• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Fantasy Character Smackdown

Status
Not open for further replies.
jonks

jonks

Lifer
http://www.suvudu.com/cagematch.html?ref=Widget_Bracket

In the spirit of March Madness these guys have bracketed some of the most storied characters in fantastic fiction and pitted them against one another for the title of...whatever.

There's some pretty amusing write-ups about the matches and hey, you can vote for your favorite.

I'm rather disappointed that Quick Ben, Anomander Rake or anyone else from Malazan didn't get a seed, but so be it, there were a limited number of slots.
 
Shens, all the modern authors won over the real heroes. I guess the older authors used concepts that were too manly for the site hosts.
 
As a WOT fanboy I don't see how anyone could beat Rand.

The way the books are written the One Power is essentially instant so the second Rand sees someone he just fires enough balefire to erase that person and every thing they have done for the last 5 seconds or so and he lives.

Even if his opponent does something that will kill Rand as long as the balefire is on the way before Rand dies he'll survive the match.
 
ProfJohn said:
As a WOT fanboy I don't see how anyone could beat Rand.

The way the books are written the One Power is essentially instant so the second Rand sees someone he just fires enough balefire to erase that person and every thing they have done for the last 5 seconds or so and he lives.

Even if his opponent does something that will kill Rand as long as the balefire is on the way before Rand dies he'll survive the match.
Click to expand...

what if someone dives out of the way? people miss balefire shots in the books. Or what if someone simply moves too fast for rand to see? humans in WoT don't have superfast reflexes. The Flash could probably dodge balefire shots and run up and just punch Rand in the face.
 
Update, the final is Rand al' Thor vs. Jaimie Lannister. Al'thor is currently ahead by a tiny margin. Votes open till Sunday.
 
is it which character is more compelling or which is more powerful?

my experience with fantasy lit has led me to believe that generally speaking, the more powerful an author writes a character, the less interesting they are (Elminster and Drizzt are the posterboys for this)
 
loki8481 said:
is it which character is more compelling or which is more powerful?

my experience with fantasy lit has led me to believe that generally speaking, the more powerful an author writes a character, the less interesting they are (Elminster and Drizzt are the posterboys for this)
Click to expand...

The rules say who you think "should" win, but that's vague isn't it? Are they asing who I think should win because I like the character more, or who do I think would win if they had an actual battle? Since Jaime is in the finals and defeated a few gods along the way, it's pretty clear that this contest is about fanbase and popularity. But that's the only way they really could have done this since Cthulu was an entry. Seriously, who's going to beat that?

And if you want a series full of "interesting" characters who also possess monumental epic power, exhibit nos. 1-10 are Steven Erikson's Malazan series.
 
jonks said:
And if you want a series full of "interesting" characters who also possess monumental epic power, exhibit nos. 1-10 are Steven Erikson's Malazan series.
Click to expand...
added to my list of "things to read if I ever finish Anna-mother fucking-Karenina" :thumbsup:
 
....and Rand wins in a ridiculously close final match.

Now back to wrapping up Joe Abercrombie's Last Argument of Kings.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top