Actually the catch is that if you used the republican's own example it would mean half of the country would be brutally uneducated. Average household income in the US is about $50,000. Let's assume you pay no taxes at all, the perfect republican society, so you keep that entire 50k. Uh oh, what's this, the average American family has 2 children. Education is about $10,000 per year for each child. Well shit. Instead of having a modest 20% effective rate of taxation ($10,000), you now pay DOUBLE that just to put your kids through school. Now on top of that you need to add in your user fee to use the roads, the fee to use the police, fire, the army, etc. Instead of having super rich people cover those things, the republicans think you should be broke ass poor and pay all of that yourself. Oh and forget about paying maybe $8k per year for state university, that shouldn't be subsidized either so the republicans want you to pay the entire $30,000 per year that it actually costs. Welcome to republican America.