wave your arms. the noise should do it because it's doubtful the bullets would.

on the positive, you can pretend your bond, james bond.

 

xeno2060

Golden Member
Nov 8, 2001
1,518
4
81
Originally posted by: fuzzybabybunny
So I might look into getting a gun for self defense (as opposed to offense and storming castles and stuff) while traveling and road tripping and camping. I need something very lightweight and small.

I've got pretty small hands. The Walther P22 and Colt 1911 fit me very well. The Walther P99 and H&K USP do NOT.

PS: Last night I had a dream about a revolver. I dunno why. I know revolvers are simple, reliable, and uncomplicated, but I always get bogged down by thoughts of reload speed. But then of course how often am I going to have to reload? Couldn't I just carry an extra speedloader on me?

S&W Night Guard 38

Sig Sauer P232

 

SoulAssassin

Diamond Member
Feb 1, 2001
6,135
2
0
Originally posted by: randay
get a taser.

this...only because OP isn't mature enough and will shoot himself in the foot.


If you don't have anything useful to say and just want to call the OP names, how about you refrain from posting.


esquared
Anandtech Senior Moderator


Reworded. Seriously don't think he is mature enough for a firearm, that isn't namecalling...this is an attempt to keep him out of the ER.
 
May 16, 2000
13,522
0
0
Check out the Taurus Millennium Pro PT140 (or PT145 if you prefer .45s). I can't stand larger or blockish weapons, so I finally found this gem. Best concealable handgun I've ever used, hands down.
 

K1052

Elite Member
Aug 21, 2003
53,024
47,109
136
If it's people you're worried about most of the small autos (PPK, Makarov, P232, Kel-Tec) are fine.

If you're worried about people AND animals I 2nd this:

Originally posted by: adairusmc
I would get a Smith & Wesson J Frame. Easy to conceal, packs a good enough punch with .38 special +P (or .357 mag if you get that version), and very light.

 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,418
19,827
146
Originally posted by: theblackbox
p232 is 380. the op wants something for self defense, not a toy.

Come on over to my house and let me double tap you with a couple .380s and we'll see how well you can attack me.

It's silly how people crap all over .380s They are an excellent compromise for small/skinny people looking for an effective CW.
 

theblackbox

Golden Member
Oct 1, 2004
1,650
11
81
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: theblackbox
p232 is 380. the op wants something for self defense, not a toy.

Come on over to my house and let me double tap you with a couple .380s and we'll see how well you can attack me.

It's silly how people crap all over .380s They are an excellent compromise for small/skinny people looking for an effective CW.

there is an inherent problem with the 380. it just lacks power. sure, it works against a person. even a .22 will work against a person. when it comes to animals, it lacks. it just doesn't get the job done in ALL situations.

here is a nice comparison between 380 and 9mm with tables and all.
shooting times article

you said it right, 380 is a compromise. i am not crapping on it, i am just stating 380 for what it is, and if your life depends on it, there should not be compromise.

However, if you feel secure that 380 is more then enough to stop any threat you may encounter, have at it.
115 grains max, heck, i run through boxes of 115 all the time as a minimum at the range. 124 for home defense.

My experience begs to differ.

 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,418
19,827
146
Originally posted by: theblackbox
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: theblackbox
p232 is 380. the op wants something for self defense, not a toy.

Come on over to my house and let me double tap you with a couple .380s and we'll see how well you can attack me.

It's silly how people crap all over .380s They are an excellent compromise for small/skinny people looking for an effective CW.

there is an inherent problem with the 380. it just lacks power. sure, it works against a person. even a .22 will work against a person. when it comes to animals, it lacks. it just doesn't get the job done in ALL situations.

here is a nice comparison between 380 and 9mm with tables and all.
shooting times article

you said it right, 380 is a compromise. i am not crapping on it, i am just stating 380 for what it is, and if your life depends on it, there should not be compromise.

However, if you feel secure that 380 is more then enough to stop any threat you may encounter, have at it.
115 grains max, heck, i run through boxes of 115 all the time as a minimum at the range. 124 for home defense.

My experience begs to differ.

My point is he's a little guy with small hands looking for a weapon he can CW.

Yes, the .380 is a compromise, but in his situation, probably the best option.

If he wants a carry weapon for the woods, a full size .45 or better would be ideal. But he wants something for both.
 

IGBT

Lifer
Jul 16, 2001
17,976
141
106
..I've used a AMT BackUp in .380 and a HighStandard Derringer in .22 mag. The AMT BackUp is now available in .45 acp.