Originally posted by: MoFunk
Originally posted by: PrinceofWands
Originally posted by: MoFunk
Originally posted by: PrinceofWands
Originally posted by: MoFunk
I have been thinking about this for a bit and have a question. How many of you who find nothing at all wrong with the F word being publically displayed suport taking the word God out of the pledge because it may be offensive to someone?
Good point...but be sure to differentiate between 'offensive to someone' and 'violation of the constitution with the possibility of further government decay' when you talk about reasons.
I don't believe in the current pledge, but not because it's offensive (although it is that too).
Last I checked it was freedom OF religion not freedom FROM religion.
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion
You may be able to argue that the pledge isn't a law, but it's ABSOLUTELY AND TOTALLY opposed to the original intent of the founders. If they'd wanted god in government they could easily have put him there...but you'll not find one reference, not in the constituion, not in our original money, nor in our original pledge. You'll find written records of them arguing against the government in any way involving itself in religious affairs, including inclusion of religious idolotry or writing in it's official documents. It was considered, and refused.
They expected religious men to hold office, but they did NOT want religion within the federal structure of the government itself. I have yet to ever see this effectively argued by any credible source.
This is an arguement unto itself, but man our government is FILLED with Christianity. Have you seen Washington DC? Most buildings have Christian symbolism. Have you ever been a witness in court, tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth so help me GOD, with your hand on a bible. Most of our founding fathers were Christian and spoke of God and christianity often.
But this is way off topic. This is about the morality of this country wasting away to nothing. Look I talk to my kids nightly about everything. I teach them right from wrong. I teach them morals and values. But it is a total lack of respect and lack of decency that people show stuff like this.
This is all of coarse my own opinion, I just seem to expect more out of mankind then is actually there!
You actually don't have to say, 'so help me god', nor are you required to place your hand on a bible. I'm talking about federal btw, states often came up with very theocratic constitutions (such as you orginally had to be a CHRISTIAN (not just religious) to vote, or be a juror, or hold elected office etc). But those things were all at the state level, not federal, and have long since been done away with (except for the requirement to be religious to hold office). Anyway, you cannot be required to participate in any religious observance. Instead of the whole bible thing or so help me god thing you are always allowed to say 'I so affirm'. That's how I took the oath of enlistment to the military, and how I've testified.
That ALL came about in two waves, the first during and after the civil war in an effort for re-unification and the second was during mccartheism and the work to oppose 'godless communism'. In both cases the changes were railroaded by religious organizations (like the koc) in league with certain prominent politicians and businessmen (pretty much the old give and take, we'll get our congregation to back you in the next election if you convince the businesses to give money to support these changes). If you read all the original writings it wasn't that way at all. If you're talking raw percentages, yes, most of the founders were of some christian denomination. However you should clarify that a bit, because in the last 60 years fundamentalists have tried to imply that most means 90% or something and christian means purely catholic or mainstream protestant, and that's patently untrue. A large number of our founders were deists, and many were from non-mainstream religious branches (like quakers).
What I've found in my quest for spiritual fulfillment and plain truth is that both sides (liberal and conservative, christian and atheist) have stooped to some pretty dirty politicking to get their way imposed on others. Neither are fully true, neither are fully false. Sadly, I think it's grown MUCH worse in the last 4 years and I believe it's going to get far far worse yet...possibly bad enough to bring real damage to the country. Like I said before, I want everyone to be able to practice their religion freely, but I'll execute every man and woman in the country or die trying before I'll live under a theocracy or see the intent of the founders flushed away out of prideful religious zealotry.