Got a S6 Edge Plus 64gb for $1 from Best Buy

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

thesmokingman

Platinum Member
May 6, 2010
2,302
231
106
The point was, you are whining that its X amount more a month when the OP's post was that the phone only cost on dollar. Up front, its a buck. It's no big surprise you pay a monthly charge for the phone, especially when it shows that on the same page.

As for the $27.00 monthly charge, people spend that in a day or two on food. People spend 4x that on cable TV a month. If its the monthly charge you are worried about, cut it out somewhere else if it bothers you or don't buy the phone.


Christ, I'm not talking about or have I made a debate about what you spend or anyone else at starbucks or a meal in a day.

Who the hell is whining? Stop creating arguments by yourself.

The phone is not a 1 dollar as the cost is rolled into the plan. It can be broken down as with the device payment per month. This is something the OP did not understand. That is the POINT.

And on point, if the OP were more savvy he could have bought a better phone if he took the real device cost into consideration.
 

slag

Lifer
Dec 14, 2000
10,473
81
101
Christ, I'm not talking about or have I made a debate about what you spend or anyone else at starbucks or a meal in a day.

Who the hell is whining? Stop creating arguments by yourself.

The phone is not a 1 dollar as the cost is rolled into the plan. It can be broken down as with the device payment per month. This is something the OP did not understand. That is the POINT.

And on point, if the OP were more savvy he could have bought a better phone if he took the real device cost into consideration.

To be fair, you wrote "Holy Carp" with the quote of a price under the phone. I guess we were just supposed to know your ambiguous post was not about the price but the fact that you had to pay more which was already freaking obvious from the $1.00 phone offer. It's not like Verizon or BB tried to hide that fact by providing clear wording under the phone with a link to their policy or anything...

:rolleyes::rolleyes:
 

stlc8tr

Golden Member
Jan 5, 2011
1,106
4
76
To be fair, you wrote "Holy Carp" with the quote of a price under the phone. I guess we were just supposed to know your ambiguous post was not about the price but the fact that you had to pay more which was already freaking obvious from the $1.00 phone offer. It's not like Verizon or BB tried to hide that fact by providing clear wording under the phone with a link to their policy or anything...

:rolleyes::rolleyes:

I don't think it's obvious to some people. Look at the OP. He put "$1" in the thread title. Why do that if he didn't think he got some type of great deal?
 

Insomniator

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2002
6,294
171
106
Forgetting that he can go to some crappy carrier with worse coverage and slower speeds, if he STICKS WITH VERIZON is his plan more expensive if he is on a 2 year contact?

If you just buy it month to month, its $27 a month until the phone is paid. If you lock into a two year contract he pays $1 for the phone, does his base plan price go up though?

My point is, I don't plan on leaving Verizon anytime soon so a contract is meaningless to me. Is there any reason to still use a device payment plan then?
 

thesmokingman

Platinum Member
May 6, 2010
2,302
231
106
Forgetting that he can go to some crappy carrier with worse coverage and slower speeds, if he STICKS WITH VERIZON is his plan more expensive if he is on a 2 year contact?

If you just buy it month to month, its $27 a month until the phone is paid. If you lock into a two year contract he pays $1 for the phone, does his base plan price go up though?

My point is, I don't plan on leaving Verizon anytime soon so a contract is meaningless to me. Is there any reason to still use a device payment plan then?


What's the point to a device payment plan? If you can't afford to buy the phone outright or provide your own phone some other way or you pay payments on a new phone. These $1 out the door deals are structured that way so that ppl adverse to large phone costs, can walk away none the wiser. There is a real cost as always. 24 monthly payments of $27 totals $648. For that price, he could have bought many new phones, a G5, S7, on and on.

If you are already with carrier on an existing plan, and you want a new phone, you again buy it outright or buy the phone of choice via device payment plan which would be added to your current plan. In other words you'd make payments on the new phone.
 

Insomniator

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2002
6,294
171
106
What's the point to a device payment plan? If you can't afford to buy the phone outright or provide your own phone some other way or you pay payments on a new phone. These $1 out the door deals are structured that way so that ppl adverse to large phone costs, can walk away none the wiser. There is a real cost as always. 24 monthly payments of $27 totals $648. For that price, he could have bought many new phones, a G5, S7, on and on.

If you are already with carrier on an existing plan, and you want a new phone, you again buy it outright or buy the phone of choice via device payment plan which would be added to your current plan. In other words you'd make payments on the new phone.

...What? Why would I buy a phone outright or pay $27 a month for 2 years when I can get it for $1 if I just agree to stick to Verizon for 2 years?

Its either device payment plan OR 2 year contract price. You don't get a contract, pay the 1$ to best buy and then $27 a month for the phone. Unless I am mistaken, which is what I am asking about.
 

Insomniator

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2002
6,294
171
106
From the Best Buy link - 3 ways to pay for this phone.

Verizon Device Payment Learn more
$27.00/mo. (like financing the phone, people not paying attention to their bill being higher for 2 years)

2-year contract
$1.00 (locked into Verizon with an ETF fee, but who cares if you have already been with X carrier for 10 years? Just like old times with contract upgrades)

Unactivated device
$769.99 (full price up front, just buying the phone from anywhere)
 

thesmokingman

Platinum Member
May 6, 2010
2,302
231
106
...What? Why would I buy a phone outright or pay $27 a month for 2 years when I can get it for $1 if I just agree to stick to Verizon for 2 years?

Its either device payment plan OR 2 year contract price. You don't get a contract, pay the 1$ to best buy and then $27 a month for the phone. Unless I am mistaken, which is what I am asking about.


o_O

The device payment is the break down of what the phone cost is per month for the 2yr contract.
 

Insomniator

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2002
6,294
171
106

Insomniator

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2002
6,294
171
106
Its the same deal when I log into Verizon and upgrade from there. I can do a payment plan which is full retail price / 24 months, a contract which is say $199 for an S7 (retail price has a strike through it) or retail price all at once.

It looks like Verizon never did away with the old contract system that everyone seemed to hate for some reason. So if you don't mind being 'locked in' to verizon, there is zero reason to go with month to month payment plans or retail price.
 

Insomniator

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2002
6,294
171
106
OP, did your plan price increase $27 a month? Or are you on a 2 year contract now with the same plan price?
 

MarkizSchnitzel

Senior member
Nov 10, 2013
473
119
116
I'm not from USA, but from what I gather, his price plan did not increase, because they were charging this phone subsidy whether you take the phone or not.

But you can get a cheaper plan if you de couple.

This is also how carriers did it here where I am.
 

postmortemIA

Diamond Member
Jul 11, 2006
7,721
40
91
OP, did your plan price increase $27 a month? Or are you on a 2 year contract now with the same plan price?

2yrs contracts cost $25 to $30 more than non-contract plans... it is like $39.99 for voice and $30 for data

while the "modern" share plans are likely less costly per device, as long as you have more than one user/device
 
Last edited:

futurefields

Diamond Member
Jun 2, 2012
6,470
32
91
No shit, but that's not the point is it? It's not 1 dollar. And at full device cost, one could have bought a few better phones.

I paid $1 for the phone, with no additional monthly payments. The way I see it I am paying far less than full device cost?
 

futurefields

Diamond Member
Jun 2, 2012
6,470
32
91
2yrs contracts cost $25 to $30 more than non-contract plans... it is like $39.99 for voice and $30 for data

while the "modern" share plans are likely less costly per device, as long as you have more than one user/device

I am on Verizon's "loyalty" plan there is no line fee, for a flat rate of $70 I get unlimited talk, text and 3gb of data. If I can keep my data under 2gb (which I do most months) it's $60 instead of $70.
 

thesmokingman

Platinum Member
May 6, 2010
2,302
231
106
I paid $1 for the phone, with no additional monthly payments. The way I see it I am paying far less than full device cost?


For the last time, you're paying 70 a month for the contract which includes the price of the phone! That's what teh device payment means. Subtract 27 out of 70, that leaves you with the service cost.

If you thought your service costs 70 a month, that is sheer nuttiness.
 

postmortemIA

Diamond Member
Jul 11, 2006
7,721
40
91
For the last time, you're paying 70 a month for the contract which includes the price of the phone! That's what teh device payment means. Subtract 27 out of 70, that leaves you with the service cost.

If you thought your service costs 70 a month, that is sheer nuttiness.

ditto... and that plan sucks if you don't get new device exactly every two years... and it also forces you to buy $600 device
Guess how much is same plan, but without contract? about $45.
http://www.verizonwireless.com/prepaid/smartphone-plans/
 

cronos

Diamond Member
Nov 7, 2001
9,380
26
101
ditto... and that plan sucks if you don't get new device exactly every two years... and it also forces you to buy $600 device
Guess how much is same plan, but without contract? about $45.
http://www.verizonwireless.com/prepaid/smartphone-plans/

That prepaid plan isn't even comparable because of the no-roaming, different priority, etc. The correct comparable plan is the current postpaid version (which is the exact plan that he's on), and it's $45 for unlimited talkt/txt/3 GB + $20 line fee = $65/month.

Yes, he really is only paying $5/month more than most other people who just randomly comes in and want the same deal.

I get it, guys. I've been a number one opponent of the practice of buying phones with a contract since before most people in the US know that you can get a cellphone line without a contract. I have been, and still am, strongly against it. But the OP is on a loyalty plan that very small number of people are still on and could not be had by anyone currently looking to get it. It is possible for select few people to actually be ahead by choosing to be in-contract by combining their legacy plan with a store offer like this one.
 

thesmokingman

Platinum Member
May 6, 2010
2,302
231
106
I pay $137 after taxes/fees out the door for 4 lines, 6gb unlimited text/talk with rollover and free netflix and whatever tmo gives free streaming for. Phones are all owned.
 

futurefields

Diamond Member
Jun 2, 2012
6,470
32
91
For the last time, you're paying 70 a month for the contract which includes the price of the phone! That's what teh device payment means. Subtract 27 out of 70, that leaves you with the service cost.

If you thought your service costs 70 a month, that is sheer nuttiness.

You are wrong, there is no device payment in the bill. You cannot have a $43 a month bill from Verizon that includes unlimited talk/text and 3gb. The plan I have is the cheapest available and the same you would pay if you brought an unlocked phone in.
 

futurefields

Diamond Member
Jun 2, 2012
6,470
32
91
That prepaid plan isn't even comparable because of the no-roaming, different priority, etc. The correct comparable plan is the current postpaid version (which is the exact plan that he's on), and it's $45 for unlimited talkt/txt/3 GB + $20 line fee = $65/month.

That's actually not how it works. The loyalty plan is a flat rate fee of $60 a month for 2gb of data, and an additional $10 a month for every 1gb after that. So $70 for 3gb is the figure I quote when I talk about it, since 3gb is the standard these days. But I usually am able to keep my data under 2gb and thus pay $60 a month.