spaceman
Lifer
Originally posted by: jaeger66
Originally posted by: FeathersMcGraw
If by action you mean FPS or TPS (like Max Payne/Tomb Raider/Indiana Jones), I'd give the edge to XBox over GameCube, although you will miss out on the brilliance of Metroid Prime and The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker.
I think XBox and GameCube are roughly equivalent in the adventure space. GameCube tends to have more "platformer" entries in this genre, although it does have Eternal Darkness, which makes up for a lot.
If RPG is one of your big genres, you might actually want to consider a PS2. There are probably more RPG titles alone (although to be fair, a lot of them are actually PSX games that the PS2 picks up through backwards compatibility) than all games on either XBox or GameCube. Not that quantity is the same as quality, because clearly there's a lot of junk in the PS2 library, but be aware that the RPG content on the other platforms isn't all there yet, and may take a while to materialize.
Thanks. I wouldn't want to play FPS on a console, so I guess I'd be in the TPS camp. I hate platform games, and when I said RPG I had PCRPG type games in mind although I realize it's a different thing on consoles. I haven't played a console style RPG in a long time but I always did like them.
Metroid Prime has re-defined how FPS's control on a console.
Im certain you will see many fps console games copy it in the near future.