"God is Dead"

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

DotheDamnTHing

Platinum Member
Feb 2, 2004
2,795
0
0
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: DotheDamnTHing
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: DotheDamnTHing
But what about his concept of the 'overman' who creates his own morals/virtues etc and thus can live a 'happy' life?
A replacement god for the one he proclaimed dead.
One that those who are able create
Those who were/are able always did/do create. They didn't/don't need Nietzsche.

Debatable since as with many other philosophers, he never left a 100% blueprint of his ideal end state.
 

DotheDamnTHing

Platinum Member
Feb 2, 2004
2,795
0
0
Originally posted by: stinkz


Originally posted by: DotheDamnTHingBut what about his concept of the 'overman' who creates his own morals/virtues etc and thus can live a 'happy' life?

"The human mind has no more power of inventing a new value than of planting a new sun in the sky or a new primary colour in the spectrum..."

It would not be the human mind per se but rather an act of sheer will
 

Sentinel

Diamond Member
Jun 23, 2000
3,714
1
71
Originally posted by: DotheDamnTHing
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: DotheDamnTHing
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: DotheDamnTHing
But what about his concept of the 'overman' who creates his own morals/virtues etc and thus can live a 'happy' life?
A replacement god for the one he proclaimed dead.
One that those who are able create
Those who were/are able always did/do create. They didn't/don't need Nietzsche.

Debatable since as with many other philosophers, he never left a 100% blueprint of his ideal end state.

As to creat controversy, food for discussion? I believe it.
 

DotheDamnTHing

Platinum Member
Feb 2, 2004
2,795
0
0
Originally posted by: Sentinel
Originally posted by: DotheDamnTHing
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: DotheDamnTHing
Originally posted by: Vic
Originally posted by: DotheDamnTHing
But what about his concept of the 'overman' who creates his own morals/virtues etc and thus can live a 'happy' life?
A replacement god for the one he proclaimed dead.
One that those who are able create
Those who were/are able always did/do create. They didn't/don't need Nietzsche.

Debatable since as with many other philosophers, he never left a 100% blueprint of his ideal end state.

As to creat controversy, food for discussion? I believe it.



Believe that individuals have attained overman status?
 
Oct 30, 2004
11,442
32
91
Originally posted by: judasmachine
I tend to think we will out grow our need for a heavenly babysitter, and I believe this is why many religions seem to be lashing out these days. They are concerned because every generation seems to have less and less need for the stories of the day before yesterday. God is dead and we have killed him with our own maturation.


...except for in the United States where a huge segment of the populace is still trying to outlaw 'bortions and teach creationism in the schools.

I wouldn't be surprised if most people still believe in it 1000 years from now. Throughout history religion has been used as the opiate of the masses and as a means of political control In fact, it's quite possible that our future could be a return to the Dark Ages instead of the Space Age, especially if the people warning about "Peak Oil" prove to be correct. From what I can tell, the world is only becoming increasingly populated and impoverished, with much of that third world poverty spreading to the United States in the form of the erosion of the middle class.
 
Oct 30, 2004
11,442
32
91
Originally posted by: Vic

Nietzsche was wrong. And the manner in which he was wrong has led to generations of immature and uneducated interpretations about the nature and understanding of religion and faith, and an overall weakening of philosophy. He, Kant, and Hegel pretty much killed philosophy, which IMO is one reason why people feel so empty inside today.

How do you know that people feel so empty inside today? Are you certain that you can't find large numbers of atheists and secular people who are perfectly happy and who feel fulfilled? Also, is it possible that much of the alleged emptyness might come from external factors such as the difficulty of maintaining a middle class lifestyle in today's United States (65 hour work weeks, no time for family, etc.).

It's also very possible that some of the people just had the wrong philosophy and should discover a better philosophy. For example, I've known people who were raised to be religious and who ended up carrying all sorts of poisonous religious baggage and philosophy with them even after they claimed to have become atheists. So, in a sense, it might very well be the poison of the religion that makes them feel empty inside. I suggest that they consider a different philosophy, one based on the notion that reality is objective in nature, that reason is man's means of knowledge, and that pursuing one's own life is the good. I might put it this way:

"There is a philosophy out there that is completely different from anything else that you've ever heard. If you're interested, read The Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged.


 

kage69

Lifer
Jul 17, 2003
31,318
47,531
136
He, Kant, and Hegel pretty much killed philosophy, which IMO is one reason why people feel so empty inside today.


I disagree. They did not kill philosophy - they killed people's patience in reading it! Kant in particular. Haven't been in that much discomfort since I read the Popol Vuh. Haven't met too many 'empty' types who point to Hegel and such as the cause of their despair. Usually it's something like priests preaching love whilst molesting children, or the precepts of love and forgiveness being twisted to villify and persecute.



 

DotheDamnTHing

Platinum Member
Feb 2, 2004
2,795
0
0
Originally posted by: kage69
He, Kant, and Hegel pretty much killed philosophy, which IMO is one reason why people feel so empty inside today.


I disagree. They did not kill philosophy - they killed people's patience in reading it! Kant in particular. Haven't been in that much discomfort since I read the Popol Vuh. Haven't met too many 'empty' types who point to Hegel and such as the cause of their despair. Usually it's something like priests preaching love whilst molesting children, or the precepts of love and forgiveness being twisted to villify and persecute.

add Marx to that list ;)
 

raildogg

Lifer
Aug 24, 2004
12,892
572
126
Originally posted by: EatSpam
Originally posted by: jlmadyson
Nietzscheism is absurd.

No more absurd than the bible.

Hmm, I doubt you ever read the bible all the way for you to make such a comment. Read the book, take some of that information in and then make a judgement. There are huge gaps in the bible with parts missing, parts altered and other things that are hard to explain. Some of the translations may not be totally accurate as far as we know. But still, it is among the greatest works of literature ever.
 

Harvey

Administrator<br>Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
35,059
73
91
Originally posted by: Sentinel
God is dead. God remains dead. And we have killed him."
-Aphorism 125 GS

(Die fröhliche Wissenschaft)
And not a moment too soon. Man needs a god like a fish needs a pogo stick.
 

kage69

Lifer
Jul 17, 2003
31,318
47,531
136
Hmm, I doubt you ever read the bible all the way for you to make such a comment. Read the book, take some of that information in and then make a judgement. There are huge gaps in the bible with parts missing, parts altered and other things that are hard to explain. Some of the translations may not be totally accurate as far as we know. But still, it is among the greatest works of literature ever.

Going on past experience in this forum, I'll wager he has spent more time reading it than you have. Stop regurgitating what you hear on TV, it makes you sound stupid.



Man needs a god like a fish needs a pogo stick.

Classic :thumbsup: ;)
 

EatSpam

Diamond Member
May 1, 2005
6,423
0
0
Originally posted by: raildogg
Originally posted by: EatSpam
Originally posted by: jlmadyson
Nietzscheism is absurd.

No more absurd than the bible.

Hmm, I doubt you ever read the bible all the way for you to make such a comment. Read the book, take some of that information in and then make a judgement. There are huge gaps in the bible with parts missing, parts altered and other things that are hard to explain. Some of the translations may not be totally accurate as far as we know. But still, it is among the greatest works of literature ever.

I haven't read it all the way through, but I did attempt it once. It was really really boring and after the part about the dick-chopping covenant, I decided it wasn't worth torturing myself. Greek and Norse mythology is far more entertaining - its not so preachy.

I have heard that the best way to become an atheist is to read the bible all the way through. So I guess you haven't read the bible all the way through yourself! ;)
 

raildogg

Lifer
Aug 24, 2004
12,892
572
126
Originally posted by: kage69
Hmm, I doubt you ever read the bible all the way for you to make such a comment. Read the book, take some of that information in and then make a judgement. There are huge gaps in the bible with parts missing, parts altered and other things that are hard to explain. Some of the translations may not be totally accurate as far as we know. But still, it is among the greatest works of literature ever.

Going on past experience in this forum, I'll wager he has spent more time reading it than you have. Stop regurgitating what you hear on TV, it makes you sound stupid.



Man needs a god like a fish needs a pogo stick.

Classic :thumbsup: ;)

It wasn't intended for you. You're assuming this and assuming that, typical of you. Looking at past posts, I really do believe you are fair and balanced in how to judge. I'm wondering myself how would a genius such as yourself can know if I even watch tv at all. Oh wait, such a genius can know of such things without them even happening.

Good for you, though. You win teh interwab.

But yes, you're the typical P&Ner, always bright and always witty. Go you.
 

kage69

Lifer
Jul 17, 2003
31,318
47,531
136
It wasn't intended for you, smart guy (right). You're assuming this and assuming that, typical of you. I'm wondering myself how would a genius such as yourself can know if I even watch tv at all. Oh wait, such a genius can know of such things without them even happening.



Well I'd like to think my sig would remind me... :laugh: ROTFLMAO!
Like I said, I'm going on past experience. :)





Yes, go me! :laugh:
 

raildogg

Lifer
Aug 24, 2004
12,892
572
126
Originally posted by: kage69
It wasn't intended for you, smart guy (right). You're assuming this and assuming that, typical of you. I'm wondering myself how would a genius such as yourself can know if I even watch tv at all. Oh wait, such a genius can know of such things without them even happening.



Well I'd like to think my sig would remind me... :laugh: ROTFLMAO!
Like I said, I'm going on past experience. :)





Yes, go me! :laugh:

I always see your sig with pleasure. Remind me again when I made that remark?

I don't have the Fox News channel anymore, all I get is CNN, I'm sure you're happy about that.
 

kage69

Lifer
Jul 17, 2003
31,318
47,531
136
*catches breath*


Ahahaaaaahahahahahahaaaaaa hhahahahahahahahahahaha!!!! :laugh:


 

engineereeyore

Platinum Member
Jul 23, 2005
2,070
0
0
Originally posted by: Sentinel
This is an interesting thought:

"The madman jumped into their midst and pierced them with his eyes. "Whither is God?" he cried; "I will tell you. We have killed him- you and I. All of us are his murderers. But how did we do this? How could we drink up the sea?

...

God is dead. God remains dead. And we have killed him."
-Aphorism 125 GS

(Die fröhliche Wissenschaft)

Anyone have any input or comments?

Symbolically, yes. In reality, no. In a manner of thinking, God is dead to all those who are not willing to include him in their life. Does that mean he ceases to exist? No. Only to that person is he dead. Ironically, the one who acts dead is the man. Unwilling to hear, listen, or understand. God is always there whenever we're ready to turn to him.