I just got frustrated and perhaps over reacted. Yet I believe the way this stuff works does cause more headaches than simple physical media install and be may be more problematic. I guess I am old school and like to have product in hand. lol Then again the games are cheap with the 75% off sale and I love a great sale on a good game! I will give it a chance and see if I can master the STEAM experience. (Though I will buy physical media next time as I prefer something in hand unless I see a major sale on STEAM and a killer low price.)
I am about as old school as you can get as far as PC gaming goes. My first PC beyond the AMIGA was a 386/40. That was the day way before CD-rom and I remember floppy swapping quite well.
Let's not talk about the old STEAM and our feeling when they first came around. Let's focus on today and what STEAM is for me now.
It's a platform that works well and has all my games up to date. I have yet to have any game that I purchased on STEAM, no matter how old not work. Sometime I had to do a little tweak on how it starts, but I have forums and support that is actually helpful.
I have however had A LOT of boxes and the pictures posted reminded me of my collection. When I was in the mood to install some old games of DVD I actually did run into quite a few issues. Games by EA that didn't work anymore after patched or wouldn't even install because some hard coded path that was no longer relevant.
When I moved (oversees a few month back) I left all my game boxes behind. They took too much space, didn't do me any good anymore anyway. When I got to my location I simply logged into steam and was good to go.
Purchasing from INDY devs aside from STEAM has been my passion because I want to support them, but also a nightmare. Trying to have a log in here and there, manual update hope things work has not been fun and made me appreciate STEAM even more.
I honestly don't know what adds everyone is talking about and we have to make sure that we are talking about the same thing. It has been a while since I played Deux Ex, so I am not sure about it. But if you talk about anything that happens once you execute the game you have complain to the developer of the game.
Thinking about the original Borderlands as an example that was just a pain. But again, that was a Developer issue and has nothing what so ever to do with STEAM itself.
The only other "adds" are the things that sometimes pop up when steam starts for the first time and it usually shows only 4-5 things that are currently release or are on sale. These are actually something I want to see and it never occurred to me to think of them as obtrusive. More of a hint by a friend not something that is annoying. Especially since I can close them with one click. Obtrusive is something very different.
Making a long post short. The only reason I would think you want a box is to display it in your room or you can get it cheaper (In Germany you can actually find PC game deals still in the local retail stores). If you store them in a closet and not use them you be better of getting your things on STEAM since patching, access from anywhere and general service is MUCH better than a single box install ever was! Even with a slow DSL connection your time to play is shorter than driving to town, or ordering it online and install.
And to highlight one huge point for STEAM... pre-load is with retail out of the question!
Borderlands 2 is already on my hard drive and is ready for decryption once launch day comes around.
My collection:
http://steamcommunity.com/id/blackthunder68/games?tab=all