Who did the research and is it widely excepted by other researchers? I ask because we lead in shark attacks every year although fatalities are rare and the experts here attribute most to the shark mistaking a foot or hand for a distressed fish. Personally I think some of the so called shark attacks here are actually bluefish bites since they are worse than sharks in a feeding frenzy and the docs aren't trained to tell the difference, and I don't think Sea World sends an expert out to investigate.It seems the latest shark research info indicates sharks actually can tell the difference between human and their regular food source no matter the conditions.
Originally posted by: DAPUNISHER
Who did the research and is it widely excepted by other researchers? I ask because we lead in shark attacks every year although fatalities are rare and the experts here attribute most to the shark mistaking a foot or hand for a distressed fish. Personally I think some of the so called shark attacks here are actually bluefish bites since they are worse than sharks in a feeding frenzy and the docs aren't trained to tell the difference, and I don't think Sea World sends an expert out to investigate.It seems the latest shark research info indicates sharks actually can tell the difference between human and their regular food source no matter the conditions.
Haha!EDIT: If you are going to bodyboard, DO get the swimfins. It is pretty unpleasant paddling without them. Don't worry, if you decide to later 'stand-up' surf, you will adapt.![]()
Originally posted by: apoppin
Sandy's is very dangerous shorebreak (I preferred half-point over Sashimi rock). It is the very worst place to LEARN to surf. If you are in Hawaii, try the Wall (Waikiki). Makapuu is another place that is very fickle . . . I got it all-time (10') the day before Hurricane Iniki where it was breaking far outside in deep water. Haouli Reeves was charging!
I'd like to add a few things to that 14 point list for newbies:
15. Surf/bodyboard in front of the lifeguard tower. ASK them about conditions before you enter the water (they'll know right away you are new; dont aske me how)
16. KNOW the conditions and if possible the surf forecast. I have been caught in Hawaii with the day starting out flat and in just a few hours hitting 15' (backs - 30' from top-to-bottom). This is not so likely in Cali, however.
17. Sit and watch (observe) the ocean conditions at least 1/2 hour before you go out. You can see where other people are surfing and what the sets look like.
18. Just as in swimming, don't drink alcohol or eat a heavy meal just before you surf.
Originally posted by: Jzero
Haha!EDIT: If you are going to bodyboard, DO get the swimfins. It is pretty unpleasant paddling without them. Don't worry, if you decide to later 'stand-up' surf, you will adapt.![]()
I knew you'd have a response to that.
Well, advice is worth exactly what you pay for it, so decide for yourself.
I sat atop my kayak all last weekend watching n00b surfers who grew up bodyboarding with swimfins miss 6-footers because they simply can't paddle to save their lives. They were in the right spot, they were ready to go, they just suck at paddling--they lose their board, they can't paddle fast enough, they try to do that stupidassed one-armed paddle while they hold onto the board with the other arm, they let their feet drag in the water as they paddle, you name it.
Why have to adapt when you can learn correctly from the start? There's already enough to think about when switching from a bodyboard to a surfboard.
But that's just my opinion I guess![]()
IF you doN'T get swim fins you will have a MISERABLE experience with your bodyboard.
They're just n00bs. They're 12-15 yo kids who spent the last 5-6 years bodyboarding and using fins as a crutch. They're used to the speed you get using fins, so they start paddling WAY too late, or they just plain have no endurance for paddling out to the break and then getting enough speed to actually get on the wave. When they get lucky and actually catch a wave they have no problem getting to their feet and even making a cut--their chief stumbling block lies in their lack of paddling ability.Many of my friends have (easily) adapted to standup after years on a BB. Your "surfers" must be real klutzes.
Oh, I get it. I bodyboarded for 10 years, surfed for 4 after that and have kayaked for the last 3 years.Originally posted by: apoppin
I still think you don't get it, Jzero. Fins are not a "crutch" to bodyboarding.
You're the first person I've ever heard that little tidbit from, and I don't buy it. Perhaps SOME bodyboards are, but at the end of the day, it's the size and shape of a bodyboard that make kicking possible, and even more useful than paddling with your arms.They are an integral part of the sport - they were DESIGNED to be used with swim fins aiding in the propulsion.
Similar to the body board, it being "designed" to be paddled with your arms is solely by virtue of its size and shape--you CAN'T move it by kicking for feet.A surfboard is designed to be propelled solely by paddling.
People use them b/c they work, not because they can't do it without them.It is a bigger board with better flotation (obviously). Trying to catch waves with a bodyboard solely by paddling is a frustrating experience - especially for a newbie (it has been likened to 'paddling a cork). That's why 99.99% of bodyboarders that can afford them - use them.
Wha???Some of my friends - even skilled stand up surfers - have made a changeover to bodyboarding. It is not easy for them to learn to kick, but determination and a little skill allowed them to make a transition.
Originally posted by: Jzero
Oh, I get it. I bodyboarded for 10 years, surfed for 4 after that and have kayaked for the last 3 years.Originally posted by: apoppin
I still think you don't get it, Jzero. Fins are not a "crutch" to bodyboarding.
Only once did I bother using a pair of Churchills I borrowed from another guy just to see whether or not they were worth the price, and it didn't take me long to conclude that I could do nothing extra with them that I couldn't already do on my own.
You're the first person I've ever heard that little tidbit from, and I don't buy it. Perhaps SOME bodyboards are, but at the end of the day, it's the size and shape of a bodyboard that make kicking possible, and even more useful than paddling with your arms.They are an integral part of the sport - they were DESIGNED to be used with swim fins aiding in the propulsion.
As for it being "integral" to the sport, I disagree. People use them because they WORK, not because it's somehow built in to the game. Most olympic swimmers have switched over to those whacky paper suits, but that doesn't imply that it's an integral part of competitive swimming. What really happened is one person started to use them, and to keep up with competition, now everyone that can afford them gets them.
Similar to the body board, it being "designed" to be paddled with your arms is solely by virtue of its size and shape--you CAN'T move it by kicking for feet.A surfboard is designed to be propelled solely by paddling.
People use them b/c they work, not because they can't do it without them.It is a bigger board with better flotation (obviously). Trying to catch waves with a bodyboard solely by paddling is a frustrating experience - especially for a newbie (it has been likened to 'paddling a cork). That's why 99.99% of bodyboarders that can afford them - use them.
Or at least that's my impression.
Maybe I'm a far better swimmer than I gave myself credit for all these years.
Paddling a cork? You have got to be kidding me. The most "high quality" body board I ever owned was a friggin Morey Mach Gripper, which isn't all that great, and I have no trouble paddling out, duck-diving or catching waves.
It's just as frustrating to see a surfer throwing down his board in disgust because he can't even figure out how to ride a wave. The next day you seem him back on his bodyboard, with his swimfins on.
Wha???Some of my friends - even skilled stand up surfers - have made a changeover to bodyboarding. It is not easy for them to learn to kick, but determination and a little skill allowed them to make a transition.
Kicking a bodyboard is EASY. It's the intuitive thing to do. Hell, the thing is shaped like an oversized kickboard, why not use it like one?! If you know how to paddle, go ahead and kick.
My contention is that if you want to surf, knowing how to paddle is a Good Thing, so you may want to start learning early.
Anyway, I know from prior experience, that you can't let an opposing viewpoint just stand without a rebuttal, so I guess I'll be the better man and give up on the issue. Let LakerGod decide himself. He's heard your theory and mine. He can try both ways even. So who cares?
Originally posted by: Stark
Hey apoppin... you ever see/talk to mike stewart at pipe? That guy is seriously nuts.
Interesting...I never heard that about the BB being designed for swim fins, but I defer to you on that one. Could very well be, I suppose.The creator of the BB - Tom Morey - designed the board with swim fins in mind. If you have never used swim fins, you ARE a better paddler than you give yourself credit for. I certainly CAN bb without swimfins, but why cripple myself? Many times I alternate between paddling and kicking (you change your position on the board - forward to paddle, back to kick).
I agree with that, but I think you should bodyboard, too, just b/c it's damn funIf you are looking to stand-up surf, don't bother with a BB - just get a longboard and then - if you like - move to a thruster. Also, if you live on the East Coast - with lots of tiny windswell - a longboard is more practical and fun since you will get more waves and travel further than on a BB.
Agree with that tooWhatever you are planning, Just Do IT.Remember that you will be stiff and tired from using those muscles you don't regularly use.
Is that because you can't bodyboard without fins, or because if you don't, you'll be pretty much screwed compared to everyone else?EDIT: Bodyboarding is a pro sport. ALL of the pros use swim fins with ONE exception. I rest my case.![]()
Originally posted by: apoppin
Originally posted by: Stark
Hey apoppin... you ever see/talk to mike stewart at pipe? That guy is seriously nuts.
Yes. Out of the water his is mild-mannered and rather quiet. He is considered one of the top surfers in the world and absolutely "goes off" at huge Pipe.
Actually, I got to meet most of the top surfers/bodyboarders in the world including Gerry Lopez (I lived next door to him) and Kelly Slater (pre-Pam days). I also got to know some of the top bodyboarders pretty well including Jack Lindholm and Ben Severson. Heck, I even got to know Johnny-Boy Gomes (but that was mostly because of my job in radio) - Hawaii is really small.
Surfing is - I think - a unique sport in this regard. There is NO WAY you're gonna drive a race car as an amateur in a race with pros, or play tennis with top professionals (without BIG bucks, that is). Yet you - if you have the necessary skills - can paddle right out at Pipeline and surf next to the greatest in the Surfing world.
Is that because you can't bodyboard without fins, or because if you don't, you'll be pretty much screwed compared to everyone else?
Originally posted by: holden j caufield
you ever run into doerner, bradshaw and foo before he met his fate? The big wave guys always seem to me to have some tradition,respect etc. I'm sure those big wave chargers all probably meet at the same spots. Yeah the young local pros have shi11y attitudes those guys in socal will snake you everytime and some will have the nerve to cutback right into you after they've dropped in on you